You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

The Nutcracker in 3D

Owes as much to Art Spiegelman's "Maus" as it does to Tchaikovsky.

Mary- Elle Fanning Uncle Albert- Nathan Lane The Rat Queen- Frances de la Tour The Rat King- John Turturro Father- Richard E. Grant Mother/Snow Fairy- Yulia Visotskaya Max- Aaron Michael Drozin The Prince- Charlie Rowe The Nutcracker- Shirley Henderson

Seemingly predicated on the idea that nothing says “the holidays” quite like the Holocaust, “The Nutcracker in 3D” owes as much to Art Spiegelman’s “Maus” as it does to Tchaikovsky. Like the traditional ballet, Andrei Konchalovsky’s musical extravaganza has its share of tinsel and snowflakes and draws from E.T.A. Hoffman’s “The Nutcracker and the Mouse King” — except here, the mice are Nazified rats, herding the people of old Vienna into labor camps. Audience bewilderment could turn to anger, given the dire contrast between the story’s seasonal associations and what Konchalovsky has fashioned from it, which is assuredly not “Merry Christmas.”

Music fans will have their own complaints: Tchaikovsky’s score, which ranks among the most beloved in the classical repertoire, has been modified into very conventional songs by Disney house lyricist Tim Rice and Konchalovsky collaborator Edward Artemiev. (They don’t stop at “The Nutcracker,” either: When the Prince, played by Charlie Rowe, sings “Life Begins Again,” auds will hear a melodic line snatched from Tchaikovsky’s Piano Concerto No. 1.) The familiarity of the music may actually be a disadvantage; the ear wants the melodies to conform to one’s memory of them, but instead they’ve been tortured into compliance with the needs of a standard movie musical.

It’s Christmas in 1920s Vienna   — someone early on acknowledges Sigmund Freud gliding by on ice skates — and Mary (Elle Fanning) is bright-eyed and expectant. Unhappy that her parents (Richard E. Grant, Yulia Visotskaya) are going out for the evening, she’s nevertheless thrilled that she and brother Max (Aaron Michael Drozin) will be babysat by their Uncle Albert — Einstein, naturally (Konchalovksy having suspended the time-space continuum). As played by Nathan Lane, Albert is a schnitzel-accented Santa Claus who brings gifts for Max and Mary, including what will become Mary’s most cherished possession — a mechanical wooden nutcracker (with the voice of Shirley Henderson).

So far so good, until it soon becomes evident the Nutcracker is involved in a battle for world domination against the Rat King (John Turturro, wearing a platinum wig he might have borrowed from Phil Spector), who is enslaving the population with his Rat Queen mother (Frances de la Tour). Turturro’s performance is too over-the-top to be taken seriously, although there are some transformation scenes in which his teeth take on nightmarish proportions that could frighten tykes. Add to this the slave-labor elements and “Metropolis”-inspired imagery, and it’s all a lot less First Noel than Third Reich.

In Spiegelman’s graphic novel, the Nazis were cats, the Jews were mice and the rats were … rats. Even still, the film’s anthropomorphic aspects seem strongly reminiscent of those in “Maus,” which, like the original “Nutcracker,” was a fairy tale with a tragic foundation. But “The Nutcracker in 3D” is too much of a burlesque to create many resounding moral echoes.

Konchalovsky, the veteran Russian helmer whose films have ranged from “Runaway Train” to “Tango and Cash” (he also co-wrote “Andrei Rublev” with Andrei Tarkovsky) has been at this project for several years, and it’s clear enough that the film has been on the shelf for a while: Fanning, who makes the proceedings far more bearable than they should be, is obviously years younger than the actress who appears in the current “Somewhere.”

The 3D isn’t much of a visual asset here, but it might have served as a commercial kickstart for a project that was unmistakably a labor of love, of the sort the French would call l’amour fou. Tech credits are mixed: The production design is first-rate but, not surprisingly, the music is inferior to the original.

Popular on Variety

The Nutcracker in 3D


Production: A Freestyle Releasing and Cinemarket Films (in U.S.) release of a Vnesheconombank presentation of a Nutcracker Holdings and HCC Media Group production. Produced by Andrei Konchalovsky, Paul Lowin. Executive producer, Moritz Borman. Directed by Andrei Konchalovsky. Screenplay, Konchalovsky, Chris Solimine.

Crew: Camera (Deluxe color), Mike Southon; editors, Henry Richardson, Mathieu Belanger, Andy Glen; music, Edward Artemiev; lyrics, Tim Rice; choreographer, Stuart Hopps; production designer, Kevin Phipps; art director, Adam O'Neill; set decorator, Judy Farr; costume designer, Louise Stjearnsward; sound (Dolby), Alistair Crocker; sound designer, Matthew Collinge; visual effects supervisor, Nicholas Brooks; visual effects producer, Piers Hampton; special effects supervisor, Richard Van Den Bergh; line producer, Laura Julian; assistant director, Kieron Phipps; second unit director, John Stephenson; casting, Celestia Fox. Reviewed at Universal screening room, New York, Nov. 15, 2010. MPAA Rating: PG. Running time: 107 MIN.

With: Mary- Elle Fanning Uncle Albert- Nathan Lane The Rat Queen- Frances de la Tour The Rat King- John Turturro Father- Richard E. Grant Mother/Snow Fairy- Yulia Visotskaya Max- Aaron Michael Drozin The Prince- Charlie Rowe The Nutcracker- Shirley Henderson(English dialogue)

More Film

  • Steven Spielberg Branko Lustig

    'He Left Me Speechless': Steven Spielberg Remembers Branko Lustig

    Steven Spielberg has offered a touching remembrance of Branko Lustig, the Holocaust survivor who produced “Schindler’s List” with Spielberg and Gerald Molen and died Thursday in Croatia. “I was heartbroken to hear of Branko’s passing and my thoughts are with his family and friends,” Spielberg said. “When we first met to discuss ‘Schindler’s List,’ he [...]

  • Dylan Brosnan and Paris BrosnanGolden Globe

    Pierce Brosnan’s Sons Paris and Dylan Brosnan Named 2020 Golden Globe Ambassadors

    Pierce Brosnan’s two youngest sons, Paris and Dylan Brosnan, have been named as the 2020 Golden Globe Ambassadors, the Hollywood Foreign Press Association announced on Thursday evening. Paris and Dylan are also the sons of journalist and author Keely Shaye Smith. The ambassador(s), a title that typically goes to the son or daughter of a [...]

  • Joaquin Phoenix'Joker' film premiere, Arrivals, 57th

    Film News Roundup: Joaquin Phoenix Honored by Palm Springs Film Festival

    In today’s film news roundup, Joaquin Phoenix is honored for “Joker”; Legion M backs Joe Manganiello’s “Archenemy”; sales have launched on “Lev Yashin: The Dream Goalkeeper”; Warner Bros. shuffles execs and Universal launches a first-of-its-kind animation writing program. HONOR Joaquin Phoenix has been selected as the recipient of the Palm Springs International Film Festival’s chairman’s [...]

  • Danny Huston

    Danny Huston Discusses the Significance of 'Last Photograph'

    In the decades since Danny Huston made his feature directing debut with “Mr. North,” his 1988 film adaptation of the Thornton Wilder novel “Theophilus North,” he has kept busy in front of the cameras as one of film and television’s most versatile and sophisticated character players. In just the past year, small-screen viewers have been [...]

  • Rocketman

    'Rocketman': Chris Dickens Discusses the Inside Story of Editing 'I'm Still Standing'

    Endings are so important and how the viewer leaves the cinema is crucial. For editor Chris Dickens, finding the perfect ending for “Rocketman” was paramount, but it was also a challenge. Elton John’s hit “I’m Still Standing” was going to end the film with the original idea of going to Cannes to recreate the video [...]

  • A general view of the skyline

    United Media Asia Strikes Deal With Indonesian Giant Kompas Gramedia

    Newly-formed content finance, production and distribution company United Media Asia has struck a first look deal, brokered by Hollywood talent agency CAA, with Indonesian media giant Kompas Gramedia. United has also unveiled its first two feature films. The partnership provides UMA with access to Kompas Gramedia’s media network and its 100,000 pieces of intellectual property, [...]

  • Taron Egerton Fashion

    Taron Egerton's Stylist Used Elton John as Inspiration on Press Tour

    Showstopping looks: For Taron Egerton’s “Rocketman” tour, stylist Gareth Scourfield nodded to Elton John’s iconic wardrobe with bold colors, patterns and silhouettes: “We got a bit more eccentric.” May 16 “Elton is the real original showman,” says Scourfield, who met Egerton through another client, Egerton’s “Rocketman” co-star Richard Madden. “Part of Taron as a man [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content