×

When a Stranger Calls

Modestly clever concept gets indifferent execution in another bigger-yet-blander remake of an allegedly "classic" '70s shocker. Pic might scare up some small change by appealing to ticket buyers in the same demographic as its feisty teen heroine. But it's more likely that this "Stranger" won't get acquainted with a wider aud until homevid.

With:
Jill Johnson - Camilla Belle Stranger - Tommy Flanagan Scarlet - Tessa Thompson Bobby - Brian Geraghty Mr. Johnson - Clark Gregg Dr. Mandrakis - Derek de Lint Mrs. Mandrakis - Kate Jennings Grant Officer Burroughs - David Denman Will Mandrakis - Arthur Young Allison Mandrakis - Madeline Carroll Detective Hines - Steve Eastin Voice of the Stranger - Lance Henriksen

A modestly clever concept gets indifferent execution in “When a Stranger Calls,” another bigger-yet-blander remake of an allegedly “classic” ’70s shocker. Unleashed without press previews for a Super Bowl weekend opening frame, pic might scare up some small change by appealing to ticket buyers in the same demographic as its feisty teen heroine. But it’s more likely that this “Stranger” won’t get acquainted with a wider aud until it is reintroduced in homevid format.

Original 1979 thriller achieved semi-cult status with an ingeniously nasty first act that has inspired countless imitations — and quite a few spot-on parodies. (Did somebody say “Scream”?)

In the original, babysitter Jill (Carol Kane) is rattled by phone calls from a raspy-voiced stranger who repeatedly asks: “Have you checked on the children?” Jill’s fear intensifies when the calls are traced to a phone line inside the house. The ’79 pic then leaps ahead a few years to set up a reunion between the phone caller, escaped from a mental hospital, and Jill, who now has her own offspring.

For the remake, scripter Jake Wade Wall shrewdly opted to jettison everything but the opening 20 or so minutes of the original pic. New “Stranger” consists almost entirely of a protracted cat-and-mouse game as an appreciably more formidable but equally terrified Jill (Camilla Belle) is mercilessly stalked and taunted by an apparently omniscient phone caller (played by Tommy Flanagan, voiced by Lance Henriksen) during her long, dark night of babysitting in a secluded, spectacularly opulent home.

After setting up this promising premise, however, Wall and helmer Simon West (“Laura Croft: Tomb Raider”) fail to sustain suspense — or even consistently maintain interest — during what amounts to 70 or so minutes of fake-outs, pregnant pauses and, occasionally, cheap shocks. (Tacked-on coda, which owes more than it can repay to Brian De Palma’s “Carrie” and several copycats, is bound to generate derisive laughter.)

Early scenes subtly establish an undeniably unsettling mood, as Jill reacts to the ineffably threatening sounds of commonplace household items (motion-triggered lights, an automatic icemaker, etc.) while, outside, winds howl and tree branches rustle. A little of this goes a long way, however.

It doesn’t help that the plot mechanics creak much too loudly, and the shameless contrivances are all too obvious. In addition, sequel goes through elaborate contortions to make sure this Jill doesn’t benefit from cell phone technology that original pic’s heroine didn’t have. This leads to one truly amusing plot wrinkle: Jill is forced to baby-sit as punishment for using too many minutes on her family’s cell phone account.

Belle earns props for performing gracefully and compellingly under the pressure of being the only person on screen for long stretches of running time. However, supporting players, including Katie Cassidy as a bitchy classmate, are mostly unremarkable.

Production designer Jon Gary Steele merits his own kudos for creating what gradually emerges as Belle’s most prominent co-star: An enormous and ultra-modern three-story house tricked out with glass walls, dark shadows and a cavernous atrium. Set allows lenser Peter Menzies Jr. ample leeway to employ an impressive variety of visual stratagems to enhance pic’s wall-to-wall paranoia. Although, in the end, that’s not quite enough.

Popular on Variety

When a Stranger Calls

Production: A Sony Pictures Entertainment release of a Screen Gems presentation of a Davis Entertainment production. Produced by John Davis, Wyck Godfrey, Ken Lemberger. Executive producer, Paddy Cullen. Directed by Simon West. Screenplay, Jake Wade Wall, based on the film written by Steve Feke, Fred Walton.

Crew: Camera (Deluxe color, widescreen), Peter Menzies Jr.; editor, Jeff Betancourt; music, James Dooley; production designer, Jon Gary Steele; art director, Gerry Sullivan; set decorator, Traci Kirshbaum; costume designer, Marie Sylvie Deveau; sound (Dolby Digital/DTS/SDDS), Glenn Berkovitz; assistant director, Steve Danton; casting, Nancy Nayor. Reviewed at Edwards Marq*e Cinema, Houston, Feb. 2, 2006. MPAA Rating: PG-13. Running time: 87 MIN.

Cast: Jill Johnson - Camilla Belle Stranger - Tommy Flanagan Scarlet - Tessa Thompson Bobby - Brian Geraghty Mr. Johnson - Clark Gregg Dr. Mandrakis - Derek de Lint Mrs. Mandrakis - Kate Jennings Grant Officer Burroughs - David Denman Will Mandrakis - Arthur Young Allison Mandrakis - Madeline Carroll Detective Hines - Steve Eastin Voice of the Stranger - Lance Henriksen

More Scene

  • Cara Delevingne'Carnival Row' TV show premiere,

    Cara Delevingne Talks Immigration, Taylor Swift's Battle With Scooter Braun

    Cara Delevingne, whose faerie character in “Carnival Row” finds herself washed ashore as a refugee in a foreign land, said she was immediately drawn by the show’s fantastical take on issues of immigration and assimilation. “It’s a cause that I have been involved in for a long time,” Delevingne told Variety at the premiere of [...]

  • John Travolta, Fred Durst. John Travolta,

    John Travolta Recalls Fans Breaking Into His House: 'I Was Scared the First Time'

    Nobody can accuse John Travolta of not being gracious to his fans, whether it’s an autograph, a selfie or, you know, a home invasion or two. “I’ve only had two people that actually invaded my house,” Travolta told Variety at the premiere of “The Fanatic” at the Egyptian Theater on Thursday night. “They were just [...]

  • Sublime Primetime

    How Emmy-Nominated Writers’ Rooms Keep Politics in Mind

    In a world filled with elections, social movements and national tragedies, how open should the doors of a writers’ room actually be? For some of this year’s Emmy-nominated shows, those doors are wide open. Before the 71st annual Primetime Emmy Awards air on Sept. 22, the Writers Guild of America West and Writers Guild Foundation, [...]

  • 50 Cent Power S6 Premiere

    50 Cent, Snoop Dogg & Trey Songz 'Power' Up New York City for Massive Season 6 Premiere

    “Power” is entering its final season, but you would never know if you walked by Madison Square Garden in Manhattan on Tuesday night. Starz pulled out all the stops for its ratings powerhouse “Power,” throwing a massive premiere event, complete with a full-length concert at Madison Square Garden from Curtis “50 Cent” Jackson and a [...]

  • Diane Warren'Late Night' Film Premiere, Arrivals,

    Songs of Hope to Honor Diane Warren, Marc Shaiman, Boi-1da, More at 15th Annual Event

    Cancer research and treatment center City of Hope today announced the initial lineup of presenters and honorees who will celebrate the song and songwriter at its 15th annual Songs of Hope event. Among the music and entertainment industry VIPs in attendance will be veteran executive and producer Clive Davis, producer Boi-1da (Drake, Kendrick Lamar), award-winning [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content