Knives and Other Sharp Objects

There's enough material for a full-length play in any one of the four warring plotlines that make up "Knives and Other Sharp Objects."

Beatrice - Noemi Del Rio Alex - Joselin Reyes Manuel - Michael Ray Escamilla Loren - Amanda Perez Lucy - Ana Nogueira Lydia - Candy Buckley Jaime - Jaime Tirelli Harvey - Ed Vassallo Perry - Angelo Rosso Eddie - David Anzuelo

There’s enough material for a full-length play in any one of the four warring plotlines that make up “Knives and Other Sharp Objects.” As it is, Raul Castillo’s heartfelt Texas drama is considerably less than the sum of its parts, with too many characters and more locations than a James Bond movie. Still, it’s hard to begrudge the play its vast scope when its subject matter — old-money families in south Texas, life in a border town — mines such a rich, seldom-explored seam of experience, however briefly.

Castillo opens on Beatrice (Noemi Del Rio) and Alex (Joselin Reyes) — sisters heading away from their tiny hometown of Mission, about five miles north of the Texas/Mexico border. Not a bad kid overall, Beatrice has reached the bratty stage of adolescence, and big sister Alex plays surrogate mother during their trip north. It’s a journey of indefinite length — the girls’ father is dying, and the two siblings are to be looked after by their uncle, Jaime (Jaime Tirelli).

The action moves from bus to bus station to car to house with an alacrity that does some significant structural damage to the narrative. Castillo has clearly learned his storytelling craft from the movies, and his settings, many of which confine the dialogue to chairs and car seats, suck a lot of energy out of the performances.

Happily, most of the performers have energy to spare. Reyes and Del Rio, in particular, play their roles with utter conviction and keep at bay much of the incredulity that Castillo’s gangster subplot might otherwise inspire.

When the girls finally make it to Jaime’s house, Castillo gives us the most interesting dynamic in the play: the old money Hispanic/WASP family. This, by the way, is not some offbeat construction — living right next to the “Remember the Alamo” set in Texas is a multigenerational Hispanic aristocracy that continues to flourish. In this particular family, Castillo has paired Tio Jaime with Tia Lydia (Candy Buckley, good in a thankless role), an insufferable social climber who has latched onto her moneyed husband and produced two similarly self-centered kids, Loren (Amanda Perez) and Lucy (Ana Nogueira).

It would be a stretch to say Castillo should have made his play entirely about these people. The writer demonstrates such contempt for Lydia and Jaime’s trashy daughters — Loren especially — that it’s hard to imagine any further indignities he could have visited on them, much less a burst of sympathy for these barely parented young women. Still, there’s something about the white/Hispanic dynamic that keeps Castillo coming back to this uniquely dysfunctional family.

That attraction may be Jaime, whose greed and ego drive away both his new family and his old one. Tirelli’s performance is good, but it’s the playwright who makes the part interesting with his unerring sense of this bitter old man surrounded by people he’s chosen to be with and doesn’t particularly like anymore.

At one point a couple of soldiers (Ed Vassallo and Angelo Rosso) spout conservative platitudes; at another, a hard-luck case caught up in narcotrafficante troubles (Michael Ray Escamilla) tries to woo Alex. Neither of these stories really seems to matter.

In staging the piece, the Public has located a topic worth devoting further time and attention to. And for about 30 of this play’s 140 minutes, Castillo nails it dead-on.

Knives and Other Sharp Objects

Public Theater/Shiva; 99 seats; $10 top

Production: A Public Lab presentation of a play in two acts by Raul Castillo. Directed by Felix Solis.

Creative: Set, Peter Ksander; costumes, Ilona Somogyi; lighting, Sarah Sidman; sound, Bray Poor; production stage manager, Michael D. Domue. Opened April 12, 2009. Reviewed April 11. Running time: 2 HOURS, 20 MIN.

Cast: Beatrice - Noemi Del Rio Alex - Joselin Reyes Manuel - Michael Ray Escamilla Loren - Amanda Perez Lucy - Ana Nogueira Lydia - Candy Buckley Jaime - Jaime Tirelli Harvey - Ed Vassallo Perry - Angelo Rosso Eddie - David Anzuelo

More Legit

  • The Kilroys The List

    Listen: New List, New Leaders as the Kilroys Push for Parity

    The collective of writers and producers known as the Kilroys has been pushing for gender parity in the theater for five years now. With the launch last week of the latest edition of the List — the group’s annual round-up (inspired by Hollywood’s Black List) of plays by women, trans and non-binary writers — members [...]

  • Annette Bening

    Star-Studded Cast to Perform Live Reading of the Mueller Report

    Haven’t perused the Mueller report yet? A star-studded cast, including Annette Bening, Kevin Kline, and John Lithgow, can read it to you. For one night only on Monday, June 24, stars will perform a live reading of passages from the Mueller report for “The Investigation: A Search for the Truth in Ten Acts,” Robert Schenkkan’s [...]

  • Paula Vogel Never Expected 'Indecent' to

    Paula Vogel Never Expected 'Indecent' to Be This Timely

    When Paula Vogel began writing “Indecent” in 2010, she had no idea how resonant its exploration of immigration woes, anti-Semitism and homophobia in the past century would become in the current political climate. The Tony-nominated play, running until July 7 at L.A.’s Ahmanson Theater, traces the theatrical history of 1907 Yiddish play “God of Vengeance” [...]

  • Bitter Wheat review

    West End Review: John Malkovich in David Mamet's 'Bitter Wheat'

    How soon is too soon? Hardly a year had passed since allegations against Harvey Weinstein were made public before David Mamet announced that his satire on the subject, “Bitter Wheat,” was set to star John Malkovich in the West End. Six months later, we’re sat watching a corpulent, super-rich movie mogul — Barney Fein (cough, [...]

  • Batman Julia Roberts Spike Lee

    Batman, Julia Roberts, Spike Lee Among 2020 Walk of Fame Honorees

    Batman, Julia Roberts and Spike Lee are among the names selected to be inducted into the 2020 Walk of Fame. The full list of honorees was announced by the Hollywood Chamber of Commerce’s Walk of Fame Selection Committee via an exclusive livestream by Variety. Chosen from hundreds of nominees during a selection meeting in June, [...]

  • Tracy Letts

    Tracy Letts' Comedy 'The Minutes' to Hit Broadway in 2020

    Playwright Tracy Letts’ comedy “The Minutes” will hit the Broadway stage in Feb. 2020. “The Minutes,” written by actor, producer and playwright Letts, is a comedy taking a look at the current state of American politics through the lens of a small, fictional town called Big Cherry. The play is set in a city council [...]

  • Jamie Forshaw Tapped as Executive Producer

    Jamie Forshaw Tapped as Executive Producer of MWM Live (EXCLUSIVE)

    Jamie Forshaw has been named executive producer of MWM Live, Variety has learned. The theater veteran most recently served as VP of production for Andrew Lloyd Webber’s Really Useful Group. In his new role, he will oversee MWM Live’s slate of stage productions with an emphasis on expanding the division’s work on Broadway. MWM Live [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content