You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Dear John

Nicholas Sparks' formula of life-altering love receives the youth-edition treatment.

John Tyree - Channing Tatum Savannah Curtis - Amanda Seyfried Mr. Tyree - Richard Jenkins Tim - Henry Thomas Randy - Scott Porter Noodles - D.J. Cotrona

Novelist Nicholas Sparks’ formula of life-altering love — invariably faced with some grand, operatic impediment — receives the youth-edition treatment in “Dear John,” an almost painfully earnest romance that throws the Sept. 11 terror attacks between its Romeo and Juliet. Mostly, the movie provides ample opportunity to admire Channing Tatum’s broad shoulders and Amanda Seyfried’s incandescent smile, but the narrative device that keeps them connected while geographically apart doesn’t work especially well onscreen. The result amounts to a handsome Lifetime movie that could do some modest business before taking its place on the lower shelves of the Sparks bibliography.

Other Sparks adaptations have offered the somewhat rare allure of seeing characters experience transformative love (“Nights in Rodanthe,” “Message in a Bottle”) in middle age, after they’ve experienced pain and disappointments. Here, Special Forces soldier John (Tatum) meets fresh-faced student Savannah (Seyfried) on spring break, triggering a whirlwind affair (“Two weeks together. That’s all it took,” she writes him) and the inevitable “uh-oh” effect — inasmuch as he talks about leaving the service in a year’s time to be with her, but the period is the spring of 2001.

As a consequence, the fall of the World Trade Center towers becomes the unanticipated sticking point to John and Savannah’s plans, as the two remain in contact via a series of letters, which are generally read to accompaniment from gauzy musical montages. While director Lasse Hallstrom and writer Jamie Linden do what they can to make these sequences pop, the pic takes on a drowsy quality during its extended midsection from which it never fully recovers.

There’s also too little support for the square-jawed Tatum (in a mild departure from the action roles he’s played) and Seyfried, the “Big Love” co-star who made a conspicuous splash in “Mamma Mia!” Richard Jenkins is somewhat handcuffed in portraying John’s emotionally stunted father — who occupies his days collecting coins — with Henry Thomas as a friend of Savannah’s family; still, the truth is that there’s not much to augment the central duo, and even she disappears for stretches when the two are separated.

Ultimately, the story feels as if it’s killing time before throwing the next hurdle at the couple, seizing on a favorite Sparks theme that in matters of love, life isn’t fair. Then there’s the added burden that the term “?’Dear John’ letter” possesses a secondary meaning, albeit one that originated several wars ago.

Such nuance will likely be lost on the younger audience that has exhibited a powerful appetite for star-crossed romances, but even for them, “Dear John” feels a trifle earthbound and sober. To accommodate that crowd, Sparks might want to skip current events next time and begin studying up on vampires.

Popular on Variety

Dear John

Production: A Sony Pictures Entertainment release of a Screen Gems presentation in association with Relativity Media of a Temple Hill and Relativity Media production. Produced by Marty Bowen, Wyck Godfrey, Ryan Kavanaugh. Executive producers, Jeremiah Samuels, Toby Emmerich, Michele Weiss, Tucker Tooley. Co-producers, Kenneth Halsband, Jamie Linden. Directed by Lasse Hallstrom. Screenplay, Linden, based on the novel by Nicholas Sparks.

Crew: Camera (Technicolor, Panavision widescreen), Terry Stacey; editor, Kristina Boden; music, Deborah Lurie; music supervisors, Happy Walters, Season Kent; production designer, Kara Lindstrom; art director, Mark Garner; set decorator, Summer Eubanks; costume designer, Dana Campbell; sound (Dolby Digital/DTS/SDDS), Jonathan Gaynor; supervising sound editor, David Patterson; associate producer, Michael Disco; assistant director, Cara Giallanza; second unit director, Charlie Croughwell; casting, Joanna Colbert, Richard Mento. Reviewed at Mann Chinese 6, Los Angeles, Feb. 1, 2010. MPAA Rating: PG-13. Running time: 107 MIN.

With: John Tyree - Channing Tatum Savannah Curtis - Amanda Seyfried Mr. Tyree - Richard Jenkins Tim - Henry Thomas Randy - Scott Porter Noodles - D.J. Cotrona

More Film

  • Johnnie To Quits Taiwan Golden Horse

    Johnnie To Quits Golden Horse Awards as China Builds Pressure

    Leading Hong Kong film maker Johnnie To has dropped out of the Golden Horse Awards, where he was set to be president of the jury deciding the prize winners. The awards, which take place and are organized from Taiwan, have long been considered the most prestigious prized in Chinese-language cinema. However they are currently under [...]

  • Zeroville

    Film Review: 'Zeroville'

    I’m tired of hearing how some novels are “impossible to adapt.” Balderdash! Just because some books don’t lend themselves to being translated from page to screen doesn’t mean that the attempt ought not to be made. Just ask James Franco, who’s shown a speed freak’s determination to tackle some of the unlikeliest literary adaptations of [...]

  • Red Penguins review

    Toronto Film Review: 'Red Penguins'

    “Red Penguins” is a cautionary tale with particular resonance in the context of our current bizarre intertwining with Russia, the country that interfered in the last U.S. presidential election and is led by the POTUS’ apparent BFF. This wild tale of attempted transnational commerce just after the demise of the USSR in the 1990s chronicles [...]

  • Danny Ramirez'On My Block' TV show

    Danny Ramirez to Star in Film Adaptation of 'Root Letter' Video Game (EXCLUSIVE)

    An English-language film adaptation of Japanese video game “Root Letter,” starring Danny Ramirez, is in production in the U.S. through Akatsuki Entertainment USA. Besides Ramirez (“Top Gun: Maverick,” “Assassination Nation”), the film stars Keana Marie (“Huge in France,” “Live in Pieces”) and Lydia Hearst (“The Haunting of Sharon Tate,” “Z Nation”). With a screenplay by [...]

  • Screen writer Beau WillimonMary Queen of

    Beau Willimon Re-Elected as President of Writers Guild of America East

    Beau Willimon, the playwright and showrunner who launched Netflix’s “House of Cards,” has been re-elected without opposition to a two-year term as president of the Writers Guild of America East. Willimon also ran unopposed in 2017 to succeed Michael Winship. Kathy McGee was elected to the vice president slot over Phil Pilato. Secretary-treasurer Bob Schneider [...]

  • Running With the Devil review

    Film Review: 'Running With the Devil'

    A retired Navy SEAL who for a time was a military advisor on the Colombian drug trade, Jason Cabell conceived his first solo feature as writer-director to tell the story of that particular commerce “from the point of view of the drugs.” The result isn’t exactly a docudrama indictment like “Traffic,” a thriller a la [...]

  • Sweetheart review

    Blumhouse's 'Sweetheart' Sets October Digital Release From Universal (EXCLUSIVE)

    After making waves at this year’s Sundance Film Festival, the Blumhouse project “Sweetheart” is set to hit digital and on demand platforms. Universal Pictures Home Entertainment will offer the film on all major streaming hubs and paid video on demand come Oct. 22, unleashing the creature feature which stars Kiersey Clemons in a harrowing tale [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content