×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

. . .for the times, they have already changed

Bigger doesn't mean better in a dereg world

Is it possible Norman Lear is wrong?

For that matter, could the likes of Tom Fontana, Barry Diller and Ted Turner also have misjudged the issue?

All four men, in one form or another, have come out against the FCC’s decision last week to loosen some of the key rules governing the regulation of broadcast television.

A common theme in their dissent has been a fear that allowing congloms to own more TV stations, or to own both a newspaper and a TV station in the same city, will kill off whatever independent voices are left in television.

The result, they say, will be increasingly bland television programming, produced by just a few people.

Their fears, however well-intentioned, aren’t based in fact.

It’s one thing to argue congloms are getting too big and too powerful.

There’s plenty of evidence to suggest arrogance bred by size has led to countless dumb decisions by execs at all levels.

The disaster that was the AOL-Time Warner merger, or the painful transformation of ABC into the Almost Broadcasting Co., demonstrate that corporate IQ doesn’t increase with each acquisition.

But despite the lofty rhetoric from opponents, last week’s action by the FCC really won’t radically overhaul the media landscape. Yes, the big will get bigger — but only incrementally.

Some newspaper chains will add more TV stations to their portfolios, but with most people under 30 getting their news from the Internet or cable, what’s the big deal?

(And most local TV stations would benefit by having some ink-stained wretches mingle more frequently with their blow-dried brethren in broadcasting.)

The Big Four will be able to own more of their own stations, but not many more. With the ownership cap rising from 35% to 45%, it’s not as if the new rules will wipe out local affiliates or smaller station groups overnight.

Some mid- and small-level players in the station group business will suffer or possibly disappear. But why should the TV biz be any different from the rest of corporate America?

Any time a fast-food upstart like Boston Market or Chipotle shows signs of gaining traction, McDonald’s or one of its rivals swoops in to buy it. A small handful of grocery congloms owns most of the supermarkets in the country, yet the vegetables are still fresh.

Dereg critics scoff at comparing broadcasting to selling burgers, arguing the Big Six should be more heavily regulated because they use the public airwaves.

Well, cell phone carriers operate on public airwaves, but nobody expects them to air three hours of semi-educational conversations each week.

What’s more, in an era marked by hundreds of cable channels and broadband Internet connections, it no longer makes sense to impose the same old Divine burdens of public responsibility on broadcasters — and nobody else.

Turner rightfully takes credit for revolutionizing the news business, but his empire was also built on cable channels like TBS Superstation which air a heavy diet of sitcom repeats and B-movies– and have zero obligation to serve the public interest.

The midlevel station owners decrying the FCC’s actions, meanwhile, are often painted as heroic champions of the little guy, ensuring diversity and choice for consumers.

That argument would hold more water if those same station owners hadn’t years ago eliminated virtually all locally produced entertainment or magazine shows in favor of more lucrative syndicated sitcom repeats and turned most local newscasts into tabloid affairs containing just a few morsels of actual information.

Finally, for those who believe conglom growth spells the end of creativity, how to explain shows like “24,” “The West Wing” or “Everybody Loves Raymond”? All managed to find their way onto free, over-the-air TV despite the fact their creators all work for huge companies like AOL-Time Warner, News Corp. or Viacom.

Creators like Aaron Sorkin might not be able to build the one-man empires folks like Lear or Marcy Carsey and Tom Werner established. But it’s not like they’ll go broke, either.

There’s a legitimate debate to be had over whether media companies have become too big. For that matter, it’s worth having discussions about the impact of deregulation on all sorts of industries, from telecom to airlines.

But first, a simple truth needs to be acknowledged: However inept FCC chairman Michael Powell may be as a politician — and the general’s son did a horrible job selling his war plan — the actions the FCC took last week don’t signal the coming of a media Apocalypse.

More TV

  • Homecoming Amazon Studios

    Julia Roberts Will Not Return for 'Homecoming' Season 2

    Julia Roberts will not be starring in “Homecoming” Season 2 at Amazon, Variety has confirmed with sources. The Oscar-winning actress will remain on the show as an executive producer, however. “Homecoming” was picked up for two seasons when it was initially ordered at Amazon, but Roberts only had a one-year deal to star on the show, [...]

  • ‘Metro Exodus’ Opens Up Post-Apocalyptic Russia

    ‘Metro Exodus’ Author On Film, Possible TV Series, Expansive New Game

    Since the launch of the post-apocalyptic survival first-person shooter “Metro 2033” in 2010, the series has kept its action confined to the tunnels running underneath Russia. “Metro Exodus,” due out next month, takes the gameplay to the surface for the first time, going above ground with sprawling levels against a changing backdrop of weather conditions [...]

  • Mr. Peanut to Appear in His

    Mr. Peanut to Appear in His First Super Bowl Commercial

    The monocle-wearing Mr. Peanut is about to offer snack fans an entirely new lens on Super Bowl advertising. Planters, which has featured the anthropomorphic legume for more than a century as its spokes-character, will place him in a 30-second ad slated to appear in the second quarter of CBS’ broadcast of Super Bowl LIII on [...]

  • DRG Boards Sales on Scandi Sci-Fi

    DRG Boards Sales on Scandi Sci-Fi Mystery Series ‘The White Wall’

    Scandinavian sci-fi series “The White Wall” is coming to the international market, starting at NATPE, after DRG picked up international rights to the upcoming project. Finland’s Fire Monkey and Nice Drama, part of the Nordic Entertainment Group, are making “The White Wall” for Swedish pubcaster SVT and its Finnish counterpart, YLE. It will feature a [...]

  • L.A. Teachers' Strike: Hollywood Studios, Unions

    Hollywood Studios, Unions Support Parents and Educators as L.A. Teachers' Strike Rages

    Hollywood unions and entertainment companies have stepped up to support the 31,000 Los Angeles teachers in the second day of a massive strike that’s affected nearly half a million students. More than 50 SAG-AFTRA members picketed at a Tuesday afternoon rally in the driving rain next to the Hollywood & Highland Center with secretary-treasurer Jane [...]

  • R. KellyR. Kelly in concert at

    'Surviving R. Kelly' Producers on the Lifetime Doc's Ripple Effect

    The ripple effect of “Surviving R. Kelly” continues to widen more than a week after the documentary aired on Lifetime, renewing public interest — and outrage — over the litany of sexual abuse allegations against the R&B artist. Lady Gaga and Phoenix have apologized for working with him. Chance the Rapper and other artists are said to [...]

  • Yellowstone

    Viacom Lays Off Paramount Network Staffers Amid Reorganization (EXCLUSIVE)

    Viacom has laid off a number of staffers in its entertainment group, with the majority of the affected employees hailing from Paramount Network, Variety has learned exclusively. A Viacom spokesperson declined to comment. But a source with knowledge of the situation that the number of affected employees was fewer than 20, or less than 2% of [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content