You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

The War

"The War" reps Ken Burns' return to the battlefield, and he comes away with a major victory for PBS.

With: Adam Arkin, Bobby Cannavale, Kevin Conway, Tom Hanks, Rebecca Holtz, Samuel L. Jackson, Josh Lucas, Carolyn McCormick, Robert Wahlberg, Eli Wallach.

A monumental undertaking filled with moments of tremendous poignancy, “The War” reps Ken Burns’ return to the battlefield, and he comes away with a major victory for PBS, albeit in a production lacking the thrill of discovery and freshness that distinguished its predecessor, “The Civil War.” Methodically documenting World War II’s progression chronologically through the experiences of those in four geographically spaced towns, “The War” captures both the sweeping impact of a conflict that inexorably changed the world and the hardships endured by those who fought the battle at home as well as abroad.

In part, this seven-night, 15-hour marathon is victimized by just how much screentime has already been devoted to these events, making it easy to let one’s mind drift to some movie or documentary — “Saving Private Ryan,” “Band of Brothers,” “Patton,” etc. — chronicling a given aspect of the story. From that perspective, “The Civil War” benefited from the bracing approach of using letters and stills to document a prevideo conflict.

Still, Burns and collaborators Lynn Novick and Geoffrey C. Ward unearth breathtaking new footage (much of it in color) and flesh out the imagery with on-camera testimony from those who survived the war, creating a fitting tribute to how ordinary people can respond — in ways inspiring and heartbreaking — to extraordinary times.

To that extent, this has the sense of a definitive work, one that will speak not only to the World War II generation but to those who have lived under the blanket of their sacrifice — provided that PBS can entice a younger audience to tune in.

The most significant quibble here is structural. By proceeding in chronological fashion, Burns deals with part of a soldier’s experience and then abandons him, rapidly shifting from the home front — in the towns of Mobile, Ala.; Luverne, Minn.; Sacramento, Calif.; and Waterbury, Conn. — to the European theater to the Pacific. As such, just when some stories begin to get interesting, that character is left, only to be returned to hours (and given the broadcast pattern, nights) later.

Far from whitewashing the war or seeking to shower those who fought in glory, Burns and Novick endeavor to present the conflict in all its “unimaginable brutality,” as narrator Keith David soberly intones, costing the lives of anywhere from 50 million to 60 million people.

Those interviewed recall the long-ago events in riveting detail, often breaking down at the memories. “We had no rights,” says Asako Tukuno, a Japanese-American college student when she was shipped off to an internment camp.

“The War” starts slowly, partially mirroring the U.S.’ lack of preparedness, with a puny standing army before 1940 and scant ability to supply its forces — deficiencies that were met and overcome with remarkable ingenuity. The narrative gains momentum as the Americans learn to fight, peaking in the third, fourth and seventh installments.

Despite the evenhanded tone, the segments are punctuated by emotional highs — the letters of a slain soldier (“Nothing ever happens here,” he reassuringly tells his worried mother), the recollections of fighter pilot Quentin Aanenson and the astonishing bravery of Daniel Inouye, a member of the much-decorated Japanese-American 442nd unit and later six-term senator from Hawaii who lost his arm while single-handedly dispatching a trio of German machine-gun nests.

Both combatants and filmmakers endeavor to demythologize war where, they stress, no amount of skill, courage or athleticism could ensure survival. “The shell hit somebody who was not yourself,” recalls one soldier, adding “pure luck” often determined who lived or died.

Many of the images are haunting: the D-Day landing, made more surreal by knowing this is actual footage, not a Steven Spielberg production; the ferocity and enormous casualties of the Japanese at Okinawa; the corpses of barely pubescent boys in German uniforms, as young and old alike were desperately conscripted as the war wound down; bodies strewn at meaningless battles; the leveling of Dresden; footage of shell-shocked soldiers; the discovery of the Nazi death camps; the devastation of Hiroshima.

“I live in a world of death,” Aanenson, a soft-spoken Minnesotan, writes to his fiance, whom he had met during the war and asked to wait for him. “I am not the same person you said goodbye to.”

Inevitably, not everything works quite so well, such as having Tom Hanks read the words of a Minnesota newspaper columnist, which feels saccharine and predictable. Given the length, more time could also have been devoted to the war’s immediate aftermath, such as the way Mobile’s black population came home to unabated prejudice and segregation, which helped give rise to the civil rights movement.

It’s worth mentioning, too, that prebroadcast complaints about the film overlooking Hispanics, criticism which Burns addressed by incorporating additional material, seem misguided. Even at 15 hours, Burns cannot tell every story, and the format is constructed around linear time and geography, with the various stories regarding African-Americans and Japanese-Americans (the latter interred at home while sons and siblings valiantly fought in Europe) growing organically out of that approach.

As controversies go, then, the tempest in this teapot contains a weaker brew than most — one of the few places, actually, where the term “weak” can be used in conjunction with “The War.”

Popular on Variety

The War

PBS, Mon. Sept. 23, 8 p.m.

Production: Produced by Florentine Films. Producers, Ken Burns, Lynn Novick, Sarah Botstein; co-producers, Peter Miller, David McMahon; directors, Burns, Novick; writer, Geoffrey C. Ward.

Crew: Camera, Buddy Squires; supervising editor, Paul Barnes; editors, Tricia Reidy, Erik Ewers; music, Wynton Marsalis. 15 HOURS.

Cast: With: Adam Arkin, Bobby Cannavale, Kevin Conway, Tom Hanks, Rebecca Holtz, Samuel L. Jackson, Josh Lucas, Carolyn McCormick, Robert Wahlberg, Eli Wallach.Narrator: Keith David.

More TV

  • Laverne Cox arrives at the 71st

    Laverne Cox Raises Awareness About LGBTQ Supreme Court Case With Rainbow-Colored Purse

    “Orange is the New Black” actress Laverne Cox strutted down the purple carpet at the 71st Primetime Emmy Awards flaunting a small, rainbow-colored purse with the words “Oct. 8, Title VII Supreme Court” across the front. “Oct. 8 there’s an incredibly important case going to the Supreme Court involving Title VII,” she told Variety as [...]

  • Phoebe Waller-Bridge accepts the award for

    Emmys Surprise: Phoebe Waller-Bridge Wins Lead Actress in a Comedy

    Phoebe Waller-Bridge won the 2019 lead comedy actress Emmy for her titular role on Amazon Prime Video’s “Fleabag.” Waller-Bridge created the streaming series in which she also stars and was also nominated in the comedy writing category this year (the show was also up for comedy series overall). Her MI6 drama “Killing Eve” was also [...]

  • Alex Borstein Emmys

    Emmys: Alex Borstein Pays Tribute to Grandmother Who Survived the Holocaust

    After winning the supporting comedy actress Emmy for the second year in a row, “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” star Alex Borstein paid tribute to her grandmother, a Holocaust survivor, in a powerful speech. She started by thanking a number of women, including “Maisel” creator Amy Sherman-Palladino and the cast and crew of the Amazon Prime [...]

  • The Politician - Ben Platt

    Netflix Drops Final 'The Politician' Trailer (Watch)

    As Netflix is busy battling HBO on stage for Emmys supremacy, the streamer also released the final trailer for Ryan Murphy’s latest series “The Politician.” The series centers around Payton Hobart (Ben Platt), an aspiring politician from Santa Barbara, California who must navigate the ins and outs of high school if he’s to ever win [...]

  • Atmosphere71st Primetime Emmy Awards Nominations Announcement,

    Emmy Awards 2019: The Complete Winners List (Updating Live)

    Television’s biggest night is currently underway at the Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles. HBO’s “Game of Thrones” and Amazon’s “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” are expected to be big winners at the 2019 Emmy Awards, but a handful of small-screen favorites are also vying for top prizes. Among drama series, the epic conclusion to HBO’s “Game [...]

  • Bethenny Frankel arrives at the 71st

    Bethenny Frankel Reveals Her New Slate of 'Female-Centric' Shows For MGM

    Reality star Bethenny Frankel is still staying busy after announcing her plans to exit the “Real Housewives” franchise last month. She left because she wanted to “explore my next chapter,” and entered a production partnership with Mark Burnett and MGM television. “Most of them happen to be female-centric,” she said on the Emmys purple carpet [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content