A uniquely satisfying entertainment that may nonetheless pose formidable marketing challenges.

Kaulder - Scoot McNairy Sam - Whitney Able

By audaciously turning inside out the narrative conventions of traditional sci-fi thrillers about extraterrestrial invaders, “Monsters” offers a uniquely satisfying entertainment that may nonetheless pose formidable marketing challenges. The title creatures appear only fleetingly during writer-director-lenser Gareth Edwards’ arresting indie, which concentrates more on the human drama of characters under pressure while traveling through what is essentially a war zone. Some critics will be quick to parse the pic for sociopolitical metaphors, but mainstream auds might complain about unfulfilled expectations. Theatrical and homevid prospects will depend on the effectiveness of a carefully targeted ad campaign.

Opening scenes briskly establish the pic’s premise: A humongous swath of Mexico has been quarantined after squidlike creatures crash-landed there as stowaways aboard a NASA space probe. Occasionally, some of the enormous extraterrestrials wander outside the officially designated”infected zone” to destroy lives and property. For the most part, though, the threat is contained within an area to the north — along the U.S.-Mexico border — by a colossal fence.

Photojournalist Kaulder (Scoot McNairy) is on assignment in Mexico, eager to take pictures of the creatures, when he’s ordered to escort Sam (Whitney Able), his publisher’s daughter, to a far-off port where she can board a U.S.-bound ferry. Due to bad timing and worse luck, however, Sam is unable to leave on schedule, forcing Kaulder to find other, riskier ways of getting her back to the States.

Edwards begins”Monsters” with a bravura faux-verite sequence, as heavily armed U.S. troops attack a multitentacled beast on the streets of a Mexican city. For a long time after that, however, the pic settles into a doggedly realistic, almost neorealistic mode, as Kaulder and Sam establish an amicable but wary relationship while making their way first to the port city, and eventually into the infected zone.

Here and elsewhere in”Monsters,” the dialogue is fluidly improvised and the emotions, even during jokey interludes, are bluntly expressed. The sense of verisimilitude is skillfully sustained as Kaulder and Sam journey through the infected zone led by native-born ferrymen and heavily armed mercenaries.

At times, the picture recalls suspenseful treks through war-ravaged landscapes in dramas as diverse as”Apocalypse Now” (which is none-too-subtly referenced before the opening clash) and”Salvador.” The big difference is that, instead of worrying about Viet Cong irregulars or right-wing militia, the protagonists here must guard against attacks by giant squids. A nice touch: While the Americans are repeatedly shocked, the locals take an almost matter-of-fact approach to avoiding danger.

Edwards and a small production team reportedly shot”Monsters” guerrilla-style in various locales throughout Guatemala and Mexico, using local nonprofessionals in supporting roles and dropping CGI effects into the mix — everything from army tanks to mile-high fences — after the fact. But the most spectacular f/x aren’t really f/x at all: Climactic scenes were shot in areas of Galveston, Texas, devastated by Hurricane Ike.

Edwards attempts a tricky balance of gritty-indie style and horror-movie substance — if John Cassavetes had ever made a sci-fi thriller, it probably would’ve looked and sounded a lot like this — and he pulls it off with an improbable degree of success. Credit must also go to McNairy and Able, whose unaffectedly naturalistic and sympathetic performances ground”Monsters” in reality, and editor Colin Goudie, who keeps the pic seamless and suspenseful.

Popular on Variety



Production: A Magnet Releasing (in U.S.) release of a Vertigo Films production. Produced by Allan Niblo, James Richardson. Executive producers, Nigel Williams, Nick Love, Rupert Preston. Directed, written by Gareth Edwards.

Crew: Camera (color, HD), Edwards; editor, Colin Goudie; music, Jon Hopkins; music supervisor, Lol Hammond, production designer, Edwards; sound, Ian Maclagan; special effects, Edwards; assistant director, Maritza Carbajal. Reviewed at SXSW Film Festival (Fantastic Fest), March 18, 2010. Running time: 97 MIN.

With: Kaulder - Scoot McNairy Sam - Whitney Able

More Film

  • Parasite

    Bong Joon-ho's 'Parasite' Wins Best Film at Asia Pacific Screen Awards

    Bong Joon-ho’s “Parasite,” which earlier this year won the Palme d’Or at the Cannes Film Festival, on Thursday added the Asia Pacific Screen Award for best film to its burgeoning trophy cabinet. “Parasite” producer Jang Young-hwan was on hand to accept the award at the end of a ritzy ceremony in Brisbane, Australia. The APSAs, [...]

  • Game of Thrones Season 6

    British Directors Guild Issues Guidelines for Filming Nudity and Simulated Sex

    Directors UK, the professional guild for screen directors in Britain, has launched guidelines for directing nude and simulated sex scenes to prevent unprofessional conduct in film and TV. Described as the “first of their kind in the U.K.,” the new guidelines “are born of the need to set clear and shared professional expectations that apply [...]

  • People attend the opening ceremony of

    Korean Festival Selectors Resign Over Programming Independence Complaint

    Three programmers who have headed the Jeonju International Film Festival, South Korea’s second largest festival, resigned en masse on Tuesday. They say they are protesting the encroachment on their independence by the board of directors and city authorities. The three – Kim Young-jin, Lee Sang-yong and Jang Byeong-won – have led the Jeonju film festival [...]

  • Yuni Hadi

    Singapore Film Festival to Reflect South East Asian Spirit of Cooperation

    Yuni Hadi, executive director of the Singapore International Film Festival, says South East Asian cinema contains exciting talent. And that the way forward involves cooperation with the video streaming platforms. What have been the high and low points of the cinematic year for Southeast Asian cinema? “There are some amazing short films and documentaries that [...]

  • Adele Haenel Adèle Haenel

    Accusations Against Roman Polanski, Other Filmmakers Propel #MeToo in France

    When the Harvey Weinstein scandal broke two years ago, the news was mostly met in France with a Gallic shrug. Screen icon Catherine Deneuve even denounced the #MeToo movement as creating a “totalitarian” environment. But bombshell accusations this month from actors Adèle Haenel and Valentine Monnier may finally have turned the tide in the local film [...]

  • Peppa Pig

    U.K. Competition Watchdog to Examine Hasbro's $4 Billion Deal for Entertainment One

    Britain’s competition watchdog will investigate Hasbro’s $4 billion takeover of Entertainment One. The Competition and Markets Authority said Thursday that it would examine whether the intended acquisition of eOne would result in a “substantial lessening of competition” under U.K. rules. The CMA was deeply involved in scrutinizing the sale of Sky, which was ultimately bought [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content