You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Why Joel Stein’s Column Irritates Me

As a columnist I enjoy reading other columnists, especially those off my beat covering entertainment.

Just perusing the New York Times, I admire the way David Brooks constructs an argument (even when I disagree with them) and how cleverly Gail Collins turns a phrase. Nobody hammers a public figure quite like Frank Rich (though his targets are a trifle predictable), and on the days when she’s good (which unfortunately occur with less and less frequency), no one is better than Maureen Dowd. Nicholas Kristof spurs feelings of inferiority, mostly because he has no fear of going places that appear to be dangerous hellholes.

By contrast, I’m frequently irked by those who seem to have no memory of what they’ve written before. That’s one reason I won’t miss WIlliam Kristol (whose shortcomings at the Times were well documented by Editor & Publisher’s Greg Mitchell) and can’t stand LA Times sports columnist Bill Plaschke.

Closer to home both geographically and in terms of subject matter, for some time now I’ve been annoyed by Joel Stein’s column in the Los Angeles Times. But I didn’t really understand the intensity of my reaction until I started writing this blog and was forced to differentiate between blog-worthy and column-worthy material.

Stein can occasionally be funny, even if the whole horny-married-guy, please-please-please-hire-me-to-write-for-a-sitcom shtick quickly wears thin. But what really bothers me about his work is that none of the ideas seem to have the weight to sustain a column. They’re more like random musings str-et-ch-ed to column length.

Stein has a sort of loose theme — our celebrity-obsessed culture — but he goes at it in the most banal way possible. Let’s goof on Ashton Kutcher for being a movie star. Let’s goof on actors by auditioning for a sitcom. His latest gem is perfectly emblematic of the problem — seeking to feebly approach the current financial crisis by filtering our economic woes through the easiest of cultural targets, a rapper named Plies, who gaudily throws cash around.

Somehow every column keeps cycling back to Stein’s favorite subject — Joel Stein, and finding employment opportunities for Joel Stein. Yet the Times’ opinion editors are apparently so out of touch they view this as hip and edgy.

Granted, there are all kinds of columnists, and not all of them have to be serious and weighty. (I like to think of myself as weighty in the literal sense — or maybe just big-boned — but only occasionally serious.) Some will doubtless assume I’m picking a fight with another sort-of journalist to drive traffic, and while I’m probably not above that, that’s honestly not the motivation. I just hate to see prime newspaper real estate (yes, I’m naive enough to assume there is still such a thing) squandered. And maybe I’m a little more sensitive because with so many former colleagues out of work, it’s harder to justify the print equivalent of “Paul Blart: Mall Cop.”

Besides, I have this blog now, and it needs to be fed — even with this kind of passing thought, which does not, by any means, merit a column.

More Voices

  • Elaine May in The Waverly Gallery

    Playwright Kenneth Lonergan on the Genius of His 'Waverly Gallery' Star Elaine May

    When Elaine May agreed to be in my play, “The Waverly Gallery,” naturally I was ecstatic. I had admired her as a director, writer, actor and sketch comedian since high school, when my friend Patsy Broderick made me listen to the album “Nichols and May Examine Doctors.” I didn’t know then that I had already seen Elaine’s [...]

  • billions Showtime

    It's About Time for the Emmys to Expand the Number of Nominees in Top Categories

    You’ll have to excuse the Television Academy if its members feel a little smug when it comes to their film counterparts. As the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences keeps wading into controversy, the TV folks in North Hollywood comparatively look like they have their act together.  In particular, the Emmys were already recognizing [...]

  • emmy dvd

    The Goodbye to Emmy DVD Screeners Has Already Begun (Column)

    Pour one out for the Emmy DVD screener. The Television Academy will no longer allow networks and studios to campaign by sending out physical discs as of next year, and thankfully some companies aren’t even waiting that long to eliminate the much-maligned mailers.   With Emmy For Your Consideration campaign season in high gear, those screener [...]

  • Taylor Swift's "ME!" Video Brings the

    Swift Take: Taylor's Dazzling 'ME!' Is a Phantasmagorical Sugar Rush (Watch)

    Taylor Swift has been leaving Easter eggs for her fans, with clues about the title, themes, et al. of her new single. The video, as it turns out, is almost like diving into a literal basket of Easter eggs. The opening title card for “ME!” reads “directed by Dave Meyers and Taylor Swift,” but we [...]

  • Contract Placeholder Business WGA ATA Agent

    WGA, Agents Face Tough Issues on New Franchise Pact (Column)

    The Writers Guild of America and the major talent agencies are seven weeks away from a deadline that could force film and TV writers to choose between their agents and their union. This is a battle that has been brewing for a year but few in the industry saw coming until a few weeks ago. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content