You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Google stands firm on Viacom appeal

Internet company maintains it does not violate copyright law

Google is pushing back at Viacom’s effort to reverse a judge’s decision last year that YouTube was well within the “safe harbor” provisions of copyright law and not liable for thousands of copyrighted clips from TV shows and movies posted to the site.

Viacom, which sued Google and YouTube in a $1 billion copyright infringement suit, appealed U.S. District Judge Louis Stanton’s June decision, arguing that if his opinion stands, it would “radically transform” the copyright system and act as an invitation for rampant infringement across the Internet. Studios and some guild leaders expressed dismay at the judge’s decision, as it placed the burden of identifying infringing material on the copyright owner rather than the user-generated site.

Google argues that when YouTube promptly took down tens of thousands of videos after Viacom gave it notice, YouTube was within provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act.

“Plaintiffs have not identified a single clip-in-suit that YouTube knew was infringing but failed to promptly take down,” Google said in its brief to the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals. “Instead, plaintiffs offer various theories about generalized awareness that unidentified infringing material may be somewhere on YouTube should be disqualifying.”

Google acquired YouTube in 2006, and Viacom filed its suit against both companies in 2007.

In a statement in response to Google’s brief, Viacom said that under the 1998 Copyright Act, “Content owners and systems operators share responsibility for the protection of copyrighted content online. It was never intended to absolve companies like YouTube from liability for building a business by deliberately infringing others’ creative works. We look forward to the review of this case by the court of appeals and are confident that it will vindicate the rights of content creators.”

More TV

  • Dignity

    Writer-Producer Andreas Gutzeit on German-Chile Co-Production ‘Dignity’

    Based on true events, “Dignity,” a Chile-Germany co-production from co-creators Maria Elena Wood and Patricio Pereira, head writer-producer Andreas Gutzeit and director Julio Jorquera, has been a hit since its launch as the first original series from German digital platform Joyn, a streaming service run jointly by Discovery and German media giant ProSiebenSat. The series is [...]

  • Conecta FICTION 4

    Conecta Fiction Announces United States as 2020 ‘Focus America’ Invitee

    Spain’s Conecta Fiction, an increasingly important TV market focused on trans-Atlantic cooperation and co-production, will host it’s fourth edition this June 22-25, and have announced the United States as this year’s Focus America country. With particular focus being placed on the U.S. Hispanic market, the event returns for the second year to Pamplona, where it [...]

  • Taskmaster - Series 9Picture shows: Taskmaster

    Originals, Streaming Drive 4% Growth in Viewing at British TV Network UKTV

    British broadcast network UKTV claimed a 4% rise in viewing last year, fueled by a spate of original programming and rapid growth for its on-demand service UKTV Play. The 4% figure refers to an increase in “Share of Commercial Impacts,” a metric broadcasters employ to quantify viewing in the digital era for their advertisers, where [...]

  • Baby Yoda The Mandalorian

    Disney Plus Set for Earlier Launch in U.K. & Western Europe

    The Walt Disney Co. has set March 24 as the new launch date for Disney Plus in the U.K. and other key markets across Western Europe. With the roll-out previously set for March 31, the streaming service will now be available a week earlier in the U.K., Ireland, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Austria and Switzerland. Pricing [...]

  • 9-1-1: LONE STAR: L-R: Rob Lowe

    TV Ratings: '9-1-1: Lone Star' Starts Strong Behind NFC Championship Game

    “9-1-1 Lone Star” got off to a flaming start for Fox in the TV ratings behind the NFC Championship game. The Rob Lowe-fronted series premiere to a 3.2 rating among adults 18-49 and 11.5 million viewers in the time zone-adjusted ratings, which represents easily the best scripted debut of the 2019-2020 season. “Lone Star” had [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content