You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Judge OKs release of ‘Hangover 2’

Tattoo artist can still press case of copyright infringement

Warner Bros.’ release of “The Hangover Part II” can go forward as planned on Thursday, after a federal judge rejected an effort to block its release by a St. Louis artist who claims that a facial tattoo worn by Ed Helms infringes on a copyright for one he created for Mike Tyson.

But U.S. District Judge Catherine D. Perry signaled that artist S. Victor Whitmill “has a strong likelihood of success” of prevailing in his copyright infringement claim — and she’s allowing the case to go forward on an expedited schedule.

She rejected Whitmill’s request for a preliminary injunction in part because the studio stands to lose more than $100 million and that it would disrupt related businesses, like exhibitors and others involved in the distribution chain.

“The public interest does favor protecting the thousands of other business people in the country as well as Warner Brothers, and not causing those nonparties to lose money, and I think it would be significant, and I think it would be disruptive,” she said, according to a transcript of her remarks at a Tuesday hearing.

Yet Perry called “most” of the studio’s arguments “just silly.”

“Of course tattoos can be copyrighted. I don’t think there is any reasonable dispute about that,” she said, noting that Whitmill and Tyson, who got the tattoo in 2003, signed a document saying that Whitmill kept the rights.

She also rejected Warner Bros.’s arguments that Helms’ tattoo was a parody, which courts have exempted from infringement claims.

“This was an exact copy,” she said. “It’s not a parody.”

The image of Helms wearing the tattoo appears not just in the movie but in marketing materials, as well as in a tie-in campaign with 7-Eleven.

Whitmill’s legal team, Michael Kahn, Geoffrey Gerber and Peter Salsich from Brickhouse Law Group in St. Louis, argued that the issue was not the way that Tyson has appeared in “Hangover” movies and other projects — for which Whitmill raised no objection — but that its design was replicated on another character, played by Helms.

Tyson also appears in the film, which is a critical point for Warner Bros. as it argues that it was given an “implied license” to use the tattoo. Tyson agreed to let the studio use his likeness, and raised no objection when it was used on Helms, said the studio’s counsel, Frederick J. Sperling of Schiff Hardin in Chicago. It’s part of the schtick, as when Tyson warns, “You better get that tattoo off your face.”

Warner Bros. has a lot at stake. That was evident in the hearing on Monday, in which WB’s heads of marketing and distribution, Sue Kroll and Dan Fellman, were among those testifying. Kroll told the court that the studio has an $81 million media marketing budget for the movie, with $77 million spent as of last Friday. With tracking showing the movie doing a similar level of “Twilight,” “The Dark Knight” and “Shrek,” Fellman said that he expects the sequel to gross more than $100 million in its opening weekend, or more than double that of the original.

“We are very gratified by the court’s decision which will allow the highly anticipated film, ‘The Hangover 2’ to be released on schedule this week around the world,” the studio said in a statement. “Plaintiff’s failed attempt to enjoin ‘H2’ in order to try and extract a massive settlement payment from Warner Bros. was highly inappropriate and unwarranted.” Sperling pressed Whitmill on whether he was aware that his attorney had “demanded $30 million” to settle the claim, before Kahn objected and Perry sustained it. Kahn said that Sperling had “spent a week” trying to get them to make a settlement offer, and that the figure was a “calculation of the range of his client’s exposure.”

More Film

  • FX's 'Snowfall' Panel TCA Winter Press

    John Singleton Hospitalized After Suffering Stroke

    UPDATED with statements from John Singleton’s family and FX Networks John Singleton, the Oscar nominated director and writer of “Boyz N’ the Hood,” has suffered a stroke. Sources confirm to Variety that Singleton checked himself into the hospital earlier this week after experiencing pain in his leg. The stroke has been characterized by doctors as [...]

  • 'Curse of La Llorona' Leads Slow

    'Curse of La Llorona' Leads Slow Easter Weekend at the Box Office

    New Line’s horror pic “The Curse of La Llorona” will summon a solid $25 million debut at the domestic box office, leading a quiet Easter weekend before Marvel’s “Avengers: Endgame” hits theaters on April 26. The James Wan-produced “La Llorona,” playing in 3,372 theaters, was a hit with hispanic audiences, who accounted for nearly 50% [...]

  • Jim Jarmusch in 'Carmine Street Guitars'

    Film Review: 'Carmine Street Guitars'

    “Carmine Street Guitars” is a one-of-a-kind documentary that exudes a gentle, homespun magic. It’s a no-fuss, 80-minute-long portrait of Rick Kelly, who builds and sells custom guitars out of a modest storefront on Carmine Street in New York’s Greenwich Village, and the film touches on obsessions that have been popping up, like fragrant weeds, in [...]

  • Missing Link Laika Studios

    ‘Missing Link’ Again Tops Studios’ TV Ad Spending

    In this week’s edition of the Variety Movie Commercial Tracker, powered by the TV ad measurement and attribution company iSpot.tv, Annapurna Pictures claims the top spot in spending for the second week in a row with “Missing Link.” Ads placed for the animated film had an estimated media value of $5.91 million through Sunday for [...]

  • Little Woods

    Film Review: 'Little Woods'

    So much of the recent political debate has focused on the United States’ southern border, and on the threat of illegal drugs and criminals filtering up through Mexico. But what of the north, where Americans traffic opiates and prescription pills from Canada across a border that runs nearly three times as long? “Little Woods” opens [...]

  • Beyonce's Netflix Deal Worth a Whopping

    Beyonce's Netflix Deal Worth a Whopping $60 Million (EXCLUSIVE)

    Netflix has become a destination for television visionaries like Shonda Rhimes and Ryan Murphy, with deals worth $100 million and $250 million, respectively, and top comedians like Chris Rock and Dave Chappelle ($40 million and $60 million, respectively). The streaming giant, which just announced it’s added nearly 10 million subscribers in Q1, is honing in [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content