×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

John From Cincinnati

"John From Cincinnati" might be the strangest show ever produced for American television -- an HBO drama that makes "Twin Peaks" look like "Mayberry RFD." Yet even worshippers at the altar of writer extraordinaire David Milch are likely to find themselves bewildered and frustrated with the premiere, and two subsequent episodes only marginally improve matters.

With:
Cissy Yost - Rebecca De Mornay Dr. Smith - Garret Dillahunt Shaun Yost - Greyson Fletcher Meyer Dickstein - Willie Garson Mitch Yost - Bruce Greenwood Ramon Gaviota - Luis Guzman Kai - Keala Kennelly John - Austin Nichols Bill Jacks - Ed O'Neill Linc Stark - Luke Perry Butchie Yost - Brian Van Holt Barry Cunningham - Matt Winston

“John From Cincinnati” might be the strangest show ever produced for American television — an HBO drama that makes “Twin Peaks” look like “Mayberry RFD.” Yet even worshippers at the altar of writer extraordinaire David Milch are likely to find themselves bewildered and frustrated with the premiere, and two subsequent episodes only marginally improve matters. It’s easy to admire the hypnotic poetry in Milch’s dialogue, but this existential surfing fantasy — infused with a touch of “Starman” — dips and swerves amid its confounding currents, and hardly appears like the standard-bearer to help lead the pay service into a post-“Sopranos” future.

Indeed, fans of Milch’s “Deadwood” (notably, a few members of that show’s cast show up here) might wonder what possessed HBO to inadvertently hasten the foul-mouthed Western’s demise to liberate the producer to pursue this perplexing, messy bit of whimsy inspired by surf novelist (and series co-creator) Kem Nunn.

Built around three generations of surfers, the show’s patriarch is Mitch Yost (Bruce Greenwood), a wave-conquering legend whose son, Butchie (Brian Van Holt), was equally promising before the high life got the best of him and he became a junkie. Mitch and his wife Cissy (Rebecca De Mornay) thus care for their grandson Shaun (Greyson Fletcher), another surfing prodigy who Mitch desperately wants to protect from Butchie’s fame-driven fall and the leeches (including a surf promoter played by Luke Perry) that would latch onto him.

Into this fractured family drama descends John (Austin Nichols), a messianic figure who mostly seems to parrot what others say to him. Once John arrives, strange things start occurring — from Butchie feeling no dope sickness to Mitch inexplicably levitating a few inches off the ground.

“Some things I know, and some things I don’t,” John repeats with childlike simplicity. Butchie guesses he’s from Cincinnati — hence the title — whereas the audience is left to ponder whether the fresh-faced lad comes from outer space, Heaven or somewhere else equally exotic.

If the show quit there, it would be maddening enough, but Milch tosses in family friend Bill (Ed O’Neill) and a peculiar, suicidal lottery winner (Matt Winston) that won’t earn any prizes from GLAAD, along with other quirky characters whose larger contribution remains fuzzy at best. For his part, John seemingly wants Mitch to surf again (“get back in the game,” as he puts it), but where the narrative flows is anybody’s guess, and after three hallucinatory hours, I’m not really sure I care.

Part of that is because the characters prove almost uniformly unpleasant beyond the serene John, barking and squabbling in obscenity-laced exchanges that awkwardly wed “NYPD Blue’s” terse cop-talk with “Deadwood’s” frontier barbarism. Mitch and Cissy — while well-played by Greenwood and De Mornay — are particularly poor company, even with their understandable anger at Butchie and the world at large.

In a sense, “John From Cincinnati” represents the ultimate leap of creative faith — with HBO having banked on Milch and Nunn to locate a TV series at the heart of this acid flashback. Perhaps they eventually will, but unless the audience is surprisingly tolerant and forgiving, by the time that ship comes in, most of those who tested the waters will have drifted away.

John From Cincinnati

HBO, Sun. June 10, 10 p.m.

Production: Filmed in Imperial Beach, Calif., by Red Board Prods. and HBO Entertainment. Executive producers, David Milch, Gregg Fienberg, Zvi Howard Rosenman, Mark Tinker; co-executive producers, Kem Nunn, Peter Spears, Scott Stephens; producer, Ted Mann; director, Tinker; writers, Milch, Nunn.

Crew: Camera, Joseph E. Gallagher, Uta Briesewitz; editor, Martin Nicholson; music, Johnny Klimek, Reinhold Heil; production designer, Maria Caso; casting, June Lowry Johnson, Libby Goldstein. 60 MIN.

Cast: Cissy Yost - Rebecca De Mornay Dr. Smith - Garret Dillahunt Shaun Yost - Greyson Fletcher Meyer Dickstein - Willie Garson Mitch Yost - Bruce Greenwood Ramon Gaviota - Luis Guzman Kai - Keala Kennelly John - Austin Nichols Bill Jacks - Ed O'Neill Linc Stark - Luke Perry Butchie Yost - Brian Van Holt Barry Cunningham - Matt Winston

More TV

  • HIGHWIRE LIVE IN TIMES SQUARE WITH

    TV News Roundup: 'Highwire Live in Times Square' Tops Sunday Night Ratings

    In today’s TV news roundup, ABC’s “Highwire Live in Times Square” tops Sunday night ratings, and “Total Bellas” has been renewed for a fifth season. DATES FX will air the special event “Peabody Presents: Stories of the Year” on July 7. The program will showcase the issues honored at the 78th Annual Peabody Awards Ceremony [...]

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    'Scream' Series Moves From MTV to VH1 for July Debut

    The long-gestating third season of the “Scream” series is finally debuting–but not on its original network. Variety has confirmed that the series will air on VH1 instead of MTV as originally planned. “Scream” will debut on VH1 on July 8 and air two one-hour episodes back-to-back for three straight nights. The third season of the [...]

  • Jussie Smollett

    Video of Jussie Smollett With Rope Around His Neck Released by Chicago Police

    The Chicago Police Department released new surveillance footage and files in regards to the Jussie Smollett hoax case on Monday, including one that shows the “Empire” actor shortly after the alleged attack. In one of the videos, police body-cam footage shows authorities entering Smollett’s Chicago apartment, led by his manager, Frank Gatson. Smollett is found [...]

  • rachel brosnahan Variety Cover Story

    Rachel Brosnahan Signs First-Look Deal With Amazon Studios

    Rachel Brosnahan is deepening her relationship with Amazon. The “Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” star has signed a first-look deal with Amazon Studios, under which she and her Scrap Paper Pictures production company will develop TV series exclusively for Amazon’s streaming platform. Brosnahan has won several awards for her performance as Midge Maisel, including an Emmy Award [...]

  • Kevin Costner stars as John Dutton

    'Yellowstone' Season 2 Premiere Ratings More Than Double in Delayed Viewing

    The Season 2 premiere of “Yellowstone” more than doubled its Live+Same Day numbers in Live+3. According to Nielsen data, the premiere last Wednesday rose to a 0.98 rating in adults 18-49 and just over 5 million total viewers after three days of playback. That is up 115% in the demo and 109% in viewers from [...]

  • Malaka

    Conecta Fiction 2019: 10 Takeaways

    MADRID  —  The 3rd Conecta Fiction, Europe’s biggest Latin American TV co-production forum, wrapped last week in Pamplona after four days of dealing, debate and gastronomic delectation. Following 10 Takeaways from an intense and buoyant event, driven by the unfaltering growth of high-end production in Spain and most of Latin America: 1.PLATFORM PIVOT  The writing [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content