You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Hollywood still the butt of criticism

Some anti-smokers say MPAA not doing enough

Where there’s smoke, there’s ire.

Make no mistake, the MPAA’s announcement last week that smoking would become another factor in deciding the ratings of movies drew kudos from a range of child advocacy and health organizations that have long wanted such action.

But it could also be another example of damned if you do, damned if you don’t.

Some advocacy groups had been pushing for an automatic R rating for any film that depicts smoking, regardless of the context.

Two of the harshest critics of cigarette smoking onscreen — the American Legacy Foundation and Smoke Free Movies — dismissed the MPAA effort as not going nearly far enough.

“Wholly inadequate and will cost countless lives,” said ALF, which also disputed several of MPAA’s statistics.

SFM blasted the MPAA’s statement that historical context would have to be included in any evaluation of a movie rating.

” ‘Titanic’ was full of women smoking, but virtually no women smoked at the time,” says SFM director Stan Glantz. “And only rich men smoked. Leo DiCaprio‘s character would not have smoked.”

That kind of complaint is likely to resonate with directors and others, who in the past have knocked the MPAA ratings system in general as arbitrary and vague.

While ALF and SFM have pressed for automatic R ratings on movies with any smoking, MPAA topper Dan Glickman said that would be “extreme.”

No doubt true. But it would also be unequivocally clear.

Meaning if the MPAA were to do it, somebody’s bound to complain.

More News

  • ECAM Incubator Documentary Project ‘The Garcias’

    A Look at ECAM Incubator Documentary Project ‘The Garcias’

    Where there’s smoke, there’s ire. Make no mistake, the MPAA’s announcement last week that smoking would become another factor in deciding the ratings of movies drew kudos from a range of child advocacy and health organizations that have long wanted such action. But it could also be another example of damned if you do, damned […]

  • Coincoin and the Extra Humans

    San Sebastian Debates New TV Landscape

    Where there’s smoke, there’s ire. Make no mistake, the MPAA’s announcement last week that smoking would become another factor in deciding the ratings of movies drew kudos from a range of child advocacy and health organizations that have long wanted such action. But it could also be another example of damned if you do, damned […]

  • Emma Suarez'April's Daughter' photocall, 70th Cannes

    Inside Content Takes Emma Suárez Starrer ‘Josefina’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    Where there’s smoke, there’s ire. Make no mistake, the MPAA’s announcement last week that smoking would become another factor in deciding the ratings of movies drew kudos from a range of child advocacy and health organizations that have long wanted such action. But it could also be another example of damned if you do, damned […]

  • ECAM Incubator’s Daniel Castro On Catfish

    ECAM Incubator Participant Daniel Castro On Catfish Comedy ‘Old Man In Love’

    Where there’s smoke, there’s ire. Make no mistake, the MPAA’s announcement last week that smoking would become another factor in deciding the ratings of movies drew kudos from a range of child advocacy and health organizations that have long wanted such action. But it could also be another example of damned if you do, damned […]

  • Dezenove Produced, Paula Kim’s ‘Butterfly Diaries’

    San Sebastian: Exploring Teen Angst in Brazil’s ‘Butterfly Diaries’

    Where there’s smoke, there’s ire. Make no mistake, the MPAA’s announcement last week that smoking would become another factor in deciding the ratings of movies drew kudos from a range of child advocacy and health organizations that have long wanted such action. But it could also be another example of damned if you do, damned […]

  • Ozzy Osbourne Drops Lawsuit Against AEG

    Ozzy Osbourne Drops Lawsuit Against AEG

    Where there’s smoke, there’s ire. Make no mistake, the MPAA’s announcement last week that smoking would become another factor in deciding the ratings of movies drew kudos from a range of child advocacy and health organizations that have long wanted such action. But it could also be another example of damned if you do, damned […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content