You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Essential Killing

Despite skillful assemblage, the script's plausibility issues increasingly undermine engagement.

With: Vincent Gallo, Emmanuelle Seigner, Zach Cohen, Iftach Ofir, Nicolai Cleve Broch, Stig Frode Henriksen, David Price, Tracy Spencer Shipp, Klaudia Kaca, Dariusz Juzyszyn. (English, Polish dialogue)

After his mostly well-received return to filmmaking with the intimate chamber piece “Four Nights With Anna,” Polish helmer Jerzy Skolimowski tackles a broader canvas with “Essential Killing,” an escape drama set almost entirely outdoors. Unfortunately, despite skillful assemblage, the script’s plausibility issues increasingly undermine engagement, even with the generous argument that the pic is a parable and operates according to more poetic laws of realism. Still, the topical political angle — the lead, played surprisingly convincingly by Vincent Gallo, is an Afghani prisoner transported to a secret Euro location — could help “Killing” break out in a limited way offshore.

After opening with spectacular helicopter footage of a jagged, mountainous desert landscape in what is presumably meant to be Afghanistan (the location used is actually near the Dead Sea in Israel), the action begins with some American contractors (Zach Cohen, Iftach Ofir) on a secret-ops exploratory mission. A wrong turn in a canyon brings them face to face with a frightened Taliban soldier (Gallo), with fatal consequences.

The Afghani (called Mohammed in the credits, but never actually named onscreen) is captured and brought to a U.S. military base for interrogation and waterboarding, although he doesn’t talk, perhaps because he’s simply unable to hear any questions after being temporarily deafened during capture. Soon after, he’s flown to an unknown location with several other orange-jumpsuited prisoners, but en route to the next detention camp, the truck swerves off the road and the protag escapes barefoot through a snowy forest.

With a strong assist from pro editing (by Reka Lemhenyi) and an ominously sparse, often atonal score by Pawel Mykietyn that blends deftly with the source soundscape, helmer/co-writer Skolimowski builds effective suspense initially over whether and how the protagonist will stay alive, warm and uncaptured in what turns out to be the Polish countryside. There are felicitous touches, such as the visual counterpoint of the earlier desert scenes with later footage of the winter-white expanses of the European terrain.

However, as the pic progresses and Mohammed keeps surviving serious injuries and scrapes, like some unholy cross between Rasputin and the Energizer Bunny, credibility is stretched to the breaking point. Flashbacks showing the protag in a mosque are perhaps meant to suggest that he’s blessed by God, but religious belief barely figures as an issue in this near-wordless film, just as politics and the U.S. military’s treatment of prisoners serve as little more than background context. Instead, Mohammed’s adventure seems to serve strictly as an illustration of how individuals will do anything necessary to survive (hence the title).

In a strong perf, Gallo looks suitably ragged, frightened and desperate throughout — and, per press notes, was up for doing at least some of his own stunts. The handful of Polish- and English-speaking thesps playing bit parts here, as well as Emmanuelle Seigner (as a mute woman who appears toward the end), are less significant as co-stars than the animals Mohammed encounters and the pic’s real star — its landscape.

Essential Killing


Production: A Skopia Film, Cylinder Prods., Element Pictures, Mythberg Films production in association with Canal Plus Poland, Syrena Films, co-financed by Task Films, Akson Studio, with the support of the Polish Film Institute, the Irish Film Board, the Norwegian Film Institute, MMKA, Eurimages. (International sales: Hanway, London.) Produced by Ewa Piaskowska, Jerzy Skolimowski. Executive producers, Jeremy Thomas, Andrew Lowe. Co-producers, Ingrid Lill Hogtun, Ed Guiney, Jozsef Berger. Directed by Jerzy Skolimowski. Screenplay, Skowlimowski, Ewa Piaskowska.

Crew: Camera (color, widescreen), Adam Sikora; editor, Reka Lemhenyi; music, Pawel Mykietyn; production designer, Joanna Kaczynska; costume designer, Barbara Conway; sound (Dolby Digital), Robert Flanagan; supervising sound editor, Fiadhnait McCann; stunt coordinator, Kristoffer Jorgensen; line producer, Bjarne Bjorndalen. Reviewed at Venice Film Festival (competing), Sept. 5, 2010. (Also in Toronto Film Festival -- Masters.) Running time: 84 MIN.

Cast: With: Vincent Gallo, Emmanuelle Seigner, Zach Cohen, Iftach Ofir, Nicolai Cleve Broch, Stig Frode Henriksen, David Price, Tracy Spencer Shipp, Klaudia Kaca, Dariusz Juzyszyn. (English, Polish dialogue)

More Scene

  • Robert De Niro

    Robert De Niro Slams Trump Administration at Tribeca Opening Night

    The 18th annual Tribeca Film Festival opened with Roger Ross Williams’ documentary “The Apollo” at the iconic uptown venue which performers and Harlem community members call “home.” “You can feel the history, the echo of the entertainers,” Tribeca Film Festival co-founder Robert De Niro said in a speech before the film. “In this administration, during [...]

  • Lilli Cooper Tootsie

    How the 'Tootsie' Musical Was Updated for the #MeToo Era

    Turning the beloved 1982 comedy “Tootsie” into a 21st century musical already seemed like a challenge when work on the adaptation began back in 2016. Then the #MeToo movement revved up — and the writers knew they couldn’t tell Dorothy’s story for a modern audience without it. “It’s different than it was when the movie [...]

  • Ralph Fiennes attends a special screening

    Ralph Fiennes on Directing Rudolf Nureyev Biopic: 'It's Been a Very, Very Long Road'

    Ralph Fiennes celebrated his latest directorial outing, “The White Crow,” on Monday night in New York City. The Sony Pictures Classics film tells the story of legendary dancer Rudolf Nureyev. “It’s been a very, very long road. We were mad. We were mad to take on this subject of Rudolf Nureyev. Mad. Completely mad,” Fiennes [...]

  • Taylor Swift Time 100 Performance

    Watch Taylor Swift's Time 100 Gala Performance and Speech

    Just two nights out from Taylor Swift D-day spring 2019 — i.e., Thursday’s release of a new single — Swift made an appearance Tuesday at the Time 100 event in New York, where she did not let loose with any spoiler performances of new music but did sing a few fan favorites, including “Style,” “Delicate,” and [...]

  • Katie HolmesAT&T Presents: Untold Stories Luncheon

    Katie Holmes, Kal Penn Help Decide Winner of $1 Million Filmmaker Grant

    Tribeca Film Festival and AT&T gave one young filmmaker a million and one reasons to rejoice at the “Untold Stories” third annual competition. After a nerve-wracking 10-minute long pitch in front of over 850,000 live stream audience members and a panel consisting of celebrities and industry leaders, filmmaker Kate Tsang was awarded $1 million Monday [...]

  • Laurie Metcalf, John Lithgow'Hillary and Clinton'

    Why John Lithgow Worried About Starring in Broadway's 'Hillary and Clinton'

    When Lucas Hnath first conceived of “Hillary and Clinton” in 2008, he was writing for and about a very different America. Now, a total reimagining of the show has made its way to Broadway with Laurie Metcalf and John Lithgow in the titular roles. At the opening on Thursday night, the cast and creatives talked [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content