×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Stealing America: Vote by Vote

Arguing that the current electronic voting systems across the U.S. are fundamentally flawed and, worse, being gamed for political gain, "Stealing America: Vote by Vote" functions as an organizing tool for people worked up about the important issue, but is hardly suitable as a commercial doc release.

With:
With: Bob Hagan, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., Ion Sancho, Charles Lewis, Bruce O'Dell, Chuck Herrin, Greg Palast, Paul Craig Roberts, John Zogby, John Boyd, Matthew Damschroder, Bob Fitrakis, Jonathan Simon, Chris Hood, Pat Leahan, Dr. Avi Rubin, Charles Traylor, Dr. Jonathan Simon. Narrator: Peter Coyote.

Arguing that the current electronic voting systems across the U.S. are fundamentally flawed and, worse, being gamed for political gain, “Stealing America: Vote by Vote” functions as an organizing tool for people worked up about the important issue, but is hardly suitable as a commercial doc release. Pic’s classroom-style presentation and wooden filmmaking can be ignored by eager activists, but will surely bore audiences in theaters (a limited rollout began Aug. 1). Homevid sales, though, look to enjoy a boomlet close to election season.

Director-producer Dorothy Fadiman summons a large group of experts, observers and activists (and no less a pollster than John Zogby) to lay out the case that nationwide elections over the past 10 years have seen skewed results that raise questions about the legitimacy of computerized voting machines. Based on the not-entirely-precise premise that exit polling has been generally accurate, pic cites particularly the 2000 presidential election as a case where exit numbers favored Al Gore and final results favored George W. Bush.

After years of general (though, pic fails to note, hardly consistent) correlation between exit-poll numbers and final tallies, recent times have seen that correlation break down. The film, which carries no writer credit (although Peter Coyote’s narration is prominent), has its theories of why this is so, and suggests that GOP dirty tricksters may be the villains without saying it in so many words. (This is manifested most crudely by composer Laurence Rosenthal’s contrasting “dark” and “sympathetic” underscores for images of Bush and his 2004 opponent, John Kerry, respectively.)

The cited problems include long lines (particularly in lower-income and Democratic-leaning precincts), voting-machine malfunctions, exit polling itself, Republican-friendly influence and ownership of the machine manufacturers, software manipulation, uncounted votes and elimination of likely Democratic voters through such tricks as “caging,” used to nix names from voter registries.

The most damaging testimony comes from computer security analyst Chuck Herrin, who had previously reported to Congress of his successful hacking experiments to prove that a vote count could be skewed or reversed. Pic shifts into the conspiratorial when it notes that such machine makers as Diebold were big contributors to the GOP in such key swing states as Ohio.

But the film fails in its journalistic responsibility to directly grill those it holds responsible: There’s no stated or indicated sign that the filmmakers even tried to speak to current Diebold execs or suits in other major voting-machine firms to get to the bottom of the matter.

Final passage is merely a “get organized” primer, underlining the film’s real purpose as an organizing tool and not an informational general-aud doc. Pic misses the latest trend, which is a growing rejection of electronic voting machines and a return to the more reliable paper ballot.

“Stealing America” also blows a golden opportunity to go further by examining the flaws in plurality voting — more than anything else, the real cause of Gore’s 2000 defeat — as detailed in William Poundstone’s recent book, “Gaming the Vote: Why Elections Aren’t Fair (and What We Can Do About It).” The film’s lack of debate over such alternative ideas is even more problematic than its bland look and sound, which are more likely to put viewers to sleep than to wake them up.

Stealing America: Vote by Vote

Production: A Direct Cinema Limited release, in association with Abramorama & Mitropoulos Films, of a Concentric Media production. Produced by Dorothy Fadiman. Executive producers, Mitchell Block, James Fadiman. Co-producers, Bruce O'Dell, Carla Henry. Directed by Dorothy Fadiman.

Crew: Camera (color, DV-to-35mm), Matthew Luotto, Rick Keller; editors, Katie Larkin, Luotto, Xuan Vu, Ekta Bansal Bhargava; music, Laurence Rosenthal; sound, Rob Dickson; sound designer, Dave Nelson; re-recording mixer, Nelson; archival footage, Lisa Rein, Pete Nicholls; research, Carla Henry, Killen, Victoria Parks, Jay McGowan, Mary Anne Saucier; associate producers, Larkin, Robert Carillo Cohen, James Q. Jacobs, Theron Horton, Jo Killen. Reviewed at Wilshire screening room, Beverly Hills, July 14, 2008. Running time: 90 MIN.

With: With: Bob Hagan, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., Ion Sancho, Charles Lewis, Bruce O'Dell, Chuck Herrin, Greg Palast, Paul Craig Roberts, John Zogby, John Boyd, Matthew Damschroder, Bob Fitrakis, Jonathan Simon, Chris Hood, Pat Leahan, Dr. Avi Rubin, Charles Traylor, Dr. Jonathan Simon. Narrator: Peter Coyote.

More Film

  • 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood':

    'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood': First Reactions Pour in From Cannes

    Reactions to Quentin Tarantino’s “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” which premiered Tuesday evening in Cannes, have started flooding Twitter, and critics are excited, to say the least. The movie, starring Brad Pitt, Leonardo DiCaprio and Margot Robbie, is set in 1969 Hollywood against the backdrop of the Manson murders. DiCaprio plays washed-up TV star [...]

  • AMMAN, JORDAN - MAY 13: Naomi

    After Hosting 'Aladdin' 'Star Wars' and 'Dune' Jordan Ups Production Rebates (EXCLUSIVE)

    Jordan is raising its cash back rebate for film and TV productions from 20% to 25% after recently hosting Disney’s ‘Aladdin,’ “Star Wars IX, The Rise of Skywalker,” and the Denis Villeneuve-directed “Dune” reboot. Concurrently, the kingdom, which provides one of the few stable environments for filmmaking in the Middle East, has reinstated the Jordan Film [...]

  • Benedict Cumberbatch stars in The Current

    Benedict Cumberbatch's 'Current War' Gets Awards-Season Release

    David Glasser’s 101 Studios is positioning the long-shelved and revamped “The Current War,” starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Michael Shannon, for an awards-season release in October. 101 Studios announced Tuesday that the film would open in limited release on Oct. 4, then go wide on the following weekend. The film presents the story of the “war [...]

  • Just Cause

    'Just Cause' Video Game Getting Movie Adaptation From 'John Wick' Writer

    “Just Cause” is the latest video game getting the movie treatment. Germany’s Constantin Film has acquired movie rights to the “Just Cause” video game franchise and hired “John Wick” creator Derek Kolstad to write the script. Constantin Film’s Robert Kulzer and Prime Universe Films’ Adrian Askarieh will produce the pic with Kolstad, who has written [...]

  • Cannes: Florence Pugh, Francois Civil Honored

    Florence Pugh, Francois Civil Honored With Chopard Award for Rising Talent

    Rising British actress Florence Pugh (“Lady Macbeth”) and French actor Francois Civil (“Wolf’s Call”) received the Chopard Trophy Award at a star-studded ceremony hosted by Chopard on Monday during the Cannes Film Festival. Pugh and Civil were chosen among many actors by a jury consisting of former Chopard Trophy recipients such as Marion Cotillard, Gael [...]

  • Belle Epoque

    Pathé Sells ‘La Belle Epoque’ to Half the World

    French sales, distribution and production company Pathé has closed a raft of sales deals on three titles at the Cannes Film Market: “La Belle Epoque,” “Misbehaviour” and project “Eifel.” The company will handle distribution in France and Switzerland on all three. Nicolas Bedos’ “La Belle Epoque,” which screened out of competition at the festival, is [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content