You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Did 10 nominations add up for Oscar?

Expanded best picture race spreads the wealth

Main story | Nominees list | Reactions | Scorecard | Gallery | Oscar observations | Did 10 noms add up? | Oscar push for pics | Award Central

Was the expansion of the best picture race a success?

In the noms announced Tuesday, there was certainly more diversity than usual — the 10 films, from 10 different distributors, represent a nice mix of B.O. hits and specialty fare.

While the contenders didn’t run the gamut, various Academy Award veterans and contenders gave a thumbs-up to the expansion, with the caveat that it will take several years to determine if this year’s wide range will be repeated.

Popular on Variety

Focus Features’ James Schamus was obviously enthused about the nomination of the company’s “A Serious Man” as best pic, in addition to the wider canvas, laughing about the curious turn of a specialty division chief touting the inclusion of more mainstream studio fare.”I’m all for the 10: It’s fun,” he said. “It’s exciting seeing that range of films, which is varied and dynamic. Oscars are embracing the whole spectrum of the industry, from specialty divisions to the major studio fare. I think it’s great.”

Sandra Bullock, who earned one of the two bids for Warner’s “The Blind Side,” said, “I am such an advocate of this 10 picture list and am so glad they are doing it. So many films, from small to big that never get the opportunity to be seen by the public or acknowledged for what they have done, are now given that chance. It’s long overdue that this change was made.”

Nominations for the 82nd annual Academy Awards got out the populist vote. In addition to the sort of intimate, small-scale films that have dominated the best picture race of late, there are two sci-fi pics, a sports-themed family drama, an animated feature and topical titles (films addressing the economy and the Iraq war).

You’d have to go back to 2003’s “The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King” to find a genuine crowd-pleasing high-grosser competing for the top prize. The lineups in the past five years were dominated by small, dark and handsome films like “There Will Be Blood,” “No Country for Old Men,” “Frost/Nixon” and “The Reader.”

When the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences announced the expansion last June, the org’s honchos said they hoped it would open Oscar’s doors to all genres. While the list is more varied than usual, this year’s tally did not include, for example, a documentary, foreign-lingo pic, flat-out comedy or musical.

Even so, there were clues that Oscar voters were thinking outside the box, spreading the wealth wide and including surprises in nearly every category, including Maggie Gyllenhaal (“Crazy Heart”), adapted screenplay for “In the Loop” and a toon bid for “The Secret of Kells.”

As always, there were surprise omissions, including a shutout for “The Hangover,” Julianne Moore and Tom Ford (“A Single Man”), actor Michael Stuhlbarg (“A Serious Man”), the screenplay for “500 Days of Summer” and the relatively light showing for Clint Eastwood’s “Invictus” and Peter Jackson’s “The Lovely Bones.”

And there were films that were admired by critics but never gained much traction during kudos season, including “This Is It!,” “The Road,” “The Informant!,” “Public Enemies” and “Where the Wild Things Are,” and ones that were highly anticipated but never caught fire with auds or critics, such as “Amelia” and “The Soloist.” Other pics once touted as 2009 contenders were moved into 2010, including “Shutter Island,” “The Green Zone” and “The Tree of Life.”

Another key question: Did the Academy Award noms reflect the year accurately? Yes and no.

For the film biz, 2009 was a year of major upheaval: Studios released films with production budgets that ranged from record lows ($16,000 for “Paranormal Activity”) to major highs (an estimated $280 million for “Avatar”). Three of the six major studios saw senior executive shuffles, while new companies emerged as awards contenders (Apparition, the newish Summit, Oscilloscope Laboratories) and other smaller companies like Miramax retreated.

And studio execs got a jolt (albeit a pleasant one) when audiences in 2009 created so many surprise hits (“Taken,” “Paul Blart: Mall Cop,” “The Proposal,” “The Ugly Truth,” “District 9,” “Paranormal Activity,” “The Blind Side”) and pics that performed way bigger than expected (“New Moon,” “Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs” and “Avatar”).

There were no major jolts with Oscar: no best-pic noms for “G.I. Joe” or “G-Force,” no shutouts of major frontrunners.

But there were some notable developments that reflected the changing business, such as a strong presence of 3D films, as well as Oscar’s first nom for a day-and-date VOD/theatrical release: the adapted screenplay bid for IFC Films’ “In the Loop.”

Traditionally, there is little correlation between Oscar recognition and box office success, and 2009 was no exception, despite the presence of B.O. hits in Oscar’s inner circle.

The top 10 grossers worldwide for calendar 2009 were, in order, “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince,” “Avatar,” “Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs,” “Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen,” “2012,” “Up,” “New Moon,” “Angels and Demons,” “The Hangover” and “Night at the Museum: Battle of the Smithsonian.” They collectively earned more than $7 billion during the calendar year, but aside from “Avatar” and “Up,” only two nominations: One each for “Harry Potter” and “Transformers.”

Conversely, modest box office is no impediment to a film’s Oscar chances. (With the screenings and screeners, a lot of awards voters don’t need to pay to see a film, after all). One of this year’s success stories is Oscilloscope’s “The Messenger,” which nabbed two key noms (supporting actor and screenplay), despite a modest box office of $770,000. And Sony Pictures Classics’ “The Last Station” and “The White Ribbon” combined earned less than “The Messenger” but got two noms each: for actress and supporting actor, and foreign-language film and cinematography, respectively.

More Film

  • Legendary Logo

    Legendary Invests in Library Pictures to Fund Local-Language Production

    Legendary Pictures has made an investment in Library Pictures International with plans to fund local-language productions. Library Pictures is a content-financing entity organized earlier this year by CAA Media Finance to support industry-leading filmmakers and distributors by investing in local-language production slates. As part of the deal, Legendary becomes part of a team at Library [...]

  • Knives and Skin

    Film Review: 'Knives and Skin'

    Jennifer Reeder’s “Knives and Skin” will test the limits of viewer patience. The positive qualities lie in the surrealistic film’s bold cinematography, distinctive use of music, and diversity of cast, though that’s not enough to redeem this tedious viewing experience. Following a festival run that began at the Berlinale, IFC Midnight is giving the film [...]

  • Frozen 2

    Women In Animation Celebrate a Banner Year

    When “Missing Link” producer Arianne Sutner began her career in the early 1990s, fresh out of college, she had a goal: Get a job working on a film set that didn’t involve doing craft service. Because, she says “as women, they were always kind of either intentionally or unintentionally pointing you in that direction.” After [...]

  • Laura DernIFP Gotham Awards 2019 -

    Palm Springs Festival to Honor Laura Dern With Career Achievement Award (EXCLUSIVE)

    The 31st annual Palm Springs International Film Festival has selected Laura Dern as the recipient of its Career Achievement Award. Dern will be honored at the festival awards gala on Jan. 2 at the Palm Springs Convention Center. The festival runs Jan. 2-13. “Laura Dern is one of the most outstanding and talented actresses of [...]

  • American Cinematheque Charlize Theron

    Listen: How Charlize Theron Overcame Her Fear of Playing Megyn Kelly in 'Bombshell'

    Charlize Theron immediately didn’t jump at the chance to play controversial news anchor Megyn Kelly in “Bombshell,” the Jay Roach-directed drama about the downfall of late Fox News boss Roger Ailes’ downfall after he was accused by multiple women of sexual misconduct and harassment. “She wasn’t necessarily a person who I just could throw my [...]

  • From the film AMERICAN FACTORY

    Oscar Documentary Race Shaping Up to be Year of the Woman

    When it comes to the film industry’s non-fiction arm, 2019 has proven to be the year of the woman. Not only are females behind the majority of this year’s high-profile documentaries, they are also, thus far, dominating the non-fiction feature awards race. Case in point, six of the 10 best doc noms selected from 375 [...]

  • chadwick boseman 21 Bridges

    '21 Bridges' DP Seeks New York-Style 'Street' Cred in Philadelphia

    In director Brian Kirk’s “21 Bridges,” Chadwick Boseman plays a very different kind of hero than T’Challa in “Black Panther”: He’s an intense New York cop tracking a pair of killers throughout the city one fateful night, trying to box them in by closing the titular connections between Manhattan and the mainland. Along with Kirk, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content