You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

The Silence Before Bach

Spanish avant-garde helmer Pere Portabella's "The Silence Before Bach" defies categorization.

With: Christian Brembeck, Alex Brendemuhl, Feodor Atkine, Daniel Ligorio, Georg C. Biller, Georgina Cardona, Franz Schuchart. (Spanish, Catalan, German, Italian, French dialogue)

Composed of seemingly unrelated vignettes that span countries, languages and centuries, Spanish avant-garde helmer Pere Portabella’s “The Silence Before Bach” defies categorization: A stalking player piano, two truckers, a female equestrienne (plus horse), a blind piano tuner (plus dog), a bewigged tour guide, a nude female cellist and Johann Sebastian Bach perform their appointed rounds in an atmosphere of quiet subversion. Arguably stronger conceptually than visually, surreal mix of the unexpected and the banal is definitely not to everybody’s taste. But the music is inarguably sublime. Hybrid docu opens Jan. 30 at Gotham’s Film Forum.

Virtually unknown (except perhaps as producer of Carlos Saura’s “The Delinquents” and Luis Bunuel’s “Viridiana”) until a series of recent retrospectives in Europe and the U.S. brought his own highly eclectic experimental oeuvre to light, 78-year-old enfant terrible Portabella seasons his apparent humanism with a peculiarly deadpan mordancy.

Anyone expecting an austere, quietly reverent musical excursion will be quickly disabused by the sight of a player piano emerging from an empty gallery to advance on the receding camera, the piano’s moving parts fluttering madly to the notes of “The Goldberg Variations” (pic’s most-sampled Bach opus).

Portabella’s occasional forays into costume-drama biopic are often obviously apocryphal: Bach (Christian Brembeck) takes time out of his perusal of a score to correct his young son’s rendition of “The Well-Tempered Clavier” (not enough tension) before getting caught up in the music himself. His pregnant wife then brings in his neglected score — closeup on the “St. Matthew Passion.”

Later in the film (and a century later in time), Mendelssohn’s manservant wanders through a magnificently rendered marketplace, where a butcher hands him a bloody roast wrapped in the very same score of the “St. Matthew Passion.” He runs to his master, a lost masterpiece is restored, and the idiocy and literalness of biopic convention are ironically offset by the beauty of the underlying musical truth.

Many sequences unfold as pure, joyful exercises in high concept, not dissimilar to Peter Sellars’ or Adrian Marthaler’s incongruous musicvideos of classical etudes: Some 20-odd cellists, seated facing each other on an empty subway, simultaneously downbow into a “Suite for Unaccompanied Cello,” their rich chords counterpointing the whooshing sounds of the subway in postmodern harmony.

Other scenes play as less serendipitous, stressing the necessary tension Bach finds lacking in his son’s too melodious performance: One quasi-sadistic sequence intercuts one of the “Variations” with a horse-training session.

Audio and visual tech credits are highly accomplished.

Popular on Variety

The Silence Before Bach


Production: A Films 59 production, in collaboration with 3 Televisio de Catalunya. Directed by Pere Portabella. Written by Portabella, Carles Santos, Xavier Alberti.

Crew: Camera (color, widescreen), Tomas Pladevall; editor, Oskar Xabier Gomez; art director, Quim Roy; costume designer, Montse Figueras; sound (Dolby Digital), Albert Manera, Ricard Casals. Reviewed at Film Forum, New York, Jan. 24, 2008. (In Venice Film Festival -- Horizons.) Running time: 101 MIN.

With: With: Christian Brembeck, Alex Brendemuhl, Feodor Atkine, Daniel Ligorio, Georg C. Biller, Georgina Cardona, Franz Schuchart. (Spanish, Catalan, German, Italian, French dialogue)

More Film

  • Hustlers Box Office

    Box Office: Why 'Hustlers' Soared While 'The Goldfinch' Flopped

    Though STX’s “Hustlers” and Warner Bros.’ “The Goldfinch” couldn’t be more different in terms of genre or style, the two new releases prove the divergent paths that mid-budget movies can take at the box office. Both films arrived last weekend in an environment that has been increasingly hostile to anything that’s not of the superhero [...]

  • The Irishman

    Martin Scorsese's 'The Irishman' Set for Centerpiece Screening at Rome Festival

    Martin Scorsese’s “The Irishman” will be among highlights of the upcoming Rome Film Festival, following its European launch as the closing film at the BFI London Film Festival. As with the Oct. 13 London premiere, key cast members of the hotly anticipated Netflix film are expected to attend the screening in Rome, as is Scorsese. [...]

  • 'Cheer Up, Mr. Lee' to be

    Korean Comedy 'Cheer Up, Mr. Lee' to be Remade in French

    Currently on-release South Korean comedy drama, “Cheer Up, Mr. Lee” is to be remade in French. “Mr. Lee” is the story of a mentally-challenged man who learns that he has a sick daughter, and embarks on a voyage of discovery with his new family member. A remake deal was struck between Yong Film, part of [...]

  • The Bad Guys: Reign of Chaos

    Korea: 'The Bad Guys: Reign of Chaos’ Rules Chuseok Holiday Box Office

    Local films dominated cinemagoing in South Korea over the 4-day Chuseok holiday weekend, traditionally one of the year’s busiest periods. The winner was “The Bad Guys: Reign of Chaos.” Opening on Wednesday, the CJ Entertainment release earned $20.2 million from 1.97 million admissions over five days. A film adaptation of CJ E&M’s 2014 hit TV [...]

  • Disco

    New Europe Sells Toronto and San Sebastian Film 'Disco' to Several Territories (EXCLUSIVE)

    Jan Naszewski’s New Europe Film Sales has signed several distribution deals on “Disco,” which had its world premiere in Toronto Film Festival’s Discovery section and makes its European premiere in San Sebastian’s New Directors competition. The film has been picked up by Palace for Australia and New Zealand, Artcam for Czech Republic and Slovakia, Kino [...]

  • "Jade Dynasty" in front at the

    China Box Office: 'Jade Dynasty' in Front Ahead of Mixed Competition

    With “Jade Dynasty” out front, Chinese action and Asian animation films led the way at the China box office over the past weekend, while the few American titles in play have failed to attract many moviegoers. Chinese action fantasy “Jade Dynasty” led the weekend box office in its debut with $38.1 million, figures from consultancy [...]

  • The Painted Bird

    Venice Competition Film 'The Painted Bird' Is Czech Entry in Oscar Race

    Václav Marhoul’s “The Painted Bird,” which world premiered at the Venice Film Festival in the main competition and also played at the Toronto Film Festival in Special Presentations, has been selected as the Czech Republic’s entry for the 92nd Academy Awards in the international feature film category. The pic follows the journey of an unnamed [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content