You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Oscar directing omission loses stigma

With 10 film noms but 5 for helming, it's not personal

When the Academy upped the number of best picture nominations from five to 10 this year, it made for a broader race, inclusive of everything from smaller-budget indies to one of the biggest-budget films ever released. It also meant that — with still only five director noms available — some helmers would find themselves with an acclaimed film but no kudos in their own category.

John Lee Hancock (“The Blind Side”), Neill Blomkamp (“District 9”), Lone Scherfig (“An Education”), Ethan and Joel Coen (“A Serious Man”) and Pete Docter (“Up”) are the directors whose pictures were nominated without getting nods themselves. What that means for these helmers and their films is hard to say at this point.

“It’s definitely a different code than what was sent to the filmmaking community in the past,” says Tony AngelLotti, a veteran awards-season consultant with his own PR shingle. “In the past, (having a pic nommed without the director meant) you definitely had not been chosen by your peers for a nomination, but now my feeling is that with 10 best picture nominees and only five best director nominees that there is less stigma, because there’s simply no room for everyone.”

During the years of five noms in each category, there have been several high-profile instances in which a film got an Oscar nod but its director was left hanging.

“Historically it has happened on and off that a film that receives a best picture nomination doesn’t also get a best director nomination,” says awards consultant Ronni Chasen, who also has her own PR company. “It happened in 1989 on ‘Driving Miss Daisy’ even though the film went on to win best picture.” (The film was directed by Bruce Beresford.)

One awards season PR consultant who asked not to be identified says the new division in the list sends strong signals. “The Academy has tipped its hand by having 10 best picture nominations and only five best director nominees,” says the consultant. “The pictures without best director nominations are not the front-runners.”

Given the variety of experience and the diverse films made by this year’s spurned helmers, it’s hard to generalize about why they’ve been left off the list. Hancock directed “The Rookie” and “The Alamo,” among other films. The bulk of Blomkamp’s career has been in visual effects. Danish director Scherfig has written and helmed for European television for more than 15 years. Docter has had a lengthy career with Pixar, writing such films as “Toy Story” and “Monsters, Inc.” and helming “Monsters, Inc.” as well. The Coen brothers have been iconic indy filmmakers for more than a decade.

This group is also a mash-up of one-time nominees and Academy heavyweights. Three of them — Hancock, Blomkamp and Scherfig — have not been previously nominated. The other two have received multiple Academy nods. Docter earned two prior noms for original screenplay, one for animated short film and one for animated feature. Ethan and Joel Coen have each received eight noms that yielded four wins each.

Though many covet the golden statuettes, helmers don’t necessarily need the director nod or win to take their careers to the next level. Some believe a picture, actor or actress nomination can prove even more important in terms of box office as well as setting up the director up for his or her next success.

“John Lee Hancock is in a good position because ‘The Blind Side’ was nominated and Sandra Bullock was nominated, and he fought for her,” Angellotti says. “That means actors will want to work with him, which makes studios more interested in him. Not getting a best director nomination might be less important in his case.”

In the end, whether the helmer is individually acknowledged, it’s a plus to be attached to a nominated picture.

“It’s still a terrific honor for a film to be nominated, and there’s no way that can be reported as anything but good news,” Chasen says. “Films still in current release really benefit from a nomination.”

More Film

  • Juliette Binoche Slack Bay

    Juliette Binoche Named Jury President of 2019 Berlin Film Festival

    Oscar-winning French actress Juliette Binoche will preside over the main jury at the 2019 Berlin Film Festival. Binoche is known worldwide for her work in such films as “The Unbearable Lightness of Being” and “Chocolat.” She won an Academy Award and a Silver Bear in Berlin for her role in Anthony Minghella’s “The English Patient,” [...]

  • Eklektik, Alba, Aramos Set Ventana Sur

    Ventana Sur: Belgium's Eklektik, Italy's Alba, Argentina's Aramos Co-Produce 'The Veil' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Belgian film house Eklektik Productions is teaming with Italy’s Alba Produzioni and Argentina’s Aramos Cine to co-produce Stefano Pasetto’s feature drama project “El velo” (The Veil). “The Veil” was presented at September’s San Sebastian Co-Production Forum and then chosen for pitching at the upcoming Proyecta showcase, a new joint initiative launched by Argentine film-TV market [...]

  • Ventana Sur: Latido Films Acquires Hari

    Ventana Sur: Latido Swoops on ‘This Is Not Berlin’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    BUENOS AIRES — In the first deal to be announced on a title in Ventana Sur’s three live-action feature competitions, Madrid-based Latido Films, headed by Antonio Saura, has acquired world rights outside Mexico on Hari Sama’s Copia Final contender “This Is Not Berlin.” Latido’s buy, celebrated with a handshake at Ventana Sur, effectively re-calibrates the [...]

  • Storyboard Media Announce David Albala’s ‘Viento

    Storyboard Media Announce David Albala’s ‘Viento Blanco’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    Chile’s Storyboard Media has announced an agreement to co-produce, along with Calibre71, Javier Valdés and Benjamin Vicuña, director David Albala’s second feature, “Viento Blanco.” (“White Wind”) Albala’s debut, “Jailbreak Pact,” turned on a dramatic real-life prison-break which took place in Santiago, Chile in 1990. That film was also produced by Calibre 71, and featured Chilean [...]

  • C International Sales, Pablo Solarz Ink

    C International Sales Inks Sales Representation Deal with Argentina’s Pablo Solarz (EXCLUSIVE)

    Argentina’s Pablo Salarz, one of Latin America’s best-known film and TV writer-directors, has entered a non-exclusive financing relationship with C International Sales, the international arm of Cinestaan Film Company. Although non-exclusive, the deal is an early example of international companies moving to court or tie-down key talent in Latin America. The deal was negotiated by C International [...]

  • Director’s Feature Debut Paints Dark Comic

    Cuba’s Marcos Diaz Sosa Delivers ‘Shock’ to Ventana Sur

    A disenchanted young pregnant woman is afraid of getting stuck in the small Cuban town where she lives. But when a tornado whisks her away to a luxury resort – where her competitive shooting skills turn her into a celebrity amongst the island’s Communist elite – she comes to realize, like a Hollywood heroine of [...]

  • Alan Moore's 'The Show' to Star

    First Look: Alan Moore's 'The Show,' Starring Tom Burke

    The first look image has been released from British independent movie “The Show,” based on an original story by graphic novel creator Alan Moore, best known for “Watchmen,” “V for Vendetta,” “The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen” and “From Hell.” The cast is led by Tom Burke, whose credits include “War and Peace,” “The Souvenir” and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content