×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

The God Committee

First there's the sound of switching radio stations. Then a screech of car brakes and a crash. Then the sound of a heart giving out its last beats. Lights up and we're at a meeting room of a hospital where a group of doctors and hospital authorities are gathered to decide which of the many candidates will be the recipient of this heart. "The God Committee," a predictable melodrama receiving its world preem in the Berkshires, falls into the category of medical ethics drama.

With:
Father Charles Dunbar - Gerrit Graham Dr. Keira Banks - Kelly Hutchinson Dominick Piero - Ron Orbach Dr. Jack Klee - David Rasche Dr. Alex Gorman - Armand Schultz Nella Redwood - Michele Shay Dr. Ann Ross - Amy Van Nostrand

First there’s the sound of switching radio stations. Then a screech of car brakes and a crash. Then the sound of a heart giving out its last beats. Lights up and we’re at a meeting room of a hospital where a group of doctors and hospital authorities are gathered to decide which of the many candidates will be the recipient of this heart. “The God Committee,” a predictable melodrama receiving its world preem in the Berkshires, falls into the category of medical ethics drama. But whose play is it anyway?

According to playwright Mark St. Germain, it’s about the group around the table, whose bios and personal biases affect their life-and-death decision for those awaiting the organ transplant. But far more interesting than these stereotypical medical characters onstage are the offstage candidates we only hear about but don’t see: those faceless names that move about on a large board like horses in a betting parlor as their fates are discussed during the course of this who-gets-it play.

But we don’t come into contact with any of these people. Instead, we are left with the men and women who “play God” and decide, in effect, who lives and dies. There’s the cold and arrogant surgeon; the beloved doctor who is dying of stomach cancer; the psychiatrist whose daughter recently OD’d; the jolly, wheelchair-using social services director; and the sassy black nurse who holds it all together. Add to the mix two newbies, which allows for a lot of background exposition to assist the audience: a young, insecure female doctor and a wry lawyer-priest representing the interests of the hospital board.

Of course, there’s a secret or two to be revealed at the appropriate time, as well as some character reversals to keep the plot percolating. But many of these twists aren’t all that surprising.

Though Germain possesses a good ear for snappy dialogue, he also succumbs to over-reaching (“We are the weapons of mass destruction,” says a doctor about our atrocity-filled world) and cliches (“We’re not looking at cases. We’re looking at people!” said, in effect, not just once but twice during the play).

The candidates for the sought-after heart on its way through St. Patrick’s Day traffic and revelry — at St. Patrick’s Hospital, no less — are a far more intriguing group, including a HIV-positive man, a poet who lives alone; a 68-year-old mother and former nurse who has already received a heart transplant and recently attempted suicide; and the young drug-addicted son of a wealthy board member (“He’s a one-man rat pack”) whose girlfriend may be pregnant.

The decisionmaking process gets complicated when the board member offers to donate $30 million to the hospital, presumably to enhance his son’s chances of receiving the heart.

The values of these candidates are debated, pressured by the time constraints of the heart’s impending arrival. (“We’ve got 36 minutes,” says one doctor. “It’s like a Nazi ‘Beat the Clock,’ ” responds another.) But it’s not only the worthiness of the heart candidates but of the doctors themselves that’s being evaluated, and in the end, people aren’t as pure as they seem.

David Saint directs the exposition-filled production with clarity and moves the action along swiftly. The actors all do well, especially Rasche as the afflicted doctor and Gerrit Graham as the sardonic lawyer-priest who has some of the best lines, including an Irish joke. (There’s always time for an Irish joke as the seconds are ticking away.)

Eric Renschler’s office setting is appropriately corporate and antiseptic.

While the play is diverting enough for a summer eve’s entertainment, future New York life is more iffy. However, a variation of it could do well as a TV pilot, a format that would allow the potentially more interesting offstage characters to appear. After all, a heart is a terrible thing to waste.

The God Committee

Consolati Performing Arts Center, Sheffield, Mass.; 478 seats; $42 top

Production: A Barrington Stage Co. production of a play in two acts by Mark St. Germain. Directed by David Saint.

Creative: Sets, Eric Renschler; lighting, Christopher J. Bailey; costumes, David Murin; sound, Randy Hansen; production stage manager, C. Renee Alexander; production manager, Jennifer Lyons. Opened July 24, 2004. Reviewed July 25. Running time: 1 HOUR, 45 MIN.

Cast: Father Charles Dunbar - Gerrit Graham Dr. Keira Banks - Kelly Hutchinson Dominick Piero - Ron Orbach Dr. Jack Klee - David Rasche Dr. Alex Gorman - Armand Schultz Nella Redwood - Michele Shay Dr. Ann Ross - Amy Van Nostrand

More Legit

  • Sutton Foster

    Sutton Foster Starring Opposite Hugh Jackman in Broadway's 'The Music Man'

    “The Music Man” has found its Marian, the librarian. Sutton Foster, the two-time Tony Award winner, will star opposite Hugh Jackman in the upcoming revival of “The Music Man.” She will play Marian Paroo, a small-town librarian who is initially immune to Professor Harold Hill’s charms. It’s a role that was previously performed by the [...]

  • 'Black Super Hero Magic Mama' Review

    L.A. Theater Review: 'Black Super Hero Magic Mama'

    What function do superhero stories play in American society? Are they merely escapist distractions for head-in-the-clouds teens, or could those same formats actually serve a practical function, providing useful tools for everyday life? Recognizing these comic book fantasies as by far the dominant form of contemporary mythmaking for a generation of young people, emerging playwright [...]

  • Danielle Brooks'Ain't Too Proud - The

    How 'Orange Is the New Black' Star Danielle Brooks Became a Broadway Producer

    Danielle Brooks earned a Tony nomination when she made her Broadway debut as Sofia in the 2015 revival of “The Color Purple,” but now the “Orange Is the New Black” star is working behind the scenes as a producer on the new jukebox musical “Ain’t Too Proud: The Life and Times of the Temptations.” “I [...]

  • Ain't Too Proud review

    Broadway Review: 'Ain't Too Proud'

    In the wake of the long-running “Jersey Boys” and the short-lived “Summer,” director Des McAnuff is back on Broadway with another show built around the song catalog of a music act — and although “Ain’t Too Proud” has all the right sounds and slick moves, this bio-musical of the R&B vocal group the Temptations is [...]

  • 'White Noise' Theater Review: Suzan-Lori Parks

    Off Broadway Review: Daveed Diggs in 'White Noise'

    Any new play by the Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright Suzan-Lori Parks (“Topdog / Underdog”) demands — and deserves — attention. And in its premiere production at the Public Theater, her latest, “White Noise,” opens with a burst of brainy energy that lasts through the first act. But it takes a nosedive in the sloppy second half, [...]

  • Alexander Dinelaris

    'Jekyll and Hyde' Movie in the Works Based on Broadway Musical

    The Broadway musical “Jekyll and Hyde” is getting the movie treatment from Academy Award winner Alexander Dinelaris. Dinelaris, who is writing and producing the adaptation, won an Oscar for the “Birdman” script and was a co-producer on “The Revenant.” He is producing “Jekyll and Hyde” as the first project under his New York-based development company, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content