Picking a winner

In the effects race, big and flashy still beats seamless and subtle, wizards say

The official criterion for the visual effects Oscar is spelled out in Rule No. 22 of the Academy’s Awards rulebook. Films are judged based on “(a) consideration of the contribution the visual effects made to the overall production, and (b) the artistry, skill and fidelity with which the visual illusions are achieved.”

But confronted with more movies than ever containing complex visual effects, what is it that Academy voters are really looking for?

The first hurdle is to identify what is, and what is not, a visual effects shot. 

“Many times people have to say, ‘You may not realize this, but these shots are effects,’ ” says Scott Farrar, visual effects supervisor for “Peter Pan” and a past Oscar winner for “Cocoon.”  

“A lot of the stuff we do now is not noticeable even to the trained eye,” adds Kevin Mack, visual effects producer for “Big Fish,” and an Oscar winner for “What Dreams May Come.”  

Mack also feels the Oscar race is a bit of a numbers game. “I think the Academy still tends to go with the volume of effects,” he says. “They’re going to be most aware of the shows that have a high profile in terms of effects, like ‘The Lord of the Rings’ and ‘Terminator 3.’ ”

Jim Rygiel — up for his third trophy as f/x supervisor for the “Lord of the Rings” series — concurs. “People constantly ask, ‘How the hell did you do that? Not just technically, but how did you finish the sheer amount?’ ” he says. “I have to ask myself the same question.”

Another factor, Mack says, is simply how intrinsic an effect is to the story. “A lot of being amazed by visual effects is story, and it’s most effective when it’s supporting some amazing story point, like the dinosaurs in ‘Jurassic Park’ or the liquid metal guy in ‘Terminator,’ ” he says. “They’re not just things you’ve never seen before, they’re ideas you’ve never been exposed to.”

Both in terms of technology and ideas, though, it is often the more obvious effects work, such as creatures, fantasy or sci-fi settings or flying figures, that reap the lion’s share of attention over other films that use environmental effects to create reality while not announcing their technological wizardry.  

“In terms of the awards themselves, doing seamless and organic effects is definitely not an award-winning approach,” says Jeffrey A. Okun, visual effects supervisor for “The Last Samurai.” “You actually have to mount a campaign and go out and tell people, ‘There are really 450 shots in this movie.’ ”

Some believe that the best-liked film will carry the technical awards on the basis of its popularity. “I think most Academy members react to how good the film was overall,” says two-time Oscar nominee Stefen Fangmeier, visual effects supervisor for “Master and Commander.” “They go, ‘Oh, I really liked this movie, I’ll vote for it for editing and sound design and visual effects.’ ”

John Clinton, visual effects producer for “The Matrix Reloaded” and “The Matrix Revolutions,” agrees. 

“Popularity of the film has a lot to do with it these days,” he says. Popularity is how many in the effects community explain the 2001 visual effects Oscar win for “Gladiator.” It contained about 90 effects shots, largely digital recreations of ancient Roman structures — and actor Oliver Reed, who died mid-shoot — over the more groundbreaking work done for “Hollow Man” and the complex digital weather in “The Perfect Storm.”

Popularity, of course, is directly linked to B.O, which is also a factor, per eight-time Oscar winner Dennis Muren. 

“I look back at the effects films of 40, 50 years ago where the show that had hardly any effects in it won over amazing effects work,” says Muren, who was visual effects supervisor for “Hulk.” “I saw that when I was a kid and said, ‘What the heck’s going on here?’ Well, one was a success, and the other wasn’t.”

While Academy tastes change yearly, Jim Berney, f/x supervisor for “The Matrix Reloaded” and “Revolutions,” believes “the era of big wow stuff seems to be over, and I think it’s more about the storytelling. Like when (1995’s) ‘Babe’ got it — that is a good example of creative technology to tell a story.”    

While some agree with that, and others disagree, most would echo Muren’s view that the key to winning is to present something unique. “We are talking about special visual effects,” he says, “not just visual effects.”

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Walt Disney HQ LA

    Disney Seeks to Throw Out Gender Pay Gap Lawsuit

    The Walt Disney Co. is seeking to throw out a lawsuit alleging that women employees are paid less than men, arguing that the suit is too sprawling and unwieldy to handle as a class action. Andrus Anderson LLP filed the suit in April, alleging that Disney’s hiring and pay practices have a discriminatory effect on [...]

  • Ford v Ferrari

    Christian Bale, Matt Damon to Campaign in Lead Actor Category for 'Ford v Ferrari'

    Christian Bale and Matt Damon will both campaign in the lead actor category for awards for their work in Fox’s upcoming “Ford v Ferrari,” Variety has learned. “Ford v Ferrari” follows an eccentric, determined team of American engineers and designers, led by automotive visionary Carroll Shelby (Damon) and his British driver, Ken Miles (Bale), who [...]

  • Tezuka's Barbara film

    Tokyo Film Festival: Makoto Tezuka Probes Past and Present in 'Barbara'

    The son of the late Osamu Tezuka, who is known as the “the god of manga” in Japan for his innovative and enduringly popular comics, Makoto Tezuka (also known as Macoto Tezka) long ago escaped his father’s looming shadow, carving out a career as a film and animation director. At the same time, he has [...]

  • Cuba Gooding Jr

    Cuba Gooding Jr. Sued for Allegedly Pinching Nightclub Server

    A Tao nightclub server who alleges that Cuba Gooding Jr., pinched her rear-end last year has sued the Oscar-winning actor for sexual battery. Natasha Ashworth had previously come forward to New York law enforcement, though her name had not been released publicly. Gooding was indicted last week on four misdemeanor counts, including two counts stemming [...]

  • Taika Waititi Natalie Portman SDCC 2019

    Natalie Portman Weighs in on 'Thor: Love and Thunder's' Possible Breast Cancer Storyline

    Natalie Portman doesn’t know if “Thor: Love and Thunder” will include a breast cancer storyline for her character Jane Foster, but she’s definitely intrigued by the possibility. “It’s just very rare that these kinds of big entertainment films look at more serious, real-life issues,” she told Variety at L.A. Dance Project’s 8th annual fundraising gala [...]

  • Luxbox Closes Sales on Venice Film

    Luxbox Closes Sales on Venice Film 'Sole' to U.S., France (EXCLUSIVE)

    Fiorella Moretti and Hedi Zardi’s Paris-based sales agency Luxbox has closed several territory deals on Carlos Sironi’s “Sole,” which screened in Venice Film Festival’s Orizzonti section and Toronto Film Festival’s Discovery sidebar. The film just won the audience award at Pingyao Intl. Film Festival in China and a Special Jury Mention for the lead actors [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content