You will be redirected back to your article in seconds


All of Jimmy Smits' considerable charisma can't come close to making a convincing case for "Outlaw."

Cyrus Garza - Jimmy Smits Al Druzinsky - David Ramsey Lucinda - Carly Pope Eddie Franks - Jesse Bradford Meretta Stockman - Ellen Woglom

All of Jimmy Smits’ considerable charisma can’t come close to making a convincing case for “Outlaw,” a jaw-droppingly simple-minded legal procedural that’s improbable on most every level. Conservatives, for once, will be right to express indignation about the show’s ham-fisted politics; others will have their own ideology-free but equally valid reasons to complain. The show’s Friday timeslot (following a midweek preview) carries limited expectations, but it will be a great surprise if NBC’s motion isn’t quickly rejected for a decided lack of appeal.

Inasmuch as the show comes from Conan O’Brien’s production company, Conaco, a conspiracy theorist might conclude leaving “Outlaw” behind represents his final F-you to the network — a behind-the-scenes footnote, frankly, more interesting than anything in the actual show.

Smits plays Cyrus Garza, a staunchly conservative Supreme Court justice with various personal vices, among them gambling and womanizing. (There are several wince-inducing moments, but the worst might be when he’s confronted by a liberal protester outside the court and is shown in the next scene reclining after an implied tryst with her. Now there’s a way to silence your critics.)

Ah, but then comes the epiphany — the case of a wrongly convicted man on death row. So Garza removes his robe for a more principled cause and decides to become a champion for the oppressed, resigning from the court and quickly assembling a crack team of young attorneys bought off the rack from the big-box store that wholesales stock TV characters. By that measure, the worst of the bunch is Carly Pope as his “sassy” (their word, not mine) investigator.

The conservative judge thus becomes a crusading lawyer, spouting platitudes (every actor loves courtroom speeches) that sound lifted from an American Civil Liberties Union brochure. Not to say this is farfetched, but let’s hope nobody is holding their breath for similar left-leaning awakenings by Justices Scalia or Thomas.

In what passes for a serialized thread, Garza’s decision also appears to have riled the Powers That Be, with a senator issuing vague threats about not upsetting the order of things, or some such nonsense.

Granted, “Outlaw” will theoretically be able to settle down into a standard legal procedural once the tortured setup is exhausted, in much the way CBS employed a provocative ripped-from-the-headlines concept to establish “The Good Wife.” Based on the pilot, though, there’s scant cause to anticipate evolving into that mode will strengthen the argument for watching.

In short, case dismissed.


NBC, Wed. Sept. 15, 10 p.m.

Production: Filmed in Philadelphia, Washington, D.C., and Atlantic City by Conaco Prods. in association with Universal Media Studios. Executive producers, John Eisendrath, David Kissinger, Richard Schwartz; co-executive producers, Jimmy Smits, Marcos Siega, Amanda Green, Luke Reiter, Peter Elkoff; producer, Caroline James; director, Terry George; writer, Eisendrath.

Crew: Camera, Michael Bonvillain; production designer, Kalina Ivanov; editors, Marty Nicholson, Lauren Schaffer; music, James Levine; casting, Joseph Middleton, Deanna Brigidi-Stewart. 60 MIN.

Cast: Cyrus Garza - Jimmy Smits Al Druzinsky - David Ramsey Lucinda - Carly Pope Eddie Franks - Jesse Bradford Meretta Stockman - Ellen WoglomWith: Melora Hardin.

More Scene

  • Marianne Rendon, Matt Smith, Ondi Timoner

    Robert Mapplethorpe Biopic Team Talks 'Fast and Furious' Filming

    Thursday night’s New York premiere of the Matt Smith-led biopic “Mapplethorpe” took place at Cinépolis Chelsea, just steps from the Chelsea Hotel where the late photographer Robert Mapplethorpe once lived — but director Ondi Timoner had no sense of that legacy when she first encountered him in a very different context. “When I was ten [...]

  • Producer Mel Jones poses at the

    'Dear White People' Producer Talks Hollywood's 'Black Tax'

    “Dear White People” and “Leimert Park” executive producer Mel Jones is extremely familiar with growing up and watching “white men in all types of roles and never [seeing] ourselves as a part of those narratives.” Now, there may be some more opportunities for writers of color to tell their own stories, but, she notes, there [...]

  • Rebel Wilson Isn't It Romantic

    Rebel Wilson on Twitter Gaffe: 'It Was Purely to Lift My Fellow Plus-Size Women Up'

    “I obviously misspoke in that situation,” Rebel Wilson told Variety at the premiere of her latest film “Isn’t It Romantic” Monday, acknowledging the gaffe in which she claimed to be the first-ever plus-sized woman to star in a romantic comedy during an October appearance on “Ellen.” Following the comment, Wilson was met with criticism from Twitter [...]


    How Lena Waithe Convinced Halle Berry to Team Up for 'Boomerang' TV Series

    Halle Berry wasn’t immediately sold on the idea of a “Boomerang” reboot. The 1992 romantic comedy, which starred Berry, Eddie Murphy, and Robin Givens, told the tale of cocky ad executive and insatiable ladies’ man Marcus (Murphy) who meets his match in his new boss Jacqueline (Givens) — an exec who treats him the same [...]

  • Rebel Wilson and Miley Cyrus'Isn't it

    Why Liam Hemsworth Wasn't at His 'Isn't It Romantic' Premiere, but Wife Miley Cyrus Was

    Liam Hemsworth had every intention of bringing his wife, Miley Cyrus, to Monday’s premiere of his new romantic comedy “Isn’t It Romantic.” However, the Aussie actor was forced to skip the evening because of some “health things.” That didn’t stop Cyrus from attended the red carpet shindig at the Theater at the Ace Hotel in downtown [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content