All eyes on vote system

Did Oscar's winner actually receive the most votes?

Now that “The Hurt Locker” has been crowned best pic, skeptics and conspiracy theorists can begin debating whether the winner actually received the highest number of first-place votes.

That’s because for the first time since the 1943 crop of films, Academy members didn’t simply select their favorite film from a field of five; instead they ranked their picks from one to 10.

“I don’t like this system at all because theoretically you could have a film with zero first-place votes win best picture,” groused one Academy member who ranked “Up in the Air” in the top slot.

The Acad doubled its number of best pic nominees in the hope that more popcorn fare would be featured alongside its usual crop of limited-appeal selections. That strategy appeared to have paid off. Still, it is unclear whether more films translated into better TV ratings and whether the 10-film format will be extended beyond this year. The Acad board would need to pass any such continuation. But those close to the board say it will take a few years to see if the experiment sticks.

In the meantime, there is room for debate over how the widened pool of nominees affected the final outcome.

Related:
Complete list of winners
TV review: 82nd annual Academy Awards
‘Hurt Locker’ wins big at Oscars
Bigelow first woman to win director Oscar
Oscars draw 41 million viewers

More Film

  • Moviepass

    MoviePass Parent's Stock Plunges Again to Record Low

    Now that “The Hurt Locker” has been crowned best pic, skeptics and conspiracy theorists can begin debating whether the winner actually received the highest number of first-place votes. That’s because for the first time since the 1943 crop of films, Academy members didn’t simply select their favorite film from a field of five; instead they […]

  • Timothee Chalamet

    Timothee Chalamet in Talks to Star in Denis Villeneuve's 'Dune'

    Now that “The Hurt Locker” has been crowned best pic, skeptics and conspiracy theorists can begin debating whether the winner actually received the highest number of first-place votes. That’s because for the first time since the 1943 crop of films, Academy members didn’t simply select their favorite film from a field of five; instead they […]

  • Taraji P Henson Sam Rockwell

    Taraji P. Henson-Sam Rockwell Drama 'Best of Enemies' Bought by STX

    Now that “The Hurt Locker” has been crowned best pic, skeptics and conspiracy theorists can begin debating whether the winner actually received the highest number of first-place votes. That’s because for the first time since the 1943 crop of films, Academy members didn’t simply select their favorite film from a field of five; instead they […]

  • Harrison Ford plane incident

    Harrison Ford Eyes 'Call of the Wild' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Now that “The Hurt Locker” has been crowned best pic, skeptics and conspiracy theorists can begin debating whether the winner actually received the highest number of first-place votes. That’s because for the first time since the 1943 crop of films, Academy members didn’t simply select their favorite film from a field of five; instead they […]

  • Matthew Rhys

    Matthew Rhys to Co-Star With Tom Hanks in Mr. Rogers Film 'You Are My Friend' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Now that “The Hurt Locker” has been crowned best pic, skeptics and conspiracy theorists can begin debating whether the winner actually received the highest number of first-place votes. That’s because for the first time since the 1943 crop of films, Academy members didn’t simply select their favorite film from a field of five; instead they […]

  • San Diego Comic Con Preview 2017

    Variety Announces Comic-Con Studio and Kick-Off Party With YouTube

    Now that “The Hurt Locker” has been crowned best pic, skeptics and conspiracy theorists can begin debating whether the winner actually received the highest number of first-place votes. That’s because for the first time since the 1943 crop of films, Academy members didn’t simply select their favorite film from a field of five; instead they […]

  • Israeli Film Industry Furious Over Proposed

    Israeli Film Industry Furious Over Proposed Funding Changes

    Now that “The Hurt Locker” has been crowned best pic, skeptics and conspiracy theorists can begin debating whether the winner actually received the highest number of first-place votes. That’s because for the first time since the 1943 crop of films, Academy members didn’t simply select their favorite film from a field of five; instead they […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content