You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Oscar makes room as toon field blooms

The Contenders 2011: Animation

Just as the flexible best pic category has Oscar waters wondering how many pics will make the cut, a similar suspense is building in the animation race.

The animated feature category is now a decade old, and in that time, the category has served up three nominees in all but two of its previous 10 years, when the number of eligible submissions was great enough to expand the ballot to five slots.

Last year nearly made the cut, until CG/live-action hybrid “Yogi Bear” was disqualified, leaving Golden Globe nominees “Despicable Me” and “Tangled” unrecognized by Oscar.

“What a shame that because we were short one film, we lost two nominees,” says Acad governor Bill Kroyer, who serves on the short films and feature animation branch.

That’s why the org decided to instate an intermediary threshold. If 12 or fewer toons qualify, the race stays small (at three noms), but if 13 or more toons receive theatrical release, the category expands to four noms. And if 16 or more open, there can be five.

It all sounds rather confusing, until one realizes that the net effect is a wider ballot designed to showcase what has become a bigger field.

“As the number of animated features has grown, we wanted the category to reflect that,” Kroyer says.

For evidence of that expansion, look no further than the fact that 2011 brought new work from nearly all the top toon outfits: Blue Sky (“Rio”), Pixar (“Cars 2”), DreamWorks Animation (both “Puss in Boots” and “Kung Fu Panda 2”), Walt Disney Animation (“Winnie the Pooh”), Sony Pictures Animation (“The Smurfs”), Aardman (“Arthur Christmas,” made in conjunction with Sony), Animal Logic (“Happy Feet Two”), Rhythm & Hues (“Alvin and the Chipmunks: Chipwrecked”) and newcomer ILM (for whom “Rango” was its first inhouse animated feature).

Count foreign and indie pics, and there were 18 films in all, suggesting a strong potential for five slots.

This is the point where prognosticators start to examine which films might be disqualified the way “Yogi Bear” was last year. At risk, “The Smurfs” and “Alvin” rely heavily on live-action footage, foreign submissions “Alois nebel” and “Chico & Rita” use a fair amount of rotoscoping (a technique akin to tracing live-action footage), and “Mars Needs Moms,” “The Adventures of Tintin” and “Happy Feet Two” blend motion-capture with the keyframe style the Academy prefers.

“We’re trying to preserve the animation process as a performance art, not a visual effects art,” says Kroyer, whose own CV involves both “traditional” animation and performance-capture experience.

That said, the Academy is generous in its definition: “Every artist from Picasso to Vermeer has used live models, but you look at a Picasso and think, ‘That’s real art,’ and you look at a Vermeer and say, ‘Man, he could have taken a photograph and achieved the same effect,’?” notes Kroyer.

In other words, the Academy aims to recognize performances created by animators, not flesh-and-blood actors. To make that determination, the Acad relies on “the word of the filmmaker,” Kroyer says. Hence, in 2009, James Cameron insisted his cast was responsible for the perfs in “Avatar,” so the Acad overlooked it. This year, since Spielberg believes animators were integral to “Tintin,” that film should be a formidable contender in the toon race.

2011 Toon Submissions

  • “The Adventures of Tintin”

  • “Alois nebel”

  • “Alvin and the Chipmunks: Chipwrecked”

  • “Arthur Christmas”

  • “Cars 2”

  • “A Cat in Paris”

  • “Chico & Rita”

  • “Gnomeo & Juliet”

  • “Happy Feet Two”

  • “Hoodwinked Too! Hood vs. Evil”

  • “Kung Fu Panda 2”

  • “Mars Needs Moms”

  • “Puss in Boots”

  • “Rango”

  • “Rio”

  • “The Smurfs”

  • “Winnie the Pooh”

  • “Wrinkles”

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Alexander Skarsgard in the front rowGiorgio

    Film News Roundup: Alexander Skarsgard Joins 'Passing' With Tessa Thompson

    In today’s film news roundup, Taryn Manning, Shane West and Alexander Skarsgård have new roles, and Warner Bros. unveils a modernized logo. CASTINGS Alexander Skarsgård has signed on to join Tessa Thompson, Ruth Negga and André Holland in “Passing.” The film marks Rebecca Hall’s directorial debut and is based on a screenplay that Hall adapted [...]

  • Spike Lee

    Spike Lee to Direct Hip-Hop Love Story 'Prince of Cats'

    Spike Lee will direct a big-screen version of the hip-hop love story “Prince of Cats,” based on Ron Wimberly’s graphic novel. Legendary has been developing the project with Janet and Kate Zucker of Zucker Productions. Lee, who won the Academy Award for adapted screenplay for “BlacKkKlansman,” will also re-write the “Prince of Cats” script with [...]

  • DOLEMITE IS MY NAME!, 2019, DOL_Unit_06284.RAF

    'Dolemite Is My Name' Writer Larry Karaszewski Recalls 10-Year Journey to Make Rudy Ray Moore Biopic

    “Harriet” writer-director Kasi Lemmons was in a reflective mood at Tuesday night’s “Behind the Scene” event at the Formosa Cafe in West Hollywood, sponsored by the Writers Guild of America West. The biopic, starring Cynthia Erivo as slave-turned-abolitionist Harriet Tubman, has been receiving buzz since its premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival. It’s Lemmons’ [...]

  • Writers vs Agents Packaging War WGA

    Abrams Artists Agency Signs Writers Guild Deal

    In a major triumph for the Writers Guild of America, the Abrams Artists Agency has signed the WGA’s Code of Conduct, allowing the agency to return to representing WGA members again. Chairman Adam Bold made the announcement Wednesday, saying that the agency wants to put its clients back to work. He also noted WGA West [...]

  • Taika Waititi and Roman Griffin Davis

    Holocaust Experts Debate 'Jojo Rabbit' at Museum of Tolerance Screening

    With its comedic, cartoonish portrayal of Nazis, Taika Waititi’s satirical Hitler youth tale “Jojo Rabbit” has polarized critics and audiences alike. And that division continued to be stirred at Tuesday night’s screening of the film at the Museum of Tolerance in Los Angeles, where Liebe Geft, director of the museum, moderated a heated panel discussion [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content