You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Lack of atonement could cost Wright

Director's latest effort not automatic at BAFTAs

LONDON — On paper, “Atonement” looks like the clear hometown favorite to flourish at this year’s British Academy Film Awards.

But with BAFTA, nothing is ever that simple.

Two years ago, director Joe Wright sniped from the stage when he accepted his award for “Pride & Prejudice,” chiding the voters for snubbing his star, Keira Knightley. It was a bit gauche and ruffled a few feathers at the time.

Though it seems unlikely BAFTA members will either remember or care when it comes to voting for “Atonement,” Brits are always uncomfortable about precocious success, and word of mouth around the U.K. film community isn’t quite as unanimous about the merits of “Atonement” as the critics have been.

Wright’s lush adaptation of Ian McEwan’s multigenerational novel certainly has a lot going for it. From the moment it opened the Venice festival to critical raptures, it established itself as the upscale Brit event movie of the year.

It’s an Oscar hopeful with a populist touch, grossing $25 million in the U.K. And it has an impeccable pedigree — produced by Working Title, written by Christopher Hampton, starring two of Blighty’s hottest young thesps (Knightley and James McAvoy), one of its grandest actresses (Vanessa Redgrave) and a winsome newcomer (Saoirse Ronan). And that’s not even to mention Romola Garai, who arguably gives the pic’s standout performance.

Wright has won two BAFTAs already in his short career (for TV serial “Charles II” and movie newcomer thanks to “Pride and Prejudice”) and been nominated three more times (best British film for “Pride and Prejudice,” best serial for “Nature Boy” and best short for “Crocodile Snap”).

But beware the backlash. Though the pic has plenty of admirers, particularly for its first section, debate within the industry has tended to focus on its flaws, rather than its strengths. For some, the famous five-minute tracking shot of Dunkirk beach is a breathtaking piece of authorial bravura by a remarkable young filmmaker; for others, it’s just showing off to no dramatic purpose.

Further, Wright’s supporters question the assumption that BAFTA favors British talent. After all, Knightley got nommed for an Oscar but not for a BAFTA in “Pride and Prejudice.”

In truth, the record books provide conflicting evidence. In the past 15 years, British movies have won for film nine times at the BAFTAs and four times at the Oscars. Brits have won director honors four times from BAFTA and twice from Oscar.

Yet the two directors who won the Academy Award — Anthony Minghella and Sam Mendes — didn’t actually win the BAFTA for best director in the same year, even though “The English Patient” and “American Beauty” did win best film.

Further, no British film has won the best film/director double since “Four Weddings and a Funeral” and Mike Newell managed it for Working Title way back in 1994. And even more confusingly, no movie has ever won best British film and best film, despite the many occasions when the best film winner has been British.

“Atonement” is sure to be nominated across the board. But the quirkiness of BAFTA means that the movie could just as easily win everything or nothing. If British voters really want to tease, they could name “Atonement” best film but overlook Knightley again. That would make for an interesting acceptance speech.

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • 180423_A24_Day_03B_0897.jpg

    'The Lighthouse,' 'Uncut Gems' Lead Spirit Awards Nominations

    “The Lighthouse” and “Uncut Gems” led the 2020 Film Independent Spirit Awards nominations with five each, while “Give Me Liberty” and “Honey Boy” took four apiece. “Uncut Gems,” “A Hidden Life,” “Clemency,” “The Farewell” and “Marriage Story” are up for best feature. Female lead nods went to Karen Allen for “Colewell,” Hong Chau for “Driveways,” [...]

  • Frozen 2

    How the 'Frozen' Music Team Helped Move the Story Forward in Disney's Sequel

    With Disney’s 2013 “Frozen” ranking as the highest-grossing animated film of all time and its Oscar-winning song “Let It Go” now an iconic empowerment anthem, how can the filmmakers and songwriters, reunited for “Frozen 2,” top the tale of sisters Elsa and Anna? “It was all about wanting to tell more of the story,” explains co-director [...]

  • Ben Affleck

    Ben Affleck to Direct and Produce Historical Drama 'King Leopold's Ghost'

    Ben Affleck will direct and produce the historical drama “King Leopold’s Ghost,” set in the early 20th Century in the Congo. The project will be developed by One Community. Affleck will produce via his Pearl Street Films banner, alongside Martin Scorsese who will produce via his Sikelia Productions banner. Harry and Gina Belafonte will also [...]

  • The Two Popes Marriage Story Netflix

    Streamers Ramp Up Golden Globes Race With More Contenders Than Ever

    More films from streaming services are in the awards race this year than ever, prompting some handwringing among awards season voters — most notably AMPAS board governor Steven Spielberg — about whether SVOD films with limited theatrical runs are leading to the demise of theaters and deserving of the same consideration as traditional releases. Netflix’s [...]

  • billy eichner Lion King

    Why Vocal Performances in Animated Films Deserve Their Own Oscars Category

    Given all the praise heaped on Billy Eichner’s performance this year as the wisecracking meerkat Timon in Jon Favreau’s remake of “The Lion King,” which grossed $1.6 billion worldwide, you’d think he would be a bigger contender in the Oscar conversation. His work was such a standout, he even upstaged Beyoncé’s much-hyped appearance in the [...]

  • Jumanji The Next Level

    Box Office: 'Jumanji 2' Eyes $40 Million-Plus Debut

    Will Christmas bring a fruitful box office bounty for Sony’s “Jumanji: The Next Level”? The Dwayne Johnson and Kevin Hart-led sequel, which arrives in theaters on Dec. 13, is on pace to debut to $40 million to $50 million, according to early tracking services. Since tracking has been unreliably for sequels in recent weeks, Sony [...]

  • Pluto TV Picks Up Collection of

    Pluto TV Picks Up Films for Woody Allen Season on U.K. Service (EXCLUSIVE)

    Viacom-owned streamer Pluto TV has inked a deal with Signature Entertainment for a collection of Woody Allen movies from the 1990s and will put them out in a dedicated season on its AVOD service in the U.K. Woody Allen Fridays start on the service this week, with the filmmaker’s pictures playing on the Pluto TV [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content