You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Lions for Lambs

Talky, back-bendingly liberal but also deeply patriotic, "Lions for Lambs" plays like all the serious footnotes scripter du jour Matthew Michael Carnahan left out of "The Kingdom."

Dr. Stephen Malley - Robert Redford Janine Roth - Meryl Streep Sen. Jasper Irving - Tom Cruise Ernest Rodriguez - Michael Pena Todd Hayes - Andrew Garfield Wirey Pink - Peter Berg Howard - Kevin Dunn Arian Finch - Derek Luke

Talky, back-bendingly liberal but also deeply patriotic, “Lions for Lambs” plays like all the serious footnotes scripter du jour Matthew Michael Carnahan left out of “The Kingdom.” Robert Redford’s first helming chore in seven years, and his most directly political pic yet, amounts to a giant cry of “Americans, get engaged!” wrapped in a star-heavy discourse that uses a lot of words to say nothing new. Apart from the curio value of Redford, Meryl Streep and Tom Cruise headlining the movie equivalent of an Off Broadway play, this first outing by newly resurgent UA doesn’t look likely to roar its way to significant B.O. gains.

Schematic idea sounds bold on paper: three separate events, played out roughly in real screen time across three separate timezones, with each potentially cross-fertilizing the others. Problem is, as the cross-cutting proceeds, it becomes increasingly evident that each yarn exists in its own, very specific frame of reference, with no real human drama to buttress the moral-political conflict.

In Washington, D.C., veteran TV journo Janine Roth (Streep) arrives for a one-on-one interview with Republican young gun Sen. Jasper Irving (Cruise), who has an exclusive to feed her for his own purposes. Meanwhile, earlier that same morning at “a California university,” Todd Hayes (Andrew Garfield), a student who’s been skipping class, gets dressed down by his professor, Dr. Stephen Malley (Redford). Concurrently, a small force of U.S. soldiers is airlifted to a strategic mountainous location in the Afghan mountains to head off the Taliban.

In the early stages, the three strands are cleverly linked. Irving tells Roth the administration has a “new plan” to resolve the deadlock in Afghanistan: sending small groups to secure advance positions ahead of the spring thaw. When Roth asks when this will be implemented, Irving replies, “Ten minutes ago.”

Two of the grunts in the first group, Ernest Rodriguez (Michael Pena) and Arian Finch (Derek Luke), are former students of Malley’s. To try to break through Hayes’ lackadaisical attitude toward his studies and life in general, Malley tells Hayes the story of Rodriguez and Finch, both of whom enlisted in the military as a way to engage in their country’s foreign problems rather than just sit back and take the high ground.

In addressing the issue of the U.S. role as both world policeman and a credible force for good, Carnahan’s screenplay thus takes three clearly defined avenues of approach: the practical (Rodriguez-Finch), the political (Irving-Roth) and the philosophical (Malley-Hayes). All three avenues, however, lead nowhere in particular. The first moves from the gung-ho through military bungling to personal, useless sacrifice; the second through point-by-point confrontation to ultimate resignation; and the third ends vaguely, with only a glimmer of hope.

Most engrossing moments are generated by the political tennis match between the young senator and the cynical reporter. Both thesps are perfectly cast and at the top of their game, with Cruise believably incarnating a Young Turk who believes America’s credibility (as “a force of righteousness”) is now at stake, while Streep’s veteran journo is more interested in digging up past mistakes and Middle Eastern history.

The to-and-fro of their political debate gives both actors a fine workout, and plays to the strengths of their screen personas. But as Carnahan’s script dutifully checks off the issues, it becomes clear the discourse is leading nowhere, and is merely a rerun of arguments already extensively aired by media around the world. Roth has no new arguments to propose, and Irving’s only solution is more positive action.

Meanwhile, back in California, the talk is turning even fuzzier. Faced with Hayes’ continuing skepticism-cum-lack of interest in his country’s politics, Malley finally rounds on him with, “Rome is burning.” “So you’re saying it’s better to try and fail than do nothing?” asks Hayes. “At least you (can say you) did something,” replies Malley. Well, yeah.

With almost no character backgrounding beyond repping various schools of thought, the actors largely get by on screen charisma. Cruise and Streep generate the most sparks; Redford brings a relaxed, slightly supercilious, elder-statesman aura to the role of the mature academic; and young Brit actor Garfield is convincing as an unengaged SoCal student, though his character remains enigmatic to the end.

Production values are fine. Philippe Rousselot’s widescreen lensing and Jan Roelfs’ production design manage distinctive looks for the three strands, from the burnished, formal interiors of Irving’s office and the sunnier, relaxed campus quarters to the grit and snow of an Afghan mountaintop. Mark Isham’s score is low-key until the muddled finale of the military strand, when it slips into unseemly (and inexplicable) patriotic bombast.

As if to underline the symbiotic link between Carnahan’s two scripts, “The Kingdom” helmer Peter Berg pops up here in a supporting role.

Lions for Lambs

Production: An MGM release of a United Artists presentation of a Wildwood Enterprises, Brat Na Pont Prods., Andell Entertainment production. Produced by Robert Redford, Matthew Michael Carnahan, Andrew Hauptman, Tracy Falco. Executive producer, Daniel Lupi. Directed by Robert Redford. Screenplay, Matthew Michael Carnahan.

Crew: Camera (Deluxe color, Panavision widescreen), Philippe Rousselot; editor, Joe Hutshing; additional editing, Paul Hirsch; music, Mark Isham; production designer, Jan Roelfs; art director, Francois Audouy; costume designer, Mary Zophres; sound (SDDS/Dolby Digital/DTS Digital), Petur Hliddal, Richard Hymns; sound designer, Frank Eulner; visual effects supervisor, Joseph Grossberg; associate producer, William Holderman; assistant director, Adam Somner; casting, Avy Kaufman. Reviewed at London Film Festival (Gala), Oct. 22, 2007. (Also in Rome, AFI Los Angeles film festivals.) MPAA Rating: R. Running time: 92 MIN.

Cast: Dr. Stephen Malley - Robert Redford Janine Roth - Meryl Streep Sen. Jasper Irving - Tom Cruise Ernest Rodriguez - Michael Pena Todd Hayes - Andrew Garfield Wirey Pink - Peter Berg Howard - Kevin Dunn Arian Finch - Derek Luke

More Scene

  • Andy CohenThe Shops and Restaurants at

    Andy Cohen to Receive Vito Russo Award at GLAAD Media Awards

    Mazel, Andy Cohen! Bravo’s late-night talk show host is set to receive the Vito Russo Award at the 30th annual GLAAD Media Awards on May 4 in New York City. Sarah Jessica Parker will present him with the award, which is named in honor of GLAAD founder Vito Russo. The annual award goes to openly [...]

  • Variety TV Summit Europe

    Variety TV Summit Europe Coming to London on June 13

    Variety’s TV Summit Europe will coincide with London Tech Week this year, returning to the city on June 13. The international conference will be held at the Royal Lancaster and is co-produced by global events company Informa’s KNect365 division, the world’s largest business-to-business organizer. The one-day summit will focus on the intersection of content and [...]

  • David Furnish, Bryce Dallas Howard, Taron

    'Rocketman': Paramount Previews Footage of Elton John Biopic

    “Rocketman” is ready for lift off. Paramount Pictures threw a cocktail party Monday night to preview 15 minutes of the upcoming Elton John biopic, set for release on May 31, at the Troubadour in Los Angeles, the legendary rock club where John made his U.S. debut nearly 50 years ago. The footage featured pieces of [...]

  • The CalArts REDCAT Gala 2019 Honoring

    Pixar's Pete Docter Honored at CalArts REDCAT Gala

    Pixar’s Pete Docter reminisced about his days as a student at CalArts on Saturday night at the 2019 CalArts REDCAT Gala, where he received the Distinguished Alumni Award. For the wide-eyed boy from Minnesota, where life was more routine, attending CalArts “was a free-for-all. It was eye-opening in a lot of ways,” he recalled. “But [...]

  • Sasha Pieterse, Eli Brown, Sydney Park

    'Pretty Little Liars' Spinoff Unexpectedly Coincides With College Admissions Scandal

    It was a case of art imitating life at Saturday night’s Hollywood premiere of “The Perfectionists” — Freeform’s “Pretty Little Liars” spinoff about a scandal involving college students striving for excellence by any means necessary. The TV show’s debut was coincidently preceded by a real-life college scandal involving Hollywood celebrities who allegedly didn’t let a [...]

  • Keira Knightley'The Aftermath' film screening, Arrivals,

    Keira Knightley Talks 'Aftermath,' Alexander Skarsgård and Another Itchy Wardrobe

    The reigning queen of period pieces, Keira Knightley, knows a thing or two about historical clothing. “Lining. Lining is always important,” the Oscar-nominated actress playfully advised on Wednesday at the premiere of her post-WWII drama “Aftermath.” “If you get a lot of itchy stuff always put lining in it. I have learned that from having [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content