×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Online, who owns what?

Copyright issues addressed at confab

WASHINGTON — The World Copyright Summit on Tuesday was a unifying effort as the entertainment industry grapples with an uncertain future, but it also highlighted just how polarizing the whole notion of copyright has become in the digital age.

A series of panels saw back-and-forth sniping and other disagreement — and, indeed, one expert lamented the very nature of copyright itself.

Author and Columbia Law School professor Michael Heller gave a speech ominously noting that “when too many people own pieces of one thing, no one can use it. Too much ownership causes gridlock.”

The creative media are stuck in “copyright gridlock,” Heller said, citing as an example the made-for-TV docu “Eyes on the Prize,” about the U.S. Civil Rights Movement. After initially airing in the 1980s, “Eyes” ended up locked away for 20 years as clearances for many images, photos and songs used in the footage couldn’t be secured since rights holders were unknown or wouldn’t agree to terms with the filmmaker.

The larger implication, Heller said, is that, while property rights in general can help spur innovation and investment, too many rights to the same or related property means less innovation, investment and profit. The creative industry should be concerned about this problem because, as he said, “Increasingly, the cutting edge of creativity today is the mash-up, the assembling of multiple parcels.”

The intent of the two-day confab was to focus on rights in the digital domain, a subject that drew not just industry officials but politicos, attorneys and lobbyists.

During a panel discussion on the challenges of music licensing, the head of the Harry Fox Agency — which represents numerous music publishers — made an unprecedented offer to help YouTube identify rights holders to music that appears in videos posted on the popular website.

The surprising moment came when Zahavah Levine, YouTube’s chief attorney as well as associate general counsel for Google, the website’s owner, said, “For some reason I don’t know, the music publishers have been unwilling to help us identify (publishing) rights holders.”

“We’ll start doing it tomorrow,” Gary Churgin, prexy-chief exec for Harry Fox, instantly replied.

YouTube and the music industry have clashed over unauthorized videos containing copyrighted songs. In particular, Harry Fox has sued YouTube/Google in the wake of failed negotiations to arrive at an agreed-upon royalty rate.

Exactly why Harry Fox and other entities, like ASCAP, have not helped identify publishing rights holders before isn’t clear, but Churgin’s pledge signaled a potentially significant change in the relationship at least between Harry Fox and YouTube.

Meanwhile, sparks flew during a heated debate over whether radio broadcasters should pay a performance royalty, with the recording industry’s top lobbyist accusing the other side of proffering “garbage” that should be “flushed down the toilet.”

While the scourge of digital piracy arose as a topic during several panels and focus groups, the more specific issue of a performance royalty triggered the most passionate exchanges, starting with the morning’s first panel, which addressed possible regulatory actions Congress may take.

The House Judiciary Committee has already passed a performance rights bill, and Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah), one of the day’s speakers, said that the Senate Judiciary Committee is likely to pass its version this summer. (Hatch is a senior member of the committee.)

But Benjamin Ivins, a senior general counsel for the National Assn. of Broadcasters, which opposes the legislation, said that a resolution against the bill had already gathered 221 signatures in the House.

Mitch Bainwol, the Recording Industry Assn. of America’s topper, said the resolution was nonbinding, had no force of law and was thus “a diversion. It’s garbage — flush it down the toilet.”

NAB has argued that radio stations already help record labels and artists by giving them free airplay and that some smaller broadcasters would be forced out of business if required to pay a performance royalty.

Bainwol accused broadcasters of playing a double game. “They advertise on their stations against the bill, but they refuse to let us advertise for the bill,” he said. “It’s an outrage, an abuse of power.”

“Why do you sue college students?” riposted Ivins, referring to the RIAA’s legal strategy against alleged illegal downloaders, who are often forced to settle since they can’t afford litigation.

“That’s a cheap shot,” said Bainwol.

More Scene

  • Jordan Peele'Us' film premiere, Arrivals, New

    Jordan Peele Explains the Meaning Behind the 'Us' Michael Jackson Reference

    Jordan Peele’s horror movie “Us” is filled with pop culture references, from “Jaws” to “Goonies.” But the most divisive might be right in his opening sequence. Warning, minor spoilers ahead. The movie about a couple (played by Lupita Nyong’o and Winston Duke) and their children being hunted and brutalized by a mysterious family that looks just [...]

  • Danielle Brooks'Ain't Too Proud - The

    How 'Orange Is the New Black' Star Danielle Brooks Became a Broadway Producer

    Danielle Brooks earned a Tony nomination when she made her Broadway debut as Sofia in the 2015 revival of “The Color Purple,” but now the “Orange Is the New Black” star is working behind the scenes as a producer on the new jukebox musical “Ain’t Too Proud: The Life and Times of the Temptations.” “I [...]

  • Nick Offerman Amy Poehler

    'Parks and Recreation' Cast Talks Possibility of a Revival at 10th Anniversary Reunion

    For one night, Hollywood felt a little like Pawnee. The cast of NBC’s hit comedy “Parks and Recreation” reunited at PaleyFest on Thursday in honor of the show’s 10th anniversary. The whole Pawnee gang showed up: Amy Poehler, Chris Pratt, Aubrey Plaza, Nick Offerman, Aziz Ansari, Rob Lowe, Adam Scott, Rashida Jones, Retta, and Jim [...]

  • Andy CohenThe Shops and Restaurants at

    Andy Cohen to Receive Vito Russo Award at GLAAD Media Awards

    Mazel, Andy Cohen! Bravo’s late-night talk show host is set to receive the Vito Russo Award at the 30th annual GLAAD Media Awards on May 4 in New York City. Sarah Jessica Parker will present him with the award, which is named in honor of GLAAD founder Vito Russo. The annual award goes to openly [...]

  • Variety TV Summit Europe

    Variety TV Summit Europe Coming to London on June 13

    Variety’s TV Summit Europe will coincide with London Tech Week this year, returning to the city on June 13. The international conference will be held at the Royal Lancaster and is co-produced by global events company Informa’s KNect365 division, the world’s largest business-to-business organizer. The one-day summit will focus on the intersection of content and [...]

  • David Furnish, Bryce Dallas Howard, Taron

    'Rocketman': Paramount Previews Footage of Elton John Biopic

    “Rocketman” is ready for lift off. Paramount Pictures threw a cocktail party Monday night to preview 15 minutes of the upcoming Elton John biopic, set for release on May 31, at the Troubadour in Los Angeles, the legendary rock club where John made his U.S. debut nearly 50 years ago. The footage featured pieces of [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content