You will be redirected back to your article in seconds


The 77-minute film is plenty arty and only arguably constructive in its tasteful fictionalization of a violent tragedy.

With: Sebastien Huberdeau, Maxim Gaudette, Karine Vanasse, Evelyne Brochu, Pierre-Yves Cardinal, Johanne-Marie Tremblay.

A weaker “Elephant,” Quebecois director Denis Villeneuve’s school-shooting drama “Polytechnique” nevertheless distinguishes itself by endeavoring to comprehend the 25-year-old man who murdered more than a dozen female students at Montreal’s Polytechnique School in 1989. Lensed in black-and-white, the 77-minute film is plenty arty and only arguably constructive in its tasteful fictionalization of a violent tragedy. Outside Quebec, where it opened strongly on Feb. 6, commercial prospects for the flashback-laden film appear dicey but not disastrous given the professionalism of the production and, sadly, the ease of the French-language pic’s thematic translation to most any territory.

Dedicated to the school’s students and staff, along with the victims’ families (whose loved ones are individually memorialized at the pic’s end), “Polytechnique” takes sufficient care to seem nonexploitative, and its violence, while aptly disturbing, is often obscured when not presented entirely off-camera. Still, the pic can’t fully shake its story’s connection to that of the average slasher film, particularly not with images of injured women crawling on hands and knees, nor the “Halloween”-style foreshadowing of bloodshed in a classroom lecture.

To its credit, “Polytechnique” doesn’t shrink from detailing the murderer’s misogyny. First seen composing an explanatory note that soon turns into a hateful rant, the unnamed killer attributes his rage to “feminists” who ruined his life.

Subsequent scenes emphasize the strength and autonomy of the school’s female students by way of identifying what would have threatened this self-described “rational” psychopath (Maxim Gaudette), whose swollen eyes and sullen demeanor give the character some resemblance to Tobey Maguire’s Peter Parker character in “Spider-Man” at his lowest. Closeups of the shooter’s shaking hands in the minutes before he walks into school with a semiautomatic rifle in a garbage bag make him appear human, if not sympathetic.

In addition to Gaudette’s frighteningly believable turn, strong impressions are made by Karine Vanasse as Valerie (the pic’s Jamie Lee Curtis, one could say) and by Sebastien Huberdeau as Jean-Francois, a hunky young man who dares to pursue the killer. The viewer’s mounting hope that Jean-Francois will heroically prevent a death or two is among the signals that “Polytechnique” is a far more conventional enterprise than Gus Van Sant’s Palme d’Or-winning “Elephant” from 2003.

For better or worse, musicvid vet Villeneuve (“Maelstrom”) has decided on a tone that’s only intermittently nerve-wracking, deploying some scenes largely for tension-relieving effect. As shot by d.p. Pierre Gill, whiteout images of wintry Montreal lend an ironic fairytale quality to the proceedings. Cost-conscious period detail includes a shrewd cover of Soft Cell’s “Tainted Love.” Through a climactic flash-forward, the film ends on a decidedly hopeful note.



Production: A Remstar Media Partners release of a Remstar presentation of a Don Carmody/Remstar production. (International sales: Wild Bunch, Paris.) Produced by Maxime Remillard, Carmody. Executive producers, Andre Rouleau, Julien Remillard. Directed by Denis Villeneuve. Written by Villeneuve, Jacques Davidts, Eric Leca.

Crew: Camera (B&W, widescreen), Pierre Gill; editor, Richard Comeau; music, Benoit Charest; production designer, Martin Tessier; costume designer, Annie Dufort; sound (Dolby Digital), Pierre Blain; special effects supervisor, Jacques Godbout; associate producers, Karine Vanasse, Nathalie Brigitte Bustos; assistant director, Benoit Hamel; casting, Emmanuelle Girard. Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (Directors' Fortnight), May 17, 2009. Running time: 77 MIN.

With: With: Sebastien Huberdeau, Maxim Gaudette, Karine Vanasse, Evelyne Brochu, Pierre-Yves Cardinal, Johanne-Marie Tremblay.

More Film


    Film Review: 'Nureyev'

    It would be absurd to say that Rudolf Nureyev lived, or danced, in anyone’s shadow. He was a man who leapt and twirled and flew onstage, all muscle but light as a feather, with a freedom and force that reconfigured the human spirit. There’s no denying, though, that over the last few decades, and especially [...]

  • Die Kinder Der Toten review

    Film Review: 'Die Kinder Der Toten'

    The hills are alive (or rather, undead), with the sound of music (also mastication and the moaning of zombies) in Kelly Copper and Pavol Liska’s experimental, dialogue-free, home-movie-style riff on Elfriede Jelinek’s “Die Kinder Der Toten” (The Children of the Dead). A seminal text in Jelinek’s native Austria, the 1995 book has never been translated [...]

  • Idol review

    Film Review: 'Idol'

    How many twists can a plot undergo before it snaps? This, more than any of the many political, moral and personal conundrums that snake through “Idol,” seems to be the question writer-director Lee Su-jin is most interested in posing with his extravagantly incomprehensible sophomore feature. A seedy political thriller by way of grisly revenge movie [...]

  • The Last to See Them review

    Film Review: 'The Last to See Them'

    Truman Capote’s “In Cold Blood” stretches long as a late-evening shadow over Italian director Sara Summa’s feature debut “The Last to See Them.” The Italian title, “Gli Ultimi Viderli Vivere” which translates literally to “The Last to See Them Alive,” is also the heading of the opening chapter of Capote’s book. The setting is, similarly, [...]

  • Kalank

    Film Review: ‘Kalank’

    Events leading to the 1947 Partition of India serve as the forebodingly serious backdrop for the exhaustingly overextended razzmatazz of “Kalank,” writer-director Abhishek Varman’s lavish but ponderous Bollywood extravaganza, which opened in the U.S. on more than 300 screens the same day as its Indian release. Despite the preponderance of sets and costumes spectacular enough [...]

  • WGA Agency Packaging Fight Placeholder Writer

    WGA: 92 Percent of Writers Who Signed Statement of Support Have Fired Agents

    The Writers Guild of America estimated that over 92 percent of their members who support a new code of conduct for talent agencies have fired those representatives. Letters announcing formal termination will be delivered on Monday, the guild said in a late-hitting memo on Thursday, as most agencies will be closed tomorrow in observance of [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content