Anatomy of a snub: How ‘Breaking Bad’ got shut out of the writing noms

BBs3ep312_Day3_Cam-B2-058

How has “Breaking Bad,” which is no secret to TV Academy voters — having earned seven Emmy noms this year, including top drama and lead and supporting actor — never received a writing nomination?

The “Mad Men” effect is substantial — last year, for example, the Matthew Weiner series took four of the final slots, before settling for two this year. Academy voters also save at least one spot for “Lost,” which was nominated in the category today for the fifth time in six years.

After that, it gets more complicated — with the simplest explanation being that “Bad” got caught in the switches (like a drug deal gone awry, if you will). Emmy did acknowledge a critically acclaimed, little-seen show waiting its turn for its first drama writing nod, but that was “Friday Night Lights.” And Emmy did get on board with a show whose quality transcended expectations, but that was “The Good Wife.”

Still, for those of us whose jaws drop with almost every episode of “Breaking Bad,” it’s a little shocking to see that the Academy has never once recognized the skein’s scribes — especially with “Bad” receiving its second series nomination in a row. In a writing-driven medium like television, it’s analogous to a film getting noms for best picture but not director.

Someone has to get left out, and “Bad,” of course, was hardly the only series to feel shot down this year. For example, “The Big Bang Theory” was once again a surprise comedy series and writing omission, while “Sons of Anarchy” got a big fat zero in every category, a circumstance that showrunner Kurt Sutter reacted to with his typically testy grace.

More TV

  • The Bold Type Meghann Fahy

    'The Bold Type' Boss and Star on 'Normalizing Conversations About Gun Control'

    How has “Breaking Bad,” which is no secret to TV Academy voters — having earned seven Emmy noms this year, including top drama and lead and supporting actor — never received a writing nomination? The “Mad Men” effect is substantial — last year, for example, the Matthew Weiner series took four of the final slots, […]

  • Streaming Subscribers Overtake Pay-TV Customers for

    Streaming Subscribers Overtake Pay-TV Customers for First Time in the U.K.

    How has “Breaking Bad,” which is no secret to TV Academy voters — having earned seven Emmy noms this year, including top drama and lead and supporting actor — never received a writing nomination? The “Mad Men” effect is substantial — last year, for example, the Matthew Weiner series took four of the final slots, […]

  • The Fast and the Furious

    TV News Roundup: Paramount Network Sets Paul Walker Documentary Premiere Date

    How has “Breaking Bad,” which is no secret to TV Academy voters — having earned seven Emmy noms this year, including top drama and lead and supporting actor — never received a writing nomination? The “Mad Men” effect is substantial — last year, for example, the Matthew Weiner series took four of the final slots, […]

  • Elena Kampouris Sacred Lies Facebook Watch

    TV Review: 'Sacred Lies' on Facebook Watch

    How has “Breaking Bad,” which is no secret to TV Academy voters — having earned seven Emmy noms this year, including top drama and lead and supporting actor — never received a writing nomination? The “Mad Men” effect is substantial — last year, for example, the Matthew Weiner series took four of the final slots, […]

  • 2018 FIFA World Cup

    World Cup Final U.S. Ratings Fall From 2014

    How has “Breaking Bad,” which is no secret to TV Academy voters — having earned seven Emmy noms this year, including top drama and lead and supporting actor — never received a writing nomination? The “Mad Men” effect is substantial — last year, for example, the Matthew Weiner series took four of the final slots, […]

  • Tales From The Loop

    Amazon Orders Sci-Fi Series 'Tales From the Loop'

    How has “Breaking Bad,” which is no secret to TV Academy voters — having earned seven Emmy noms this year, including top drama and lead and supporting actor — never received a writing nomination? The “Mad Men” effect is substantial — last year, for example, the Matthew Weiner series took four of the final slots, […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content