With a Girl of Black Soil

A bleak tale of an out-of-work miner's family in a wintry South Korean province, pic has some well-composed lensing going for it, but almost zilch on the dramatic side. This is pure fest fare that won't travel far beyond specialty Euro outings.

With:
With: Yu Yun-mi, Jo Yeong-jin, Park Hyeon-woo, Gang Su-yun, Jin Yim-taek, Yu Sun-cheol.

A bleak tale of an out-of-work miner’s family in a wintry South Korean province, clumsily titled “With a Girl of Black Soil” has some well-composed lensing going for it, but almost zilch on the dramatic side. Cute tyke lead Yu Yun-mi, as the daughter through whose eyes the pic unfolds, partly sustains interest, but this is pure fest fare that won’t travel far beyond specialty Euro outings. Film school direction by writer-director Jeon Soo-il (“The Bird Who Stops in the Air”) is a compendium of arty cliches that lacks originality.

Nine-year-old Yeong-lim (Yu) has a slightly older brother, Dong-gu (Park Hyeon-woo), who’s mentally handicapped, and a father, Hye-geon (Jo Yeong-jin), who’s lost his job in the mines and received no compensation. Add to that the family’s simple home is skedded for demolition and neighbors are moving away. While dad sits around drinking and looking depressed, Yeong-lim tries to keep the family going by stealing food and arranging for Dong-gu to attend a specialist school. But her solution for her father’s health problems has deadly consequences. Long silences and harshly beautiful landscapes are no substitute for the stultifying lack of drama.

With a Girl of Black Soil

South Korea

Production: A Dongnyuk Film production. (International sales: Dongnyuk, Busan.) Produced by Jo In-suk. Executive producer, Park Jin-weon. Directed by Jeon Soo-il. Screenplay, Jeon, Jeong Sun-yeong; story, Jeon.

Crew: Camera (color), Kim Seong-tae; editor, Seo Yong-deok; music, Gae Su-jeong; costume designer, Nam Hyeon-suk. Reviewed at Venice Film Festival (Horizons, competing), Sept. 1, 2007. Original title: Geomneun ddangui sonyeowa. Running time: 87 MIN.

With: With: Yu Yun-mi, Jo Yeong-jin, Park Hyeon-woo, Gang Su-yun, Jin Yim-taek, Yu Sun-cheol.

More Film

  • Cher and Meryl Streep'Mamma Mia! Here

    How the Cast of 'Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again' Geeked Out Around Cher

    A bleak tale of an out-of-work miner’s family in a wintry South Korean province, clumsily titled “With a Girl of Black Soil” has some well-composed lensing going for it, but almost zilch on the dramatic side. Cute tyke lead Yu Yun-mi, as the daughter through whose eyes the pic unfolds, partly sustains interest, but this […]

  • 'BuyBust' Review

    Film Review: ‘BuyBust’

    A bleak tale of an out-of-work miner’s family in a wintry South Korean province, clumsily titled “With a Girl of Black Soil” has some well-composed lensing going for it, but almost zilch on the dramatic side. Cute tyke lead Yu Yun-mi, as the daughter through whose eyes the pic unfolds, partly sustains interest, but this […]

  • John Malone

    John Malone, Scott Paterson Retiring From Lionsgate Board

    A bleak tale of an out-of-work miner’s family in a wintry South Korean province, clumsily titled “With a Girl of Black Soil” has some well-composed lensing going for it, but almost zilch on the dramatic side. Cute tyke lead Yu Yun-mi, as the daughter through whose eyes the pic unfolds, partly sustains interest, but this […]

  • Moviepass

    MoviePass Parent's Stock Plunges Again to Record Low

    A bleak tale of an out-of-work miner’s family in a wintry South Korean province, clumsily titled “With a Girl of Black Soil” has some well-composed lensing going for it, but almost zilch on the dramatic side. Cute tyke lead Yu Yun-mi, as the daughter through whose eyes the pic unfolds, partly sustains interest, but this […]

  • Timothee Chalamet

    Timothee Chalamet in Talks to Star in Denis Villeneuve's 'Dune'

    A bleak tale of an out-of-work miner’s family in a wintry South Korean province, clumsily titled “With a Girl of Black Soil” has some well-composed lensing going for it, but almost zilch on the dramatic side. Cute tyke lead Yu Yun-mi, as the daughter through whose eyes the pic unfolds, partly sustains interest, but this […]

  • Taraji P Henson Sam Rockwell

    Taraji P. Henson-Sam Rockwell Drama 'Best of Enemies' Bought by STX

    A bleak tale of an out-of-work miner’s family in a wintry South Korean province, clumsily titled “With a Girl of Black Soil” has some well-composed lensing going for it, but almost zilch on the dramatic side. Cute tyke lead Yu Yun-mi, as the daughter through whose eyes the pic unfolds, partly sustains interest, but this […]

  • Harrison Ford plane incident

    Harrison Ford Eyes 'Call of the Wild' (EXCLUSIVE)

    A bleak tale of an out-of-work miner’s family in a wintry South Korean province, clumsily titled “With a Girl of Black Soil” has some well-composed lensing going for it, but almost zilch on the dramatic side. Cute tyke lead Yu Yun-mi, as the daughter through whose eyes the pic unfolds, partly sustains interest, but this […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content