You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Winters chilled in court decision on comicbook

Court tests if work transformative

In a decision that clarifies the line between the First Amendment and the right of publicity, the California Supreme Court held that a DC Comics series featuring two characters named Johnny and Edgar Autumn did not violate the rights of publicity of well-known musicians Johnny and Edgar Winter.

Hailing the decision, Michael Bergman of Weissmann, Wolff, Bergman, Coleman, Grodin & Evall, who represented DC Comics, said, “The Supreme Court made it clear that not only parody but any work with significant creative expression will be protected” in a right of publicity case.

In the comicbook, as in real life, the brothers have pale faces and long white hair. One brother sports a stovepipe hat and the second has red eyes. Completely departing from reality, they are depicted as villainous half-worm, half-human offspring born from the rape of their mother by a supernatural worm creature .

In its decision, the court distinguished the Winter case from its earlier decision in the Three Stooges case, involving an artist who sold lithographs and T-shirts with a drawing of the trio that the artist had made. In that case the court found that the right of publicity prevailed over the First Amendment because there was no transformative or creative contribution. The skill of the artist was simply used to create literal depictions of the Three Stooges and exploit their fame.

In contrast, Johnny and Edgar Winter were the raw material for the half-human, half-worm comicbook characters. In addition, the court ruled that the comic did not threaten the Winter brothers’ right of publicity because they would be unsatisfactory pictures for fans.

Laying down guidelines, the court held that the test is whether the work is transformative, not whether it is parody or satire or serious social commentary.

Winter brothers attorney Vince Chieffo said he was disappointed in the decision, but took heart in the fact that the Supreme Court sent their false advertising claim back to the Court of Appeal for decision.

More Scene

  • Barbra Streisand and Gisele Bundchen

    Barbra Streisand and Gisele Bündchen to Be Honored at UCLA Science Gala

    Science can be very glamorous. It certainly will be during Oscar week on Feb. 21 when the UCLA Institute of the Environment & Sustainability (IoES) honors Barbra Streisand and Gisele Bündchen for environmental activism at its annual Hollywood for Science Gala. “When I moved to LA, the air was unbreathable. Rivers were catching fire in [...]

  • Don Cheadle and Andrew Rannells Black

    Don Cheadle, Andrew Rannells Talk Snorting 'Coke' on 'Black Monday'

    “Black Monday” show creators David Caspe and Jordan Cahen divulged an intriguing detail to come later in the first season of the new Showtime comedy at its world premiere, held at the Theatre at Ace Hotel on Monday night in Los Angeles. “The fourth or fifth episode opens with a sexual harassment seminar, which very well [...]

  • Alfonso Cuaron attends the 44th Annual

    Alfonso Cuarón to LAFCA: 'Thanks to Your Help We Can Break Down Walls'

    Inclusion was the big winner at the L.A. Film Critics Association Awards, which was held Saturday night at the InterContinental in Century City. “This year’s winners are the most diverse in LAFCA’s 43-year history,” announced its president, Claudia Puig, adding that 14 out of their 18 awards were won by women and people of color. [...]

  • Mandatory Credit: Photo by Max Malandrino/REX/Shutterstock

    Hollywood Power Players Assemble to Save Iconic Deli Nate 'n Al

    A group of Hollywood executives and celebrities have banded together with the intent to save Beverly Hills deli and star haunt Nate ‘n Al, a stone’s throw from tourist destination Rodeo Drive. A consortium of investors including music kingpin Irving Azoff and wife Shelli, Universal Filmed Entertainment Group chairman Jeff Shell, and Rande Gerber and [...]

  • Charlie Collier, FOX Chief Executive Officer

    'The Passage' Team Talks Diversifying Races, Genders and Ages of Book Characters

    “The Passage” star Saniyya Sidney was unaware that the book version of her character was originally white until her father, a fan of Justin Cronin’s apocalyptic trilogy, informed her during the audition process. “I was like, ‘Oh, she is?'” Sidney told Variety at Thursday’s series premiere in Santa Monica, Calif. “And when I got it, [...]

  • MAYFAIR HOTEL - Ballroom

    The New Space Race Energizes Awards Party Scene

    When planning an elegant A-list dinner for 10 to gala parties for a thousand, event planners have a sophisticated mix of locations to choose from in New York and Los Angeles. Variety looks at new and updated venues that cater to gatherings during Hollywood’s awards season, and throughout the year welcome all kinds of happenings [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content