×

Sound editing: Always make dramatic sense

Eye on the Oscars: Vfx, Sound & Editing - Sound Editing

Sound editors essentially choose the aural palette that create the soundscape of a film, often finding sounds make “dramatic sense” (as sound guru Randy Thom explains it) even if they don’t represent precisely what’s seen on screen.

In order to create emotionally resonant sounds for the chimp characters in “Rise of the Planet of the Apes,” Chuck Michael and the sound team worked with recordings of noises made both by actors and by chimps. Ape sounds were recorded at Chimp Haven in Louisiana, then layered with actors’ vocals.

“There’s an emotional range that only an actor can convey, but there’s also an authenticity that comes from these being the real sounds made by chimps,” Michael says.

In “Cars 2” making dramatic sense meant not always using the exact sound made by the particular make or model of car seen in the film. Originally helmer John Lasseter wanted that kind of authenticity, but that changed.

Supervising sound editor Tom Myers says, “You need something that will resonate with the audience emotionally.”

“Fast Five” also needed car and crash sounds that would tell the action story in a way that put the audience in the center of the action. Even though the audience is looking at 1970 Dodge Charger for a large part of the movie, chances are they’re hearing a group of sounds developed by a crew over time, says the film’s supervising sound editor Peter Brown.

“These films are very creative in finding new ways to push or abuse the cars,” Brown says laughing. “So we have to find ways to articulate specific sounds that match with the action or the abuse so it makes it believable and fun for people watching.”

Such films as “Green Lantern” and “Transformers 3” also traffic in the kinds of crashing and booming noises you might find in these car-centric projects, but they’ve got a different challenge altogether — find sounds that make things that may not exist at all completely believable.

Though it might seem an easier task to match a sound to an imaginary being Optimus Prime or a to the sounds made when a character with superhuman powers tears apart a sidewalk or train, there’s still a kind of internal logic that must be followed. Auds’ ears can detect a fake just as quickly as the eye though they might not immediately be aware of what’s wrong.

Says Greg P. Russell, sound re-recording mixer on “Transformers 3”: “Even though (Optimus Prime) has never walked down the street, there’s a dramatic logic to what it would sound like if he did. His weight and size would make him sound a certain way and everyone in the audience has an internal sense of how that should sound to them. You have to follow that logic or there will be this sense that something is wrong.”

Karen Baker Landers, a supervising sound editor on “Green Lantern,” sums it up thusly: “People who go to movies, especially movies with superheroes, have heard a lot of great sound editing and mixing. And you’re also trying to get them to connect with the story, not just believe a character is a superhero.”

Eye on the Oscars: Vfx, Sound & Editing
Thesps up f/x respect | Longtime teams keep work fresh | Randy’s Rules for top sound | Sound editing: Always make dramatic sense | Sound Mixing: Making it all feel real | Digital tools add quality, cut costs

Popular on Variety

More Digital

  • Illustration of the video streaming company

    Video Streaming to TVs Soared 85% in U.S. in First Three Weeks of March, Nielsen Says

    During the coronavirus pandemic, Americans are staying home — and, as you would expect, they’re streaming more than ever. U.S. consumers’ viewing of streaming has continued to increase through March. Over the first three weeks of March 2020, the total estimated number of minutes streamed to the TV was 400 billion, up 85% compared with [...]

  • HOOQ Demise Damages The Business Case

    Hooq May Have Fallen But a Business Case for Southeast Asian Streamers Endures

    With coronavirus lockdowns across the region causing a spike in stay-at-home viewing, Friday’s news that Southeast Asian video streamer Hooq is to close within a matter of days came as a shock to its friends and competitors alike. Compared with its regional rivals, Hooq had the most blue-chip backers in Singaporean telecoms giant Singtel, WarnerMedia [...]

  • U.K. Freelancers

    U.K. Government Faces Pressure From Industry on Economic Measures for Freelancers

    The U.K. government is facing increasing pressure from the creative industries after it emerged that economic measures set out for the self-employed last week by Chancellor of the Exchequer Rishi Sunak have yawning gaps in them. The measures may have come as a welcome move for many creative industries workers, but not all are eligible [...]

  • Howard Stern'America's Got Talent' Post-Show, New

    Howard Stern Announces SiriusXM Premier Will Be Free Through May 15

    Howard Stern announced Tuesday that SiriusXM Premier will be free through May 15 as a courtesy to those staying home in an effort to stop the spread of coronavirus. For the next month and a half, listeners will have access to more than 300 ad-free channels, including the Howard Stern Show. Sirius XM is also [...]

  • Lenny Abrahamson Series 'Normal People' Sets

    Oscar Nominee Lenny Abrahamson's 'Normal People' Sets BBC, Hulu Dates

    “Normal People,” a BBC and Hulu 12-part drama, will bow as a boxset on BBC Three in the U.K. on April 26, and will be released in the U.S. on April 29, it was revealed Tuesday. It will also air on BBC One, and RTE in Ireland, dates for which are yet to be confirmed. [...]

  • NewFronts 2020

    NewFronts 2020 Digital Marketing Series Postponed to June

    The 2020 Digital Content NewFronts are moving about two months later as live-streamed virtual presentations, with organizers citing the need for more time for participants to prep. Previously, the annual NewFronts had been scheduled for April 27-May 6 at various venues in New York City — but with the COVID-19 pandemic it became clear earlier [...]

  • Andrew Yang

    Andrew Yang Sets Launch of Issues-Oriented Podcast 'Yang Speaks' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Andrew Yang bowed out of the U.S. presidential race, but the businessman-turned-politico wants to keep his policy agenda on the national media stage. Less than two months after ending his 2020 presidential campaign, he’s set plans to launch a new podcast, “Yang Speaks,” in partnership with podcast studio and network Cadence13, Variety has learned. The [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content