Pellicano trial temporarily halted

Mistrial motion sets trial back

The Anthony Pellicano trial was brought to an abrupt halt Tuesday as the lawyer for one co-defendant called for a mistrial.

Chad Hummel, the attorney representing former LAPD Sgt. Mark Arneson, filed the motion, arguing that the government had access to and used statements that Arneson made during a 1999 Internal Affairs hearing into his illegal database searches he allegedly conducted for the P.I.

Arneson had been under the impression those confidential statements wouldn’t be used against him during any future criminal proceedings; Hummel argued prosecutors brought up information Arneson provided when they cross-examined him Friday.

Hummel contended he would never have allowed Arneson to testify had he known the prosecution would use the former cop’s words against him. He said he also never knew the government had the statements in their possession and thus requested a dismissal.

Assistant U.S. attorney Daniel Saunders denied the government had heard the Internal Affairs testimony, and argued that any questions asked to Arneson on Friday were never answered, thus making the motion for a mistrial irrelevant.

At first, U.S. District Judge Dale S. Fischer wouldn’t grant the hearing for the mistrial and ordered Hummel to call another witness or put Arneson on the stand again. But she finally budged when Hummel threatened to appeal to the 9th Circuit if the judge didn’t grant a hearing.

The jury was sent home for the day and the hearing took place later that morning.

Yet Judge Fischer ended up ruling against Hummel and Arneson, saying there was no deliberate attempt to reveal to jurors that Arneson had been the subject of an internal affairs investigation, and that prosecutors were not in violation of evidence discovery rules.

High-profile Hollywood attorney Bert Fields was set to testify Tuesday to discuss his ties to Pellicano, considering he hired the P.I. on numerous occasions. He’ll take the stand today.

More Scene

  • Kevin Durant Lindsey Vonn

    Kevin Durant, Lindsey Vonn to Keynote Variety's Sports & Entertainment Breakfast

    The Anthony Pellicano trial was brought to an abrupt halt Tuesday as the lawyer for one co-defendant called for a mistrial. Chad Hummel, the attorney representing former LAPD Sgt. Mark Arneson, filed the motion, arguing that the government had access to and used statements that Arneson made during a 1999 Internal Affairs hearing into his […]

  • Cher and Meryl Streep'Mamma Mia! Here

    How the Cast of 'Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again' Geeked Out Around Cher

    The Anthony Pellicano trial was brought to an abrupt halt Tuesday as the lawyer for one co-defendant called for a mistrial. Chad Hummel, the attorney representing former LAPD Sgt. Mark Arneson, filed the motion, arguing that the government had access to and used statements that Arneson made during a 1999 Internal Affairs hearing into his […]

  • Demi MooreComedy Central's Roast of Bruce

    Demi Moore Appears as Surprise Guest at Bruce Willis' Comedy Central Roast

    The Anthony Pellicano trial was brought to an abrupt halt Tuesday as the lawyer for one co-defendant called for a mistrial. Chad Hummel, the attorney representing former LAPD Sgt. Mark Arneson, filed the motion, arguing that the government had access to and used statements that Arneson made during a 1999 Internal Affairs hearing into his […]

  • Outfest Filmmakers Get Political, Issue Call

    Outfest Filmmakers Get Political, Issue Call to Action on Opening Night

    The Anthony Pellicano trial was brought to an abrupt halt Tuesday as the lawyer for one co-defendant called for a mistrial. Chad Hummel, the attorney representing former LAPD Sgt. Mark Arneson, filed the motion, arguing that the government had access to and used statements that Arneson made during a 1999 Internal Affairs hearing into his […]

  • Bob Woodruff Foundation Acquires Veterans Org

    Bob Woodruff Foundation Acquires Veterans Org Got Your 6

    The Anthony Pellicano trial was brought to an abrupt halt Tuesday as the lawyer for one co-defendant called for a mistrial. Chad Hummel, the attorney representing former LAPD Sgt. Mark Arneson, filed the motion, arguing that the government had access to and used statements that Arneson made during a 1999 Internal Affairs hearing into his […]

  • Tiffany HaddishTiffany Haddish at the Hollywood

    Tiffany Haddish on Future Career Plans, Taking Advice From Tyler Perry, Melissa McCarthy

    The Anthony Pellicano trial was brought to an abrupt halt Tuesday as the lawyer for one co-defendant called for a mistrial. Chad Hummel, the attorney representing former LAPD Sgt. Mark Arneson, filed the motion, arguing that the government had access to and used statements that Arneson made during a 1999 Internal Affairs hearing into his […]

  • Vince Gilligan Carolyn Strauss Paley Center

    'Breaking Bad' Creator Vince Gilligan Suggests 'Maybe It's Time for Heroes Again' on TV

    The Anthony Pellicano trial was brought to an abrupt halt Tuesday as the lawyer for one co-defendant called for a mistrial. Chad Hummel, the attorney representing former LAPD Sgt. Mark Arneson, filed the motion, arguing that the government had access to and used statements that Arneson made during a 1999 Internal Affairs hearing into his […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content