Someone Else’s Shinjuku East

Third in a trilogy about Taiwanese women living in Japan, "Someone Else's Shinjuku East" does not make one yearn to catch up on the first two. Unfocused docu too often seems to be simply hanging out with its subjects rather than gaining insight into their lives. Exposure is unlikely to reach beyond tube play in relevant territories.

Third in a trilogy (preceded by featurettes “Out of Place” and “Floating Women”) about Taiwanese women living in Japan, “Someone Else’s Shinjuku East” does not make one yearn to catch up on the first two. Meandering, unfocused docu too often seems to be simply hanging out with its subjects rather than gaining insight into their lives. Exposure is unlikely to reach beyond tube play in relevant territories.

First full-length effort by co-helmers Yang Li-chou and Michelle Chu initially intrigues with its cast of real-life characters: Several women and two men in the Tokyo bar-city of Shinjuku East, considered somewhat disreputable and dangerous. When Taiwan lifted an overseas travel ban in 1979, many residents — especially young women — seized the opportunity to support families back home via Japan’s higher wages, even if that meant work as bar hostesses, strippers or prostitutes. Many have been here for two decades; some prospering, some getting into debt, none finding much domestic happiness as third-class citizens. Half-dozen or so personalities focused on are engaging. But haphazardly structured, often aimless pic shortchanges more serious issues by spending too much time watching protags party. Tech aspects are OK.

— Dennis Harvey

Someone Else's Shinjuku East

Taiwan

Production: A Public Television Service production. Produced by Michelle Chu. Executive producer, Sylvia H. Feng. Directed by Yang Li-chou, Michelle Chu.

Crew: Camera (color, DV), Yang, Chu; editors, Yang, Michelle Chu, Yuki Chu; music, Wen Tzu-chieh. Reviewed at San Francisco Film Festival, April 17, 2004. Original title: . Running time: 103 MIN.

More Film

  • Durban Fest Gets Opening Night Fright

    Durban Fest Gets Opening Night Fright with ‘Tokoloshe’

    Third in a trilogy (preceded by featurettes “Out of Place” and “Floating Women”) about Taiwanese women living in Japan, “Someone Else’s Shinjuku East” does not make one yearn to catch up on the first two. Meandering, unfocused docu too often seems to be simply hanging out with its subjects rather than gaining insight into their […]

  • Steph Curry Variety Cover Story

    Stephen Curry Takes a Shot at a New Game: Producing for Hollywood

    Third in a trilogy (preceded by featurettes “Out of Place” and “Floating Women”) about Taiwanese women living in Japan, “Someone Else’s Shinjuku East” does not make one yearn to catch up on the first two. Meandering, unfocused docu too often seems to be simply hanging out with its subjects rather than gaining insight into their […]

  • BFI Sets Out Widespread Plans to

    British Film Institute Sets Out Proposals to Boost U.K. Indie Film Sector

    Third in a trilogy (preceded by featurettes “Out of Place” and “Floating Women”) about Taiwanese women living in Japan, “Someone Else’s Shinjuku East” does not make one yearn to catch up on the first two. Meandering, unfocused docu too often seems to be simply hanging out with its subjects rather than gaining insight into their […]

  • Robin Hood

    Hungary Raises Production Incentive from 25% to 30% (EXCLUSIVE)

    Third in a trilogy (preceded by featurettes “Out of Place” and “Floating Women”) about Taiwanese women living in Japan, “Someone Else’s Shinjuku East” does not make one yearn to catch up on the first two. Meandering, unfocused docu too often seems to be simply hanging out with its subjects rather than gaining insight into their […]

  • King Cohen review

    Film Review: 'King Cohen'

    Third in a trilogy (preceded by featurettes “Out of Place” and “Floating Women”) about Taiwanese women living in Japan, “Someone Else’s Shinjuku East” does not make one yearn to catch up on the first two. Meandering, unfocused docu too often seems to be simply hanging out with its subjects rather than gaining insight into their […]

  • 'The Equalizer 2' Review

    Film Review: Denzel Washington in 'The Equalizer 2'

    Third in a trilogy (preceded by featurettes “Out of Place” and “Floating Women”) about Taiwanese women living in Japan, “Someone Else’s Shinjuku East” does not make one yearn to catch up on the first two. Meandering, unfocused docu too often seems to be simply hanging out with its subjects rather than gaining insight into their […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content