×

The Staircase Murders

Treat Williams is effectively enigmatic as the egotistical Michael Peterson, an acclaimed novelist on trial for the murder of his socialite wife in "The Staircase Murders," an original pic for Lifetime. Add big money woes to the salacious combination of sex, lies and videotape and you've got solid drama. Ultimately, however, the film never really takes a definitive stance on whether the truth has been served so much as it's been skewered, flambeed and eventually overcooked.

With:
Michael Peterson - Treat Williams Caitlin Atwater - Samaire Armstrong David Rudolf - Kevin Pollak Erica - Kate Donadio Todd - Brandon Olive Margaret - Laura Bailey Clayton - Kyle Clements Martha - Stephanie Honore Bill - Ric Reitz Kathleen - Nina Jones Detective Joe Castell - Brett Rice

Treat Williams is effectively enigmatic as the egotistical Michael Peterson, an acclaimed novelist on trial for the murder of his socialite wife in “The Staircase Murders,” an original pic for Lifetime. Add big money woes to the salacious combination of sex, lies and videotape and you’ve got solid drama. Ultimately, however, the film never really takes a definitive stance on whether the truth has been served so much as it’s been skewered, flambeed and eventually overcooked.

Based on “The Perfect Husband,” by Aphrodite Jones, the movie takes a provocative look at the case as it plays out in court as well as within the Peterson family. The true-life details were sensational enough to inspire two novels, an eight-part Sundance Channel documentary as well as specials for “Dateline NBC” and Court TV, so the story certainly makes natural TV-movie fodder.

On paper, Peterson makes for an ideal husband and father and talented writer. A bestselling novelist and ex-Marine, Peterson lives in a swanky house in Durham, N.C., with his successful businesswoman wife Kathleen (Nina Jones) and their blended families.

In a frantic call late one December night in 2001, Peterson tells the police that his wife fell down the steps after a night of drinking. First on the scene is Det. Joe Castell (Brett Rice), who is immediately skeptical of Peterson’s story given the large quantity of blood at the crime scene. Conflicting opinions abound, but Castell makes no attempt to hide his suspicions or his disdain for Peterson, a former mayoral candidate and open critic of Durham’s police department. Regardless of all of the speculation, the family quickly rallies around Peterson, including Caitlin (Samaire Armstrong), Kathleen’s college-age daughter from a previous marriage. Michael had been a supportive father figure to her and shared her concerns over her mother’s drinking habits. As the police mount their case and decide to charge him, Peterson hires slick defense attorney David Rudolf (Kevin Pollak), who brings with him a documentary film crew with unlimited access to record the events.

As tales of financial troubles begin to surface along with evidence of Peterson’s bisexual affairs, Caitlin develops doubts about her stepfather. Her mother’s autopsy reveals disturbing evidence that contradicts Peterson’s account, and when it comes to light that an old family friend and mother of the two teenage girls in Peterson’s custody died in a remarkably similar staircase accident, Caitlin can’t help but suspect Peterson.

While emotions rage between Caitlin and the family, Pollak’s Rudolf is the surprising middle ground. He never seems to judge Peterson’s duplicitous life even as more startling evidence comes to light. Instead, one can practically see the gears shifting as he plans on how to spin it all to the jury.

In the meantime, Peterson seems to be doing his own spinning for the benefit of the cameras — pompously reciting Shakespeare passages, offering retakes and direction to an increasingly uneasy documentary crew. If Peterson isn’t a murderer, he is, at the very least, a master manipulator. His abject denial, even as his defense case seemingly falls apart, is a marvel. Williams, with his Cheshire smirk and oozing condescension, is one of the few actors who can pull off a scholarly dinnertime lecture rationalizing his bisexual affairs. He tells them in his best Andy Brown voice how sex between soldiers was often encouraged in ancient Greece to insure battlefield loyalty.

Williams and Pollak serve the pic well, elevating the movie from the usual Lifetime telepic sensibility, to which director Tom McLoughlin too often falls prey. He does however, give it his own distinct, horror-background touch with a couple of fade-to-deep-red commercial breaks and a particularly violent dream sequence featuring buckets of blood cascading down stairs. They’re unnecessary stunts considering it’s the repetitive shots of the boarded up crime scene that really illicit the chills.

Still, McLoughlin and writer Donald Martin do a nice job of slowly unfolding the sordid details of Peterson’s life to allow alternately for rationalizations and realizations.

The Staircase Murders

Lifetime, Sun., April 15, 8 p.m.

Production: Filmed on location in New Orleans by Lionsgate Television in association with Lifetime Television. Executive producer, Judy Polone; producer, Judy Cairo; co-producer, Aphrodite Jones, director, Tom McLoughlin; writer, Donald Martin;

Crew: camera, Lloyd Ahern II; editor, Marshall Harvey, music, Joseph Loduca; casting, John Papsidera, Shay Griffin. Running time: 2 hours.

Cast: Michael Peterson - Treat Williams Caitlin Atwater - Samaire Armstrong David Rudolf - Kevin Pollak Erica - Kate Donadio Todd - Brandon Olive Margaret - Laura Bailey Clayton - Kyle Clements Martha - Stephanie Honore Bill - Ric Reitz Kathleen - Nina Jones Detective Joe Castell - Brett Rice

More TV

  • Michael Ellenberg, Jennifer Aniston, Reese Witherspoon,

    'The Morning Show' Team on Steve Carell's Season 2 Future, Season 1 Criticism

    Although the first season of “The Morning Show” ended on Steve Carell’s former news anchor character, Mitch Kessler, who was fired at the top of the season amid sexual misconduct allegations, finally feeling the weight of what he did, there is no guarantee the second season will see him learn, grow or be around at [...]

  • Kumail Nanjiani

    Kumail Nanjiani on Not Wanting 'Little America' to Focus on the Political System

    Apple TV Plus’s anthology drama “Little America” may not be about politics, but by telling tales of immigrants in a polarizing time, many people feel there is a political undercurrent to its themes. “It is amazing that we are living in a time where kindness, empathy, humanity and shared experience feels like a political statement,” [...]

  • Apple TV Plus Renews 'Mythic Quest:

    Apple TV Plus Renews 'Mythic Quest: Raven's Banquet' Ahead of Series Premiere

    Rob McElhenney, Charlie Day and Megan Ganz’s “Mythic Quest: Raven’s Banquet” has been renewed for a second season ahead of its series debut, Apple TV Plus announced Sunday. The half-hour comedy follows a team of developers as they navigate the challenges of running a popular video game. It was inspired by McElhenney’s visit to Ubisoft’s [...]

  • Apple TV Plus Home Before Dark

    Apple TV Plus Mystery 'Home Before Dark' Renewed for Season 2 Ahead of Series Premiere

    “Home Before Dark,” Apple TV Plus’ mystery series inspired by the real-life reporting of 9-year-old investigative journalist Hilde Lysiak, has nabbed an early Season 2 renewal ahead of its series premiere on April 3. Directed and executive produced by Jon M. Chu and created by showrunners and exec producers Dana Fox and Dara Resnik, the [...]

  • 911 Lone Star rob Lowe

    '9-1-1: Lone Star': TV Review

    In some ways, Rob Lowe is a fit for the Ryan Murphy universe. Something about his actorly vanity — so much a part of his star persona that it tends to impact every project he works on — feels lurid and unseemly in exactly the bad-taste way as does much of Murphy’s work. A plotline, [...]

  • Asa Butterfield in Netflix's Sex Education

    Netflix & Sky Strike Multi-Year Deal To Keep Streamer On Service

    Comcast-owned pay-TV operator Sky and Netflix have hammered out a new multi-year deal to keep content from the streaming giant on the service.  Under the new deal, customers of Sky’s set-top box service Sky Q will have the option to opt in for Netflix’s basic plan, which is priced locally at £5.99 ($7.99) per month. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content