You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Rocking the foreign lingo vote

Guest column

Some of the year’s most prominent foreign-lingo films — “Motorcycle Diaries,” “Maria Full of Grace” and “A Very Long Engagement” among them — won’t be eligible for the foreign-language Oscar, thanks to their financing sources or the timing of their overseas release.

Goldwyn Films president Meyer Gottlieb, a member of the Foreign Language Screening Committee for 15 years, argues that the biggest problem with this year’s foreign-language race are the Academy’s outdated voting requirements.

I’ve become increasingly concerned that the rules governing foreign-language submissions no longer accomplish the principal goals of the Academy: nominating the best foreign- language films and encouraging the entire Academy to vote.

Here’s how the system works: Each country submits foreign pictures for award consideration. Once films have been submitted (49 films this year), the Foreign Language Screening Committee screens the pictures and selects the five nominees.

The screening committee consists of around 400 Academy members, broken down into three subgroups, each asked to screen about 17 films.

The screenings take place at the Academy on weekday evenings or weekends over a brief period. Each member rates the films numerically. Members must view at least 70% of films assigned to their subgroup or their ratings are not included in the selection of the five nominated pictures. The five pictures receiving the highest score are the nominees.

My concern centers on the makeup of the committee and the restrictions placed on members to qualify to vote. While it is easy to join the committee (just volunteer), there are a few hurdles you must overcome to make your vote count:

You must screen all 17 films. All official screenings are at the Academy Theater. While credit is given for films previously seen at festivals or in screening rooms, you are not permitted to view the films on tape or DVD.

It is a conflict of interest if you are involved in the production, marketing, distribution or financing of a film submitted for consideration.

The above may seem harmless. However, the conflict of interest provision is inconsistent with the nomination and voting process for mainstream Oscar categories. It is based on an honor code that encourages a tattletale mentality amongst members.

Technically everyone at a major studio would be in conflict if his or her so-called independent theatrical or homevideo divisions distributed a film in contention for the foreign-language Oscar, but that isn’t the case. Furthermore, the time commitment required to screen all of the movies is onerous with a day job.

The bottom line is that the committee does not fully represent the Academy membership.

Once the committee selects the five nominated films, the Academy rules require members to see the movies on film, in a theater or screening room, to qualify to vote. You must request a ballot from the Academy and complete a form stating when and where you saw these films. This is the most burdensome rule as the Academy offers limited screenings and there is a brief period between nominee announcements and ballot due dates.

Some of the nominations are not released to theaters so your only choice is Academy screenings. And if you haven’t seen all five nominees you cannot vote.

This opens the door for certain distributors (you know who you are) to play the “hide the movie” game by not offering them for additional screenings, limiting the number of members who qualify to vote.

The number of members who qualify to vote for best foreign film amount to about 250, which is often fewer than the number of members on the Foreign Language Screening Committee. Simple math shows 80 votes wins the Oscar.

Here are just a few simple solutions, which I’ve previously shared with the Academy:

  • Allow members to see nominated films on tape or DVD. The Academy could manufacture the tapes/DVDs and ship them to all members or as a minimum create a library system allowing members to borrow tapes or DVDs.

  • Eliminate the “hide the movie” game by supplying ballots if you’ve seen four of five nominated films. They do not have this requirement for voting in all other major categories including best picture. If screeners are sent to the entire Academy, eliminate this rule!

  • Remove the conflict of interest provision and expand the size of the committee. A larger committee will be more representative of the Academy membership and will remove the risk of those with conflicts of interest to influence the outcome.

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences is a remarkable institution that has achieved much in our industry. Nothing is more important than having our efforts recognized by our peers

As a proud Academy member I say let’s take a fresh approach to this process. I know that we can do a better job. It’s time to start thinking about the future and let go of the past.

More Film

  • Chris Pratt Tom Holland Julia Louis-Dreyfus

    Chris Pratt, Tom Holland, Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Octavia Spencer to Voice Pixar's 'Onward'

    Chris Pratt, Tom Holland, Julia Louis-Dreyfus, and Octavia Spencer are leading the voice cast for “Onward,” Pixar’s next original movie. Pixar had previously referred to the film as an untitled suburban fantasy. Dan Scanlon, who helmed 2013’s “Monsters University” for Pixar, is directing “Onward.” He’s re-teamed with producer Kori Rae, who also produced “Monsters University.” [...]

  • Steve Carell Welcome to Marwen

    Steve Carell on New Film 'Welcome to Marwen' and Reprising His 'Anchorman' Character

    In 2000, Mark Hogancamp was nearly beaten to death by five men outside of a bar. Left with brain damage and little money to afford therapy, Hogancamp began creating miniature doll versions of himself, his friends, and his attackers as a way to cope. This true story inspired the 2010 documentary “Marwencol” and the upcoming [...]

  • Maniac

    Emma Stone, Darren Criss and More React to SAG Award Nominations

    The nominations for the 25th Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards were revealed on Wednesday morning, and “A Star Is Born” commanded the list with four noms alongside TV series “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” and “Ozark.” The awards recognize acting and ensemble performances across television and film, and this year, plenty of performers will be competing [...]

  • Sterling K Brown The Fence

    Sterling K. Brown to Star in Fox Searchlight's 'The Fence' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Following his SAG nomination for actor in a drama series, Sterling K. Brown is in negotiations to star in Fox Searchlight’s biopic “The Fence,” sources tell Variety. Peter Nicks is on board to direct. George Pelecanos and Dennis Lehane, who originally brought the book to HBO before it landed at Searchlight, teamed up to adapt [...]

  • Marvel Studios' BLACK PANTHER..L to R:

    Ryan Coogler on How 'Black Panther' Broke Barriers Below-the-Line, Too

    With more than $1.3 billion at the global box office, “Black Panther” was one of the year’s biggest hits. Though some people expected just another superhero film, the project turned out to be much deeper and more complex than that. Many called it a social turning point because it was the first blockbuster with a [...]

  • Biggest Box Office Hits of 2018

    The Biggest Box Office Hits and Flops of 2018

    It was the revival nobody saw coming. After a dismal 2017, in which the North American box office tumbled to a three-year low, moviegoing rebounded in a big way. And it wasn’t just superhero tentpoles and animated adventures raking in the green. With all due respect to “Avengers: Infinity War” and “Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom,” [...]

  • If Beale Street Could Talk Sharp

    Golden Globes: Amy Adams, Regina King Lead List of Crossover Nominees

    In the age of peak TV, actors, writers, directors and producers, and subsequently their managers and agents, are open for business in any medium, and that new attitude shows in awards nominations, especially when it comes to the Golden Globe acting fields. Amy Adams and Regina King scored nominations in both film and TV categories [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content