×

Cable providers miffed by court ruling

Circuit judges uphold 'program access rules'

Major cable providers are expressing disappointment over a court decision requiring that they continue to make their programming available to satellite companies, claiming that it gives an unfair advantage to rivals.

The ruling, Friday by the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Washington, D.C., upheld the so-called “program access rule” that was intended to prevent cable companies from withholding the most desirable channels — particularly sports channels — from competitors.

In a statement, Cablevision likened the ruling to regulations that allowed ABC to temporarily black out the Oscars for 3 million New York households, saying the “program access rules are based on an outdated and obsolete view of the competitive landscape.” In the video marketplace of today, the company added, “These rules do nothing but tilt the playing field in favor of phone companies and broadcasters to the detriment of fair competition and consumers.”

Comcast charged that there is a double standard at work. “We’re disappointed that the court has preserved the current unfairness that allows DirecTV to have exclusives for NFL Sunday Ticket and NASCAR Hot Pass while restricting the exclusives that cable operators may have,” the company said.

But FCC chairman Julius Genachowski praised the ruling, saying, “I’m pleased that the D.C. Circuit Court has confirmed the Commission’s authority to prevent vertically integrated cable companies from denying critical television programming to their competitors and consumers.”

The court’s decision was the latest development that cable operators are pointing to in efforts to press lawmakers or regulators to review what they consider outmoded laws in a fast-changing business.

The rule prevents cable companies from certain exclusive programming pacts. It was set to expire in 2007 before the FCC extended it.

Cable companies had argued that the dramatic changes in the competitive landscape had made the rules outdated, and the FCC took note of the differences in the marketplace from 2002 to 2007.

But it also found that many of the most popular networks were still affiliated with a cable operator, and concluded that conditions had not changed enough to allow the rule to lapse. The court noted that seven of the top 20 networks were affiliated with the four largest cable operators, Comcast, Time Warner, Cox and Cablevision.

In its opinion, filed by Chief Judge David Sentelle, the court said that while the market continues to evolve at a rapid pace, the rule “continues to be necessary.” The court also said the FCC’s decision was “not arbitrary and capricious,” as cablers has charged, and that the FCC’s interpretation of the 1992 statute was “reasonable.”

The “program access rule” has been a focal point of congressional hearings on Comcast’s proposed purchase of a 51% stake in NBC Universal.

Despite its challenge of the rule, Comcast has given indications it is willing to continue to apply it to NBC and Telemundo stations, no matter what happened in the courts.

In a dissent, U.S. Circuit Judge Brett Kavanaugh wrote that the rule “thwarts” the government’s interest in competition, and that its “infringement on the editorial and speech rights of cable operators and cable programmers cannot be squared with the First Amendment.”

More TV

  • What to Watch on TV This

    What to Watch on TV This Week: ‘Picard' Premieres and 'Shrill' Returns

    Welcome back to Tune In: our weekly newsletter offering a guide to the best of the week’s TV. Each week, Variety’s TV team combs through the week’s schedule, selecting our picks of what to watch and when/how to watch them. This week, “Star Trek: Picard” beams into existence on CBS All Access and “Shrill” returns [...]

  • SAG Awards 2020: What You Didn't

    SAG Awards 2020: From Charlize Theron to 'Parasite,' What You Didn't See on TV

    Brad Pitt made a crack about his marriages. Robert De Niro got political. And Jennifer Aniston talked about appearing in a commercial for Bob’s Big Boy. Those were just some of thing that happened on stage at the SAG Awards that were broadcast on TNT/TBS on Sunday night. However, Variety was inside the Shrine Auditorium [...]

  • Edges Unknown

    TCB, Cineflix, All3Media Announce Sales Ahead of NATPE Miami

    Miami’s NATPE market kicks off on Tuesday, but deal announcements are already landing. London-based TCB Media Rights has sold 130 hours of content to Latin America, Cineflix and National Geographic Latin America closed a deal for four titles, and Discovery Latin America picked up popular makeover format “10 Years Younger” from All3Media. TCB’s 130 Hours [...]

  • U.K. Broadcaster Channel 5 Readies Thomas

    U.K. Broadcaster Channel 5 Readies Thomas Markle Documentary

    ViacomCBS-backed U.K. broadcaster Channel 5 will air a 90-minute documentary on Meghan Markle’s father Thomas Markle. Markle and her husband Prince Harry sparked a global media frenzy earlier this month with their decision not to continue as senior members of the British Royal Family. Buckingham Palace announced that the couple are to lose their royal [...]

  • Tony Hall BBC Director General

    BBC Boss Tony Hall Lands at U.K.'s National Gallery

    BBC director general Tony Hall has been appointed chair of the board of trustees of the National Gallery. The executive, who has served on the Gallery’s board since November, takes over as chair from Sir John Kingman, who has been interim chair since Hannah Rothschild stood down from the role in September. Hall said: “The [...]

  • Fox TV Stations Greenlight 'Central Ave'

    Fox TV Stations Greenlight 'Central Ave' From Will Packer, Debmar-Mercury

    Fox Television Stations has ordered the weekly entertainment news magazine “Central Ave,” which hails from prolific film and TV producer Will Packer and Lionsgate’s Debmar-Mercury. Debmar-Mercury and Will Packer Media will produce two half-hour shows per week of “Central Ave,” which tackles pop culture and other topics from a “socially conscious and diverse lens,” per [...]

  • Frontrunners Emerge As BBC's Tony Hall

    Frontrunners Emerge as BBC Boss Tony Hall Set to Leave Broadcasting Behind

    As the U.K. industry reacts to news of Tony Hall’s intention to depart the BBC this July, top-level executives including Charlotte Moore and Tim Davie as well as external contenders such as Channel 4’s Alex Mahon are beginning to emerge. Variety understands that Lord Hall, who has headed the BBC for seven years as director [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content