Many DVD “special editions” are cynical attempts to seduce consumers into buying something they already own. But, four years after Warner Home Video’s last edition of “Ben-Hur,” the company is putting out a DVD set that merits the revisit. In keeping with the mega-scope of the biblical epic, this collector’s edition offers four discs with 10 hours of extras, including a smart documentary and the 1925 silent version of the pic, making its DVD debut.
When MGM’s film bowed in 1959, comic Mort Sahl famously wisecracked, “Loved him, hated Hur.” That dichotomy has followed the film over the years, with fans proclaiming it one of the pinnacles of Hollywood filmmaking, and detractors rolling their eyes at its oversized style mixed with an old-fashioned sensibility.
Even the film’s detractors may be converted after listening to the info in the DVD’s docus. “Ben-Hur: The Epic That Challenged Cinema,” produced and directed by Gary Leva, offers folks like George Lucas, Ridley Scott, Arnon Milchan and Michael Douglas talking about the film’s influence on pics as diverse as “Bullitt,” “The Matrix,” “Star Wars,” “Gladiator” and “The Aviator.”
Each of the doc’s 10 chapters tackles a different area of study. Cinematographers Janusz Kaminski and Ernest Dickerson talk about “Ben-Hur’s” composition and lighting; sound man Ben Burtt praises the audio effects (and lack of music) in the chariot race. In one of the more interesting segments, production designers Anthony Pratt and Arthur Max weigh the virtues of matte paintings vs. CGI vs. actual sets.
Editor Joel Cox, director Frasier Heston and d.p. Caleb Deschanel offer insights as the doc intercuts the chariot race with the pod-racer sequence from “Star Wars: Episode I — The Phantom Menace.”
Fourth disc includes another good hourlong film that was included in the 2001 DVD, the 1993 Turner Entertainment docu “Ben-Hur: The Making of an Epic,” produced and directed by Scott Benson and written/co-produced by May Adair Kaiser. The film provides an overview of “Ben-Hur,” from the 1880 book by General Lew Wallace, through an early stage version (the chariot race featured horses running on treadmills), the silent pic and the making of the 1959 version, concluding with its then-record-setting 11 Oscar wins.
Footage from the April 4, 1960, kudocast is choppily edited, with winners mysteriously appearing out of nowhere to grab their trophy. Still, the segment is a lot of fun. Even hardcore movie buffs may have a tough time identifying some of those presenters, but it’s easy to see why kudocasts were shorter in those days. Most acceptance speeches consist of one sentence (“My humble thanks to everybody!”); accepting as best director, Wyler was one of the longest-winded winners, with a 13-second speech.
Also entertaining are the trailers from the era, which exclaim flatly that this is “the finest motion picture achievement in screen history!” and “the entertainment experience of a lifetime!” It’s a reminder that studios always revved up the hype, but once did it without the benefit of online blurbmeisters.
There is also a “Ben-Hur collector’s edition with Bible Study Guide,” written by Rev. Robert H. Schuller and his son Rev. Robert A. Schuller, co-chairmen of Crystal Cathedral Ministries. The special edition will be available at DVD stores and Christian retail stores.
The film looks terrif, in a newly remastered print from the original 65mm film elements. Also included are a new audio commentary by film historian T. Gene Hatcher (interspersed with vintage comments from Heston); screen tests, including Leslie Nielsen’s; and newsreels.
The silent version, restored by Thames Television and with a scored by Carl Davis, is new to DVD, though the Fred Niblo-helmed version had been released on VHS. This silent film merits its own extras; there are none here. Maybe they’re waiting for the deluxe super-bonus-special-collector’s six-disc version someday.