UPDATE: Shelter Island’s Shorewood Manor

SELLER: Chris Knight
LOCATION: Shorewood Road and Apple Orchard Lane, Shelter Island, New York
PRICE: $24,900,000
SIZE: 8 acres, 8,500 square feet, 11 bedrooms, 5.5 bathrooms
DESCRIPTION: With just about 8 acres total, this home features all the details of the grand era gone by. Original moldings, windows and hardwood floors, this home is ready for a 21st century renovation. Approximately 8,500 sq ft in total, the possibilities of a total renovation are endless. Over 1,000 feet of waterfront and a honeymoon cottage located at the waters edge and an impressive history of ownership, this once in a lifetime chance to own this property should not be missed. Property also features an original Celtic style water tower and massive copper beach trees.

YOUR MAMAS NOTES: Shorewood Manor, the Shelter Island estate formerly owned by New York State governor Hugh Carey, has recently seen a massive price reduction form $33,000,000 to the still astronomical asking price of $24,900,000. The property is still being marketed as a fixer-upper, but it appears that current owner Chris Knight has wisely put a little money into making it look nice for prospective buyers.

As many of y’all will recall, Your Mama discussed this property and our intimate knowledge of the place back in early April 2007, which was not long after Mister Knight purchased the property for a reported $10,000,000 and just two weeks later put it back on the market for a staggering $33,000,000. That much of a mark up in that short of a time period takes some serious real estate cajones. While Your Mam never thought for an instant that Mister Knight would get anywhere near 33 million clams, we have to stand up and applaud Mister Knight’s brazen money grab.

From the new photos, the interior looks to have been sanded and painted and stuffed full of eclectic furniture, some of which looks like catering company furniture and some of which looks like it might be better suited to an outdoor patio or screened porch. None the less, the old gurl is looking better than she has in years.

Your Mama has read and heard that the estate can be rented for special occasions and certainly this would be a spectacular location for a soiree of the Hamptons hoi polloi…if you can get them to cross over on the nearby ferry.

We have no doubt this property is worth more than the $10,000,000 Mister Knight paid for the place, but we still have a hard time getting our itty bitty and tired mind around the idea that someone might pay upwards of $20,000,000 for a house that needs updated and upgraded everything, and we mean everything.

It is the humble and meaningless opinion of Your Mama that Mister Knight would be better off listing the stunning 8 acre property with 270 degree views at $16,500,000 and selling somewhere around fourteen…that would certainly net him a few million. However, given that he’s clearly looking for a $10-15,000,000 profit on his investment, perhaps it’s worthwhile for him to wait it out, even if it takes years to sell.

Best of luck with that Mister Knight.

More Dirt

  • Brady Bunch House

    The World-Famous 'Brady Bunch' House in L.A.'s Studio City Now for Sale

    SELLER: Chris KnightLOCATION: Shorewood Road and Apple Orchard Lane, Shelter Island, New YorkPRICE: $24,900,000SIZE: 8 acres, 8,500 square feet, 11 bedrooms, 5.5 bathroomsDESCRIPTION: With just about 8 acres total, this home features all the details of the grand era gone by. Original moldings, windows and hardwood floors, this home is ready for a 21st century […]

  • Tom Petty's Former Encino Home for

    Tom Petty’s Former Encino Mansion Comes Up for Sale

    SELLER: Chris KnightLOCATION: Shorewood Road and Apple Orchard Lane, Shelter Island, New YorkPRICE: $24,900,000SIZE: 8 acres, 8,500 square feet, 11 bedrooms, 5.5 bathroomsDESCRIPTION: With just about 8 acres total, this home features all the details of the grand era gone by. Original moldings, windows and hardwood floors, this home is ready for a 21st century […]

  • Patrick Schwarzenegger Santa Monica Teardown Mansion

    Patrick Schwarzenegger Picks Up Santa Monica Teardown (EXCLUSIVE)

    SELLER: Chris KnightLOCATION: Shorewood Road and Apple Orchard Lane, Shelter Island, New YorkPRICE: $24,900,000SIZE: 8 acres, 8,500 square feet, 11 bedrooms, 5.5 bathroomsDESCRIPTION: With just about 8 acres total, this home features all the details of the grand era gone by. Original moldings, windows and hardwood floors, this home is ready for a 21st century […]

  • Kristin Cavallari Selling Nashville Mansion

    Kristin Cavallari, Jay Cutler Ready to Sell Off Nashville Mansion

    SELLER: Chris KnightLOCATION: Shorewood Road and Apple Orchard Lane, Shelter Island, New YorkPRICE: $24,900,000SIZE: 8 acres, 8,500 square feet, 11 bedrooms, 5.5 bathroomsDESCRIPTION: With just about 8 acres total, this home features all the details of the grand era gone by. Original moldings, windows and hardwood floors, this home is ready for a 21st century […]

  • Jeremy Piven House

    Jeremy Piven Re-Lists Malibu Beach House at Reduced Price (EXCLUSIVE)

    SELLER: Chris KnightLOCATION: Shorewood Road and Apple Orchard Lane, Shelter Island, New YorkPRICE: $24,900,000SIZE: 8 acres, 8,500 square feet, 11 bedrooms, 5.5 bathroomsDESCRIPTION: With just about 8 acres total, this home features all the details of the grand era gone by. Original moldings, windows and hardwood floors, this home is ready for a 21st century […]

  • Sandra Bullock House

    Sandra Bullock Seeks Sale of California Contemporary Above L.A.'s Sunset Strip

    SELLER: Chris KnightLOCATION: Shorewood Road and Apple Orchard Lane, Shelter Island, New YorkPRICE: $24,900,000SIZE: 8 acres, 8,500 square feet, 11 bedrooms, 5.5 bathroomsDESCRIPTION: With just about 8 acres total, this home features all the details of the grand era gone by. Original moldings, windows and hardwood floors, this home is ready for a 21st century […]

  • Jim Parsons House

    Jim Parsons Lists Swank Celeb-Pedigreed Pad in L.A.’s Los Feliz (EXCLUSIVE)

    SELLER: Chris KnightLOCATION: Shorewood Road and Apple Orchard Lane, Shelter Island, New YorkPRICE: $24,900,000SIZE: 8 acres, 8,500 square feet, 11 bedrooms, 5.5 bathroomsDESCRIPTION: With just about 8 acres total, this home features all the details of the grand era gone by. Original moldings, windows and hardwood floors, this home is ready for a 21st century […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content