You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Cat’s Cradle

The adaptation of "Cat's Cradle" from Untitled Theater Company #61 sacrifices a compelling point of view by being too respectful of its source.

John - Timothy McCown Reynolds Angela Hoenniker - Rosalynd Darling Newton Hoenniker - Sean Allison Bokonon - Horace V. Rogers Philip Castle - Martin J. Mitchell

Kurt Vonnegut keeps giving legiters trouble. Last month, Godlight Theater creatives took a respectable stab at his novel “Slaughterhouse-Five,” but they lost the thread by replacing his plot structure with their own metatheatrical chicanery. if that production had too little Vonnegut, however, the adaptation of “Cat’s Cradle” from Untitled Theater Company #61 has far too much. It sacrifices a compelling point of view by being too respectful of its source.

That’s a shame, because adaptor-director Edward Einhorn has an exciting concept: The entire show is a passion play performed by Bokononists, meaning people who live on the fictitious island of San Lorenzo and practice the fictitious religion of Bokonon. (Vonnegut created both.)

We’re quickly shown that thesps are worshippers at a religious service, and they only become other characters when they slip costume pieces over their linen pants and white shirts. As part of the service, a man with a video camera (Barry Weil) stands by a rack of small set models. When the parable moves to a new location — like an island castle or an American cemetery — he films the corresponding model, and the image is projected on an upstage screen. 

Popular on Variety

Zesty calypso songs accompany these transitions, and their lyrics, taken from the prayers Vonnegut wrote for his novel, explain the religion’s major philosophies. Thus, Einhorn creates a sense of dramatic urgency by insisting we’re in a present-moment church ritual.

And even devotees of the book — which relates how a substance called ice nine destroys the planet — may be seduced. If we’re learning how American scientists and San Lorenzan leaders leveled the Earth, does that mean this service takes place after the apocalypse? Did humans re-emerge, only to follow the teachings of Bokononism? Einhorn shrewdly avoids answering these questions.

That intrigue makes it tempting to listen to John (Timothy McCown Reynolds), who guides the ritual by relating how he stumbled upon San Lorenzo, accidentally became its leader and wrote down everything about the disaster. At first, it seems he’s a narrator who exists outside the passion play, ready to explain what’s going on. But really, John is just a Bokononist who put on his costume before we arrived.

That’s a delicious mind game, because it makes us trust John as our onstage stand-in and then reveals that he was an islander all along. It’s like the play is encouraging us to convert to a fake religion — if John can do it, so can we — which perfectly echoes Vonnegut’s satire.

And Reynolds’ low-key perf is excellent bait. His nonchalance says he’s unconcerned if we listen. He’s just telling the truth, with or without our approval, and that makes him fascinating.

The rest of the cast offsets Reynolds in early scenes, bringing wide-eyed eagerness to their roles-within-roles. Tacky costume pieces like giant bouffant wigs and hideous sport coats enhance the church basement wholesomeness.

After about 40 minutes, though, the play becomes much more conventional. Actors speak long passages of Vonnegut’s expository dialogue while basically standing still, meaning we hear about actions more frequently than we see them performed. It’s true that the plot grows dense with minor characters and interconnected events, but by reciting the details as liturgy, the production loses its theatricality.

“Cat’s Cradle” finally becomes a chore. With less devotion to Vonnegut’s language and details, it could succeed in translating his message into a new medium.

Cat's Cradle

Walkerspace, 70 seats, $18 top

Production: An Untitled Theater Company #61 presentation of play with music in two acts with book by Edward Einhorn, music by Henry Akona, lyrics by Kurt Vonnegut. Based on the novel by Vonnegut. Directed by Einhorn. Music direction, Akona. Choreography, Tom Berger.

Creative: Sets, Amy Davis; costumes, Carla Gant; lighting, Jeff Nash; props, Berit Johnson; models, Tanya Khordoc, Barry Weil; dramaturg, Karen Lee Ott; production stage manager, Amanda Anderson. Opened Feb. 23, 2008. Reviewed Feb. 24. Running time: 2 HOURS, 30 MIN.

Cast: John - Timothy McCown Reynolds Angela Hoenniker - Rosalynd Darling Newton Hoenniker - Sean Allison Bokonon - Horace V. Rogers Philip Castle - Martin J. MitchellWith: Michael Bertolini, John Blaylock, Katherine Boynton, Daryl Brown, Sarah Engelke, Andrew Haserlat, Sheila Johnson, Jerome Brooks, Jenny McClintock, Paul Pricer, Michelle Rabbani, Phoebe Silva, Josh Silverman, Darius Stone, Barry Weil, Sandy York.

More Legit

  • Jagged Little Pill review

    Broadway Review: 'Jagged Little Pill'

    Nearly 25 years after “Jagged Little Pill” hit the shelves of record stores, Alanis Morissette’s innovative 1995 album has arrived on Broadway under the muscular direction of Diane Paulus, who launched this galvanic production at the American Repertory Theater. The show’s supportive book by screenwriter Diablo Cody interprets Morissette’s musical idiom as a universal domestic [...]

  • Claire Warden

    Listen: Let's Talk About Sex Onstage

    The craft of intimacy direction is taking Broadway by storm — and on the latest episode of Variety’s Stagecraft, Broadway’s first intimacy director explains why, and breaks down the ways in which she’s helping to revolutionize how actors get intimate onstage. Listen to this week’s podcast below: Warden, whose credits this season include “Jagged Little [...]

  • Dan Stevens

    Mark Addy, Dan Stevens Head Broadway Cast of 'Hangmen'

    Mark Addy and Dan Stevens will appear in the Broadway premiere of Martin McDonagh’s “Hangmen.” Addy, best known for his work on “Game of Thrones” and “The Full Monty,” starred in the off-Broadway production of the black comedy. It’s the first time Stevens, beloved for his turn on “Downton Abbey,” has appeared on the Great [...]

  • Dear Evan Hansen Jordan Fisher

    Jordan Fisher Joins 'Dear Evan Hansen' in Title Role on Broadway

    Jordan Fisher will be Broadway’s next Evan Hansen, joining the cast of “Dear Evan Hansen” in the musical’s title role. Fisher, best known to theater enthusiasts for his stint in “Hamilton” and playing Mark Cohen in Fox’s “Rent: Live,” will play the role for a limited 16-week engagement starting Jan. 28. “Evan Hansen is a [...]

  • SUBJECTS] seen at the Lincoln Center

    Lincoln Center's David Geffen Hall Set for Major Renovation

    Lincoln Center’s David Geffen Hall is set to undergo a major renovation that will lead to the facility being closed for months-long stretches starting in 2022. Lincoln Center and the New York Philharmonic announced Monday that the overhaul will require the temporary shuttering of Geffen Hall from May 2022 through October 2022 and again from [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content