You will be redirected back to your article in seconds


Auds heretofore resistant to Iraq War-themed pics likely won't be lured by "Stop-Loss," a wildly uneven drama, by turns sincere and synthetic, about a decorated Army sergeant whose homecoming is cut short when he's unexpectedly ordered back to the war zone.

Brandon King - Ryan Phillippe Michele - Abbie Cornish Steve Shriver - Channing Tatum Tommy Burgess - Joseph Gordon-Levitt Roy King - Ciaran Hinds Lt. Col. Boot Miller - Timothy Olyphant Rico Rodriguez - Victor Rasuk Isaac "Eyeball" Butler - Rob Brown Jeanie - Mamie Gummer Sen. Orton Worrell - Josef Sommer Ida King - Linda Emond Shorty - Alex Frost

Auds heretofore resistant to Iraq War-themed pics likely won’t be lured to the megaplexes by “Stop-Loss,” a wildly uneven drama, by turns sincere and synthetic, about a decorated Army sergeant whose homecoming is cut short when he’s unexpectedly ordered back to the war zone. Helmer Kimberly Peirce (“Boys Don’t Cry”), working from a script she co-wrote with Mark Richard, charts a bumpy road trip through familiar territory where vividly drawn characters rub shoulders with stock stereotypes, and persuasive verisimilitude is too often overshadowed by contrivance. Expect a short tour of duty in theaters before a quick transfer to homevid.

Opening minutes crackle with energy, as Peirce and ace lenser Chris Menges employ variegated film stocks to create faux homevideos supposedly shot, edited and scored by U. S. troops in Iraq (a fact-based conceit they sporadically reprise throughout, with steadily diminishing effect). But this testosterone-fueled montage quickly gives way to an impressively staged and powerfully kinetic battle in Tikrit, as Staff Sgt. Brandon King (Ryan Phillippe) and his men pursue insurgents who have fled their roadblock. King displays courage under fire, but some of his men (and a few innocent bystanders) don’t survive the deadly encounter.

Shortly thereafter, King and a few buddies are shipped back to their warmly welcoming friends and family in the small town of Brazos, Texas (much of “Stop-Loss” was shot in and around Austin). King is proud to receive both the Purple Heart and the Bronze Star from a visiting senator (vet stage and screen actor Josef Sommer, making the absolute most of minimal screen time), but he’s more interested in simply returning to civilian life.

Unfortunately, his discharge is delayed by “stop-loss,” a controversial policy whereby the military can indefinitely extend enlistments and send soldiers back for second or third tours in Iraq. Peirce and Richard bend over backward to portray King as a model soldier and genuine patriot who rebels against the stop-loss order not because of cowardice or politics, but because he feels personally betrayed by a government he’s already served far beyond the call of duty.

This characterization may enable some otherwise disapproving auds to accept King’s impulsive decision to go AWOL. Accompanied by Michele (Abbie Cornish), the girlfriend of King’s more conventionally gung-ho buddy Steve (Channing Tatum), the angry soldier sets out for Washington, D.C., in the naive hope that he can plead his case to the senator who recently honored him. Along the way, he takes side trips to visit and/or honor former comrades, even as he remains the target of a nationwide manhunt.

Peirce reportedly was inspired to make “Stop-Loss” by her brother’s experiences serving in Afghanistan and Iraq, and by accounts of real-life soldiers who defied their stop-loss orders. And yet, huge swaths of her pic play like mash-ups of features from the 1970s and early ’80s about distressed or disturbed Vietnam War veterans. Indeed, the more dedicated deconstructionists in the audience will identify various influences reflected here, ranging from the blatantly obvious (“The Deer Hunter”) to the relatively obscure (“Heroes,” Jeremy Kagan’s 1977 cross-country odyssey with Henry Winkler as a troubled vet). There’s even a hint of “First Blood” in a scene where King opens up a can of whup-ass on punks who break into his car and trigger his wartime flashback.

Phillippe is creditable and credible — he even manages a convincing Texas twang — and there are standout supporting performances by Tatum (despite his lack of an equally believable drawl), Victor Rasuk (as a battle-scarred Hispanic soldier) and Joseph Gordon-Levitt (as a fellow Iraq vet who finds peace can be hell). But Ciaran Hinds is criminally underused as King’s supportive father, and even some of the better actors are hamstrung by the script’s cliches; at least one key character is so obviously fated for an unhappy ending, he might as well have a vulture perched on his shoulder.

The ending of “Stop-Loss” may be attacked by some critics (especially those with a political agenda) as a bases-covering cop-out. But it’s actually one of the most dramatically and emotionally sound elements in the entire pic. More’s the pity, then, that so much of what precedes this finale seems secondhand and second-guessed, the work of well-intentioned filmmakers whose stumbling efforts suggest that, much like the Vietnam War, the Iraq War won’t inspire truly great and substantial dramas until the passing of time allows for perspective.

Credit lenser Menges and production designer David Wasco for giving pic (including battle scenes shot in Morocco) at least a patina of truth.


Production: A Paramount release of a Paramount and MTV Films presentation of a Scott Rudin production. Produced by Kimberly Peirce, Mark Roybal, Rudin, Gregory Goodman. Directed by Kimberly Peirce. Screenplay, Mark Richard, Peirce.

Crew: Camera (color), Chris Menges; editor, Claire Simpson; music, John Powell; music supervisors, Randall Poster, Jim Dunbar; production designer, David Wasco; art director, Peter Borck; set decorator, Sandy Reynolds Wasco; costume designer, Marlene Stewart; sound (Dolby), Danny Michael; supervising sound editors, Eugene Gearty, Larry Wineland; sound designer, Gearty; visual effects supervisor, Thad Beier; visual effects, Hammerhead Prods.; associate producers, Michael Diliberti, Reid Carolin, Sam Cassel; assistant director, William M. Connor; second unit director/stunt coordinator, Doug Coleman; casting, Avy Kaufman. Reviewed at SXSW Film Festival (Spotlight Premieres), March 13, 2008. MPAA Rating: R. Running time: 112 MIN.

With: Brandon King - Ryan Phillippe Michele - Abbie Cornish Steve Shriver - Channing Tatum Tommy Burgess - Joseph Gordon-Levitt Roy King - Ciaran Hinds Lt. Col. Boot Miller - Timothy Olyphant Rico Rodriguez - Victor Rasuk Isaac "Eyeball" Butler - Rob Brown Jeanie - Mamie Gummer Sen. Orton Worrell - Josef Sommer Ida King - Linda Emond Shorty - Alex Frost

More Film

  • Italy's Notorious Pictures on Buying Spree

    Cannes: Italy's Notorious Pictures on Buying Spree Takes 'Vivarium,' Ups Production (EXCLUSIVE)

    Italian distribution, production, and exhibition company Notorious Pictures is on a buying spree at the Cannes Film Market where they’ve acquired four high-profile titles, including Jesse Eisenberg and Imogen Poots sci-fi-fier “Vivarium,” which world-premiered in Critics’ Week. On the production side the expanding outfit has teamed up with Belgium’s Tarantula Productions on Islamic terrorism thriller [...]

  • Marco Bellocchio The Traitor Cannes

    Director Marco Bellocchio Talks About Cannes Mafia Drama 'The Traitor'

    Cannes veteran Marco Bellocchio’s vast body of work spans from “Fists in the Pockets” (1965) to “Sweet Dreams,” which launched at Directors’ Fortnight in 2016. The auteur known for psychodramas and for bringing the complexities of Italian history, and hypocrisy, to the big screen is back, this time in competition, with “The Traitor,” a biopic [...]

  • Director Tudor Giurgiu on Transylvania Film

    Director Tudor Giurgiu on Transilvania Film Festival Opening Film ‘Parking’

    CANNES–A poet, a romantic, and a stranger in a strange land, Adrian is a Romanian immigrant working as a night watchman at a car dealership in Cordoba. After leaving his old life behind, he falls in love with a Spanish singer who offers him a shot at reinvention. But when a money-making scheme by his [...]

  • Their Algeria

    Lina Soualem’s ‘Their Algeria’ Wins First Docs-in-Progress Award

    CANNES–Lina Soualem’s “Their Algeria” won the inaugural Docs-in-Progress Award, a €10,000 ($11,300) cash prize given out by the Cannes Film Market’s Doc Corner with the support of the Intl. Film Talent Association (IEFTA), which was presented Tuesday at a ceremony at the Plage des Palmes. Soualem’s directorial debut was chosen out of the 24 works-in-progress [...]

  • Film Review: The Orphanage

    Cannes Film Review: 'The Orphanage'

    Amusing, at times poignant Bollywood re-creations are used in “The Orphanage” much as Afghan director Shahrbanoo Sadat mixed folklore with realism in her award-winning “Wolf and Sheep,” in both cases to add heightened levels of cultural significance and an element of fantasy as necessary correlatives to hardscrabble lives. While Sadat’s second feature is something of [...]

  • Three Identical Strangers

    Film News Roundup: 'Three Identical Strangers' Feature Adaptation Taps 'Bohemian Rhapsody' Writer

    In today’s film news roundup, “Three Identical Strangers” is moving ahead, Skeet Ulrich has been cast with Tom Hanks, the “Minions” sequel has been titled and “Vegas Dave” is getting a movie. MCCARTEN ATTACHED “Bohemian Rhapsody” screenwriter Anthony McCarten will write and produce the feature adaptation of the documentary “Three Identical Strangers.” Raw, Film4 and [...]

  • Bong Joon-ho, Choi Woo-shik. Director Bong

    Bong Joon-ho's 'Parasite' Earns Five-Minute Cannes Ovation

    Just days after the announcement of the selection of “Parasite” for main competition at the Cannes Film Festival, South Korean director Bong Joon-ho warned members of the local press not to expect his film to win the Palme d’Or. He also suggested that the film was “hyper local” and possibly difficult for foreign audiences to [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content