Globes analysis: Picture — Comedy/Musical

Musicals the majority in this year's top film race

Comedies typically outnumber musicals among the Golden Globe picture contenders, but this year’s song-driven spectacles were apparently strong enough to make the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. sing a different tune.

Of the three musicals nominated, “Sweeney Todd” cuts the widest swath through the nominations, drawing mentions for Tim Burton’s direction as well as the lead performances of Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter. Given the HFPA’s long-standing affection for star-driven, lavishly produced tuners (a la “Dreamgirls,” “Chicago” and “Moulin Rouge”), “Sweeney Todd” would seem to have a very sharp edge.

By the same logic, however, it’d be a mistake to dismiss “Hairspray,” which made a stronger showing than expected with its acting nominations for John Travolta and star newcomer Nikki Blonsky. A sizable B.O. hit, “Hairspray” is as far removed visually, vocally and emotionally from “Sweeney Todd” as a musical can possibly get. As such, it could be an appealing alternative for voters turned off by the latter’s geysers of blood.

So, in theory, could the similarly high-spirited “Across the Universe.” But helmer Julie Taymor’s tribute to free-love psychedelia and the Vietnam War era, scored to songs from the Beatles’ catalog, couldn’t buy any love in the other categories.

Both of the nominated comedies present stronger possibilities. “Charlie’s Wilson War” has had arguably the awards season’s least predictable trajectory — touted as a sure-fire kudos contender early on, then dampened by mixed reactions, and now resurging with five GG nominations to only four for “Todd.”

“Juno” has been likened to last year’s scrappy, crowdpleasing fest favorite, “Little Miss Sunshine.” Given that “Dreamgirls” won the Globe but ultimately missed out on a bid for Oscar while “Sunshine” made it to the Academy’s final rounds, there are worse comparisons a “Juno” fan — and certainly there are many in the HFPA — could make.

More Film

  • Benicio Del Toro and Josh Brolin

    Film Review: 'Sicario: Day of the Soldado'

    Comedies typically outnumber musicals among the Golden Globe picture contenders, but this year’s song-driven spectacles were apparently strong enough to make the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. sing a different tune. Of the three musicals nominated, “Sweeney Todd” cuts the widest swath through the nominations, drawing mentions for Tim Burton’s direction as well as the lead […]

  • Universal Launches Direct Distribution in Hong

    Universal Starts Direct Distribution in Hong Kong, Appoints Anita Cheung

    Comedies typically outnumber musicals among the Golden Globe picture contenders, but this year’s song-driven spectacles were apparently strong enough to make the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. sing a different tune. Of the three musicals nominated, “Sweeney Todd” cuts the widest swath through the nominations, drawing mentions for Tim Burton’s direction as well as the lead […]

  • Jane Fonda

    Film News Roundup: Jane Fonda to Receive Lifetime Achievement Award at Michael Moore's Festival

    Comedies typically outnumber musicals among the Golden Globe picture contenders, but this year’s song-driven spectacles were apparently strong enough to make the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. sing a different tune. Of the three musicals nominated, “Sweeney Todd” cuts the widest swath through the nominations, drawing mentions for Tim Burton’s direction as well as the lead […]

  • Kobe Bryant Barred From Film Academy

    Oscar Winner Kobe Bryant Barred Entry Into Film Academy

    Comedies typically outnumber musicals among the Golden Globe picture contenders, but this year’s song-driven spectacles were apparently strong enough to make the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. sing a different tune. Of the three musicals nominated, “Sweeney Todd” cuts the widest swath through the nominations, drawing mentions for Tim Burton’s direction as well as the lead […]

  • Producer Jennifer Todd Beats Jason Blum

    Producer Jennifer Todd Beats Out Jason Blum in Academy Governors Runoff Election

    Comedies typically outnumber musicals among the Golden Globe picture contenders, but this year’s song-driven spectacles were apparently strong enough to make the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. sing a different tune. Of the three musicals nominated, “Sweeney Todd” cuts the widest swath through the nominations, drawing mentions for Tim Burton’s direction as well as the lead […]

  • Mel Gibson

    Mel Gibson Loses Bid to Block Release of 'Professor and the Madman'

    Comedies typically outnumber musicals among the Golden Globe picture contenders, but this year’s song-driven spectacles were apparently strong enough to make the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. sing a different tune. Of the three musicals nominated, “Sweeney Todd” cuts the widest swath through the nominations, drawing mentions for Tim Burton’s direction as well as the lead […]

  • Mary J. Blige

    Mary J. Blige to Star in Horror-Thriller 'Body Cam' for Paramount

    Comedies typically outnumber musicals among the Golden Globe picture contenders, but this year’s song-driven spectacles were apparently strong enough to make the Hollywood Foreign Press Assn. sing a different tune. Of the three musicals nominated, “Sweeney Todd” cuts the widest swath through the nominations, drawing mentions for Tim Burton’s direction as well as the lead […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content