You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

The Exonerated

First, a personal confession to a critical misdemeanor: I fell asleep while watching this sober adaptation of an off-Broadway play -- which, shockingly, has never happened before -- demonstrating that social advocacy and entertainment value don't always go hand in hand. This theater piece features a high-wattage cast reading the words of Death Row inmates later proved innocent.

With:
Robert Earl Hayes - David Brown Jr. Gary Gauger - Brian Dennehy David Keaton - Danny Glover Delbert Tibbs - Delroy Lindo Kerry Max Cook - Aidan Quinn Sunny Jacobs - Susan Sarandon

First, a personal confession to a critical misdemeanor: I fell asleep while watching this sober adaptation of an off-Broadway play — which, shockingly, has never happened before — demonstrating that social advocacy and entertainment value don’t always go hand in hand. Featuring a high-wattage cast reading the words of Death Row inmates later proved innocent, this theater piece is so clenched and stagy it’s difficult to get drawn into the production, however well intentioned it might be.

As mounted by director Bob Balaban, think of this as “The Convicted Monologues,” a series of dissertations on the justice system keyed to a half-dozen convicts who were wrongly imprisoned. Shot against a stark black backdrop, it’s a strong statement against the death penalty (dead men, after all, are hard to set free) and a showcase for the actors, albeit one with more earnestness than energy.

Credit Court TV conceptually, at least, for tackling the material, an unflinching look (including frequent use of a rarely heard racial epithet) at abuses and failings of a justice system the channel otherwise exalts within many of its shows. The production notes, in fact, describe it as “cause-related programming,” which is certainly a seldom-used term.

Yet despite the blunt language and a few striking observations (one inmate says he “had to practice a bunch to be human again”), “The Exonerated” lacks the crackle of a live production and does precious little to capitalize on the movie format. And while Court TV can doubtless derive some pride from having the likes of Susan Sarandon, Danny Glover and Brian Dennehy in one of its originals, the intercutting among their various stories — bridged by slow fadeouts and David Robbins’ soothing score — plays like an expensive lullaby.

Debating the dangers inherent to capital punishment is undoubtedly a worthy cause, regardless of where one comes down on the issue. As for providing viewers with good cause to sit through this polemic, unless they’re insomniacs that’s something else again.

The Exonerated

Court TV; Thurs., Jan. 27, 9 p.m.

Production: Filmed in New York City by Radical.Media/Chicagofilms in association with the Culture Project. Executive producers, Bob Balaban, Allan Buchman; producers, Greg Schultz, Steven Tabakin; line producer, Karen Wolfe; co-producers, Jessica Blank, Erik Jensen, Mort Kasman; director, Balaban; writers, Blank, Jensen.

Crew: Camera, Rufus Standefer; editor, Andy Keir; music, David Robbins; casting, Nina Pratt, Kim Moarefi. 120 MIN.

Cast: Robert Earl Hayes - David Brown Jr. Gary Gauger - Brian Dennehy David Keaton - Danny Glover Delbert Tibbs - Delroy Lindo Kerry Max Cook - Aidan Quinn Sunny Jacobs - Susan Sarandon

More TV

  • Elite

    ‘Elite’ Gets Netflix Season 2 Order

    First, a personal confession to a critical misdemeanor: I fell asleep while watching this sober adaptation of an off-Broadway play — which, shockingly, has never happened before — demonstrating that social advocacy and entertainment value don’t always go hand in hand. Featuring a high-wattage cast reading the words of Death Row inmates later proved innocent, […]

  • Former England soccer star David Beckham

    Japanese Mascot Character Kumamon Heads for TV Series With Tonko House

    First, a personal confession to a critical misdemeanor: I fell asleep while watching this sober adaptation of an off-Broadway play — which, shockingly, has never happened before — demonstrating that social advocacy and entertainment value don’t always go hand in hand. Featuring a high-wattage cast reading the words of Death Row inmates later proved innocent, […]

  • 'AHS': Sarah Paulson on Approaching Directing

    Sarah Paulson on Directing for 'American Horror Story': 'I Don't Try to Shed My Own Instincts'

    First, a personal confession to a critical misdemeanor: I fell asleep while watching this sober adaptation of an off-Broadway play — which, shockingly, has never happened before — demonstrating that social advocacy and entertainment value don’t always go hand in hand. Featuring a high-wattage cast reading the words of Death Row inmates later proved innocent, […]

  • Riki Lindhome

    Fox to Develop Comedy Starring, Co-Created by 'Another Period's' Riki Lindhome

    First, a personal confession to a critical misdemeanor: I fell asleep while watching this sober adaptation of an off-Broadway play — which, shockingly, has never happened before — demonstrating that social advocacy and entertainment value don’t always go hand in hand. Featuring a high-wattage cast reading the words of Death Row inmates later proved innocent, […]

  • Sarah Chalke

    Sarah Chalke Re-Teams With 'Scrubs' Creator for Drama in Development at ABC

    First, a personal confession to a critical misdemeanor: I fell asleep while watching this sober adaptation of an off-Broadway play — which, shockingly, has never happened before — demonstrating that social advocacy and entertainment value don’t always go hand in hand. Featuring a high-wattage cast reading the words of Death Row inmates later proved innocent, […]

  • Jordan Reddout and Gus Hickey

    CW Developing Revenge Dark Comedy Series From Jordan Reddout, Gus Hickey

    First, a personal confession to a critical misdemeanor: I fell asleep while watching this sober adaptation of an off-Broadway play — which, shockingly, has never happened before — demonstrating that social advocacy and entertainment value don’t always go hand in hand. Featuring a high-wattage cast reading the words of Death Row inmates later proved innocent, […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content