×

What If God Were the Sun?

If Lifetime hopes to continue its ratings climb and refresh its image to match its new front office, this original film isn't going to help matters much. If anything, "What if God Were the Sun?" is exactly the kind of movie that often makes the net a punchline for chick flick jokes.

With:
Jamie Spagnoletti - Lacey Chabert Jeff - Sam Trammell Rachel - Sarah Rafferty Carmen - Klea Scott Lupe - Amanda Brugel Katherine - Diana Reis Maricela - Kim Roberts Alma - Maria Ricossa Melissa Eisenbloom - Gena Rowlands

If Lifetime hopes to continue its ratings climb and refresh its image to match its new front office, this original film isn’t going to help matters much. If anything, “What if God Were the Sun?” is exactly the kind of movie that often makes the net a punchline for chick flick jokes.

When based on the right material, Lifetime has proven its movies can deliver the goods. This pic, based on TV psychic John Edward’s novel of posthumous family relationships, has a plot about as solid as the ghostly apparitions with whom he supposedly converses. Not that paranormal activity is anything to scoff at — tales of the afterlife have made for some compelling movies, and viewers have shown a distinct fascination with the subject. But it’s almost as if director Stephen Tolkin and scribes Janet Dulin Jones and Jamie Pachino want viewers to believe that if you don’t have a connection with your departed loved ones, then something is wrong.

Lacey Chabert, a poor man’s Jennifer Love Hewitt, stars as Jamie Spagnoletti, who is less Ghost Whisperer than Ghost Shrieker. As a harried ER nurse who is also trying to plan her own wedding, her life skills seem maxed out by seating chart arrangements.

When her policeman father dies in the ER room right next to where she’s working on an elderly female patient, Jamie loses a lot more than her composure. Mainly, she’s mad at herself for wasting time and energy on saving the old woman when she could have made amends with her estranged father. So much for bedside manner.

Still, she throws herself into settling her father’s affairs, as well as the wedding planning, with frenetic determination. Jamie’s grief, however, quickly spirals into borderline medical incompetence amid some cringe-worthy overacting by Chabert. She’s soon kicked out of the ER and sent to work in long-term care.

There, she meets the feisty Mrs. Eisenbloom (Gena Rowlands), an advanced cancer patient in search of a home nurse. Eisenbloom’s daughter Rachel (Sarah Rafferty) is at odds with her mom because she’s given up the thought of more aggressive treatment. Rachel isn’t ready to let go of her mother, while Jamie doesn’t seem to care much about anyone.

Jamie’s made such a shambles of her own life, postponing the wedding and embarrassing herself at the hospital, that she accepts the home nursing gig — but not Mrs. Eisenbloom’s plucky outlook on life and death.

Turns out Jamie is a tough nut to crack sentimentally. When Mrs. Eisenbloom tries to explain to Jamie her thoughts of life after death, Jamie tells her, “You’re just saying that because you’re dying and you want it to be true.” Ouch.

Rowlands is easily the best thing about the pic, and faces its many challenges, including cliches and colossally bad dialogue, with her reputation fairly unscathed.

Why is it, though, that a zest for life is the cinematic equivalent of a kooky hat collection? Ultimately even Rowland’s presence can’t save the film from its own overwrought emotions and preposterous posthumous allusions. Perhaps the dead are always with us, but they would surely be grateful to miss this one.

What If God Were the Sun?

Lifetime, Mon. May 14, 9 p.m.

Production: Filmed on location in Canada by Fox Television Studios, JECO Prods. and Old Beantown Films for Lifetime Television. Executive producers, John Edward, Brenda Friend, Gina Rugolo Judd; producer, Greg Copeland; director, Stephen Tolkin; writers, Janet Dulin Jones, Jamie Pachino based in part on the novel by John Edward;

Crew: Camera, Robin Loewen; editor, Gib Jaffe; music, Laura Karpman; casting, Felicia Fasano, Forrest & Forrest Casting. Running time: 120 MIN.

Cast: Jamie Spagnoletti - Lacey Chabert Jeff - Sam Trammell Rachel - Sarah Rafferty Carmen - Klea Scott Lupe - Amanda Brugel Katherine - Diana Reis Maricela - Kim Roberts Alma - Maria Ricossa Melissa Eisenbloom - Gena Rowlands

More TV

  • Liz Garbus on Why We May

    Liz Garbus on Why The World May Never Know 'Who Killed Garrett Phillips'

    By the time Liz Garbus’s two-part documentary “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?” debuts on HBO, there could be a new public lead in the case of the murdered titular 12-year-old. As least, that’s what many may hope after the new St. Lawrence County district attorney admitted a new tip earlier this spring. Garbus says she would [...]

  • Mike Fleiss

    'Bachelor' Producers in Wait-and-See Mode Amid Police Probe Into Fleiss Incident

    Those working on “The Bachelor” and its sister shows are in wait-and-see mode as a domestic incident involving creator Mike Fleiss continues to be investigated in Kauai, according to sources close to production. The results of the police investigation are still pending, after Fleiss’ wife, Laura Fleiss, had accused him of attacking her in their [...]

  • Variety Cord Cutting Placeholder Cable

    Cable Blackouts Growing More Common, Even If Subscribers Get Angry

    Among media companies, “going dark” was once a matter of last resort. Now it’s an option that is seeing more light. CBS is not currently available on DirecTV or AT&T’s U-verse, the result of a battle over how much the two outlets’ owner, AT&T, ought to pay for the right to send CBS into millions [...]

  • maria elena salinas

    CBS News Names Maria Elena Salinas Contributor

    Maria Elena Salinas, one of the best-known anchors in Spanish-language broadcasting, will join CBS News as a contributor, Susan Zirinsky, the unit’s president, told staffers Monday. Salinas stepped down from her role at Univision at the end of 2017 after an on-air tenure of more than three decades. She is expected to contribute reports across [...]

  • Jonathan Taylor Thomas Ed Asner Elliott

    Jonathan Taylor Thomas, Ed Asner, Elliott Gould Seek SAG-AFTRA Board Seats

    Ed Asner, Elliott Gould and Jonathan Taylor Thomas are seeking SAG-AFTRA national board seats as members of presidential candidate Matthew Modine’s progressive Membership First slate. Asner is the former president of the Screen Actors Guild, serving two terms from 1981 to 1985, and winning five Emmys for his role as Lou Grant and two others [...]

  • Markella Kavenagh

    'Lord of the Rings' Series at Amazon Taps First Cast Member (EXCLUSIVE)

    The upcoming “Lord of the Rings” series at Amazon has made its first casting decision. Variety has learned from multiple sources that Markella Kavenagh is in talks for a role in the upcoming epic fantasy series. Details of Kavenagh’s characters are being kept under wraps, but sources say she would be playing a character named [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content