You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Reviews migrate from TV to Web

Eye on the Oscars: Crix Picks

When Roger Ebert announced last week that he had reluctantly put his TV series “Ebert Presents at the Movies” on hiatus, it may have marked the end of a genre that he helped create more than 35 years ago: the televised film-critic debate.

“It’s tough. Our problem was not viewers but financing,” Ebert explains in an email. Outside of a $25,000 grant, Ebert bankrolled the show himself.

“Our ratings pleased public television, and we would still be on the air had we found financing,” he adds, “but in this economy public television is suffering from a shortage of underwriting. I believe the time is here for PBS to consider more permissive guidelines for sponsorship.”

In 1975, Ebert, the Pulitzer Prize-winning film critic of the Chicago Sun-Times, and his cross-town rival Gene Siskel, of the Chicago Tribune, created “Sneak Previews” for a local TV station. It moved to PBS and quickly became one of its most popular series.

Ebert and Siskel left that show in 1983 to host a series of syndicated shows, usually employing the phrase “At the Movies” in the title. Siskel died in 1999, and when Ebert was diagnosed with thyroid cancer in 2006, he remained a producer on the series, which eventually ended up pairing Richard Roeper and the Chicago Tribune’s Michael Phillips in the balcony.

Ebert left when the studio sought a younger audience with the inexperienced critic Ben Lyons (whom Ebert deemed “a disaster”). The following year, producers reversed course and brought back Phillips, alongside the New York Times’ A.O. Scott. The show ceased production in 2010.

“We had favorable ratings in markets where we had favorable timeslots,” Phillips says. “Markets (with) early-morning slots weren’t doing us any favors. I think people assumed we were selling Gold Bond body powder.”

Few have attempted to replicate Siskel and Ebert’s entertaining bickering chemistry. PBS continued “Sneak Previews” to diminishing returns for another decade. In 2000, FX introduced the short-lived “The New Movie Show,” featuring a critics’ roundtable discussing movies and trends.

The proliferation of online movie sites may have damaged the genre, though Ebert points out, “Our ratings on public TV dwarfed the audiences for netcasts.”

Still, says AP film critic Christy Lemire, who appears on “Ebert Presents” and the vlog “What the Flick?,” “People want what they want and they want it now. Why wait until 6 p.m. on a Sunday to watch my show when you can go online? Hopefully, (‘Ebert Presents’) provides another level of analysis.

“There are pros and cons” to TV and vlogs, she adds. “What’s fun about ‘What the Flick?’ is we have a little more breathing room. It’s like watching friends having a conversation, which is exactly what it is. The benefit of being on TV is, you have to get to your points succinctly and make them count. I’d like to think we’re in a world where both shows are not mutually exclusive.”

“It’s a weird period if you’re a thoughtful film critic — — there’s very little perspective about movies before 1975, particularly from people giving away their reviews for free online,” says Alonso Duralde, who appears with Lemire on “What the Flick?” He worries that the shelf-life of the genre may be ending. “If Ebert can’t do it, it’s a little nerve-wracking for anyone else taking a stab at it.”

Phillips isn’t as pessimistic: “You can yak all you want about the death of film criticism, but it’s not going away any more than the film industry is vanishing. General audiences and cinephiles alike are always looking for an honest broker in the opinion game. There’s a way to get intelligent talk about the movies back into the national conversation. You just need the right people plus a format that works, and doesn’t feel busy or gimmicky.”

Chatter splatter | Regional critics flex muscles

in Oscar race | Reviews migrate from TV to Web

More Scene

  • Chinonye Chukwu Clemency

    Chinonye Chukwu on Golden Globes of Female Directors Shutout

    “Clemency” writer-director Chinonye Chukwu is weighing in on the HFPA’s failure to nominated a female director for the 2020 Golden Globes. “It’s part of the systemic oppressions that we’re all apart of and that’s internalized in many,” Chukwu told Variety in response to Monday morning’s announcement. “We need to get people in positions of power who [...]

  • Nicole Kidman, Margot Robbie, Charlize Theron

    Charlize Theron, Margot Robbie on the Power of 'Bombshell'

    Charlize Theron, Nicole Kidman and Margot Robbie make for a powerful trio on-screen. With their latest film “Bombshell,” the award-winning actors recognize the potential for the film to make real social change off-screen. “The response to the film has been incredible. I was hoping that it would be impactful in that way,” Robbie told Variety [...]

  • Awkwafina Jumanji Next Level Premiere

    'The Farewell's' Awkwafina on Her First Golden Globe Nomination, Female Director Snubs

    Awkwafina just might’ve had her best Monday ever. Shortly after 5 a.m., the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. announced that she’d earned her first Golden Globe nomination (as best actress in a motion picture – musical or comedy) for her performance in “The Farewell.” But she didn’t have a ton of time to celebrate, since she [...]

  • United States Attorney for the Southern

    'Jeffrey Epstein Didn’t Kill Himself' Is Peak Meme After Art Basel Prank 

    From Bye, Felicia to The Dress, memes have provided the ideal discursive forum for our ever dwindling attention spans. On this side of the century, most memes have been byte-sized digital novelties that fizzle away without manifesting in the meatspace. But as the gap between URL and IRL draws closer, memes are spilling into real [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content