Arbuckle case riled biz’s morality minders

<I>Variety</I> was chock-a-block with reports on the scandal

Long before the tabs, “ET” and “Access,” the Internet and bloggers, there were the sensationalist papers. And long before Robert Blake and Michael Jackson, other juicy scandals rocked Hollywood.

Whereas Variety today weighs in on these trials and tribulations only when there is a business angle — Jackson’s music empire was in question during his trial, and the paper duly explored the ramifications — it was very different in the 1920s.

In September 1921 the Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle scandal rocked the fledgling film industry and brought to the surface pent-up outrage at the mores, real or imagined, of Hollywood.

The week the rotund comedian was indicted on murder charges in the death of actress Virginia Rappe during a “wild weekend party,” Variety was chock-a-block with reports on the scandal. Under the banner “Scandal Hits Industry,” the paper recounted the grand jury proceeding, including testimony by two key witnesses. They stated that the dying girl moaned: “I am dying, I am dying. He hurt me.” That apparently clenched the indictment.

Popular on Variety

Almost instantaneously, Arbuckle films were pulled from theaters across the country.

An Arbuckle-Mabel Normand two-reeler was yanked from the Manhattan Opera House. “The audience applauded briskly at the announcement of the change,” Variety reported.

Ditto around the country.

On its Editorials page the next week, Variety opined in the sanctimonious tone of most of the coverage elsewhere: “Millions of pretty girls turn their faces toward the gilded west and sigh for celluloid stardom. Thousands venture to go after the pot of brass at the end of the Cooper-Hewitt rainbow. Virginia Rappe was one of them. She yearned for stardom. She made it — at last.”

Presumably the editorialist was referring to her role as the star of a murder investigation.

Her last feature, it turns out, was an undistinguished comedy called “The Punch of the Irish.”

At the time of his arrest, Arbuckle was one of the most familiar faces in silent movies and was making $3,500 a week under contract to Famous Players.

But the moral watchdogs were ready to bark at a moment’s notice. Then, as now, Hollywood was an obvious target.

In early October a Variety headline read “Worldwide Condemnation of Pictures as Aftermath of Arbuckle Affair.”

“The attacks against the picture industry delivered by various churches may hurt the box office everywhere,” a Variety reporter opined.

And the shockwaves went ’round the world.

“Abroad the luster of the advent of Charles Chaplin in Paris was visibly dimmed by the news of the wild San Francisco orgy and its attendant fatality.”

Several months and two mistrials later, Variety reported deep inside its pages that a single shot of Arbuckle appeared on a screen in Brooklyn in a reel about the lives of the rich and famous.

Said the paper: “It was thought to have been attempted as a test to secure a line on public opinion toward Arbuckle, as Fatty’s third trial approaches.” (The Brooklyn audience had no discernible reaction.)

Weeks later, a jury deliberated for just six minutes before finding the actor not guilty.

But Arbuckle’s acting career was over, and though he tried his hand at directing some years later, his name rarely appeared in Variety thereafter.

More Film

  • Syd Mead Concept Design 1986 Aliens

    Syd Mead Designed the Future of Science Fiction Films

    The spinner police car in 1982’s “Blade Runner,” the light cycles of “Tron,” “futuristic Las Vegas” in “Blade Runner 2049” and the “USS Sulaco” in “Aliens” are indelible images of cinema, all from the imagination of the late Syd Mead, who died last month at the age of 86. You might not be aware of [...]

  • Freestyle Love Supreme

    Watch Lin-Manuel Miranda and 'Freestyle Love Supreme' in Exclusive Clip From Sundance Documentary

    Before turning “Hamilton” and “In the Heights” into musical phenomenons, Lin-Manuel Miranda could have been found on stage, spouting off-the-cuff rhymes with his improv group, “Freestyle Love Supreme.” After performing across the globe, the troupe — founded 15 years ago by Miranda, his frequent collaborator Thomas Kail and emcee Anthony Veneziale — made its Broadway [...]

  • Fernando Szew and Tomas Yankelevich

    Particular Crowd, MarVista Set 10-Plus Movies a Year Partnership (EXCLUSIVE)

    MIAMI — Particular Crowd, the big new film banner of Warner Media’s Turner Latin America, and MarVista Entertainment, one of the world’s biggest and ambitious of independent entertainment studios, have announced a multi-year production slate deal. As part of the deal, Particular Crowd and MarVista will target production of 10-plus films per year, focusing on elevated [...]

  • Andy Serkis

    BAFTA to Honor Andy Serkis

    The British Academy of Film and Television Arts (BAFTA) is presenting Andy Serkis with its Outstanding British Contribution to Cinema Award at the 73rd EE British Academy Film Awards ceremony on Feb. 2 in London. The organization said Thursday that it was honoring the British actor, producer and director for his pioneering work on performance [...]

  • The Olympic Rings adorn an event

    Tokyo Olympics Brings Upheaval to Japan's Summer Events Schedule

    The Tokyo Olympics, to be held from July 24 to Aug. 9, and Paralympics, scheduled for Aug. 25 to Sept. 9, are affecting Japan’s big summer events. Everything from fireworks displays to music festivals have chosen to shift dates or even cancel altogether. The only film festival so far to announce a change in dates [...]

  • The Rescue

    Overseas Releases of Chinese Films to be Cancelled Following Virus Outbreak

    The overseas release of Chinese films in the next weeks is certain to be affected by the cancellation of theatrical outings in mainland China as a response to the rampant spread of the coronavirus. On Thursday, movie companies in China announced they would not go ahead with the release of seven major films at Chinese [...]

  • Boris JohnsonConservative Party rally on eve

    U.K. Parliament Passes Brexit Law, Leaving Film, TV Incentives Unaffected

    The U.K. Parliament on Wednesday evening passed legislation paving the way for the country to leave the European Union on Jan. 31, 2020. British Prime Minister Boris Johnson said the U.K. had “crossed the Brexit finish line” following passage of the Withdrawal Agreement, which will officially become law when it receives royal assent from Queen [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content