×

The Mudge Boy

Sensitive direction and a touching performance from Emile Hirsch in the title role help counter some dramatic naivete and awkward, at times unintentional, humor in "The Mudge Boy." Set in rural Vermont, the drama deals with love, grief, sexuality and the stigma of being an outsider.

With:
Duncan Mudge - Emile Hirsch Perry Foley - Thomas Guiry Edgar Mudge - Richard Jenkins Brent - Pablo Schreiber Travis - Zachary Knighton Scotty - Ryan Donowho Tonya - Meredith Handerhan April - Beckie King

Sensitive direction and a touching performance from Emile Hirsch in the title role help counter some dramatic naivete and awkward, at times unintentional, humor in “The Mudge Boy.” Set in rural Vermont, the drama deals with love, grief, sexuality and the stigma of being an outsider. Shepherded through the Sundance Screenwriter’s Lab and expanded by writer-director Michael Burke from his 1998 short “Fishbelly White,” the ultimately affecting Showtime presentation seems an unlikely candidate for theatrical play, but should resonate with cable viewers.

The sudden death of his mother from a heart attack results in a communications breakdown between tender-hearted teenage misfit Duncan Mudge (Hirsch) and his stoically unyielding father (Richard Jenkins). Duncan seeks comfort in his pet chicken and his mother’s clothes, tooling around town on her bicycle. His weird behavior earns him the derision of the local boys and the incomprehension of his father, who attempts to smother his son’s peculiarities by pushing him into farm labor. But the boy’s need for acceptance and warmth remain unsatisfied.

Duncan strikes up a tentative friendship with Perry (Thomas Guiry), a rugged farmhand conflicted by feelings of suppressed sexuality. Responding to Duncan’s softness, Perry enjoys the boy’s company when the two are alone together, but seems uncomfortable when they are part of a larger group of rowdy town youths, who call Duncan “Chicken Boy.”

When Perry’s sexual desire overcomes him, Duncan is pushed into dangerous territory, his responses confused by emotional hunger. But when the older boy betrays his friendship to guard his own secret, Duncan reacts with a dramatic, violent gesture, the shocked aftermath of which draws him closer to his father in grief.

As Duncan increasingly reaches out to Perry for the connection he misses at home, Burke’s screenplay keeps an interesting ambiguity in play. The frisson between the boys is driven by both emotional and sexual needs, though the precise breakdown of feelings becomes clear only later, and to some degree is left open to interpretation.

Where the film runs into problems is in Duncan’s more outre behavior. Burke’s script knowingly mines the humor of adolescent awkwardness, but given that one of the most important of Duncan’s relationships is with his chicken — not the most dignified of animals — the line between poignant and ridiculous often blurs. In particular, Duncan’s habit of slipping the chicken’s head inside his mouth to calm the bird seems like sexual innuendo within a context in which gay sexuality figures prominently. Even clumsier is the revelation that his mother taught him the skill.

Despite some unenviable demands made on him, Hirsch (“The Dangerous Lives of Altar Boys,” “The Emperor’s Club”) gives Duncan an unguarded vulnerability and sweetly trusting nature that ensure emotional investment in him. The young actor’s delicate looks strongly resemble those of a softer Joaquin Phoenix, or Leonardo DiCaprio circa “What’s Eating Gilbert Grape.” Guiry and Jenkins both provide solid support in the other key roles.

Graced with a gentle, elegantly unobtrusive score, the drama is handsomely shot in peaceful rural settings, often from detached angles that underscore its melancholy mood. Burke’s debut may compromise some of its emotional truths with unintended amusement, but the film’s sincerity, humanity and compassion make it difficult to dismiss.

Popular on Variety

The Mudge Boy

Production: A Showtime presentation of a First Cold Press production. Produced by Elizabeth W. Alexander, Alison Benson, Randy Ostrow. Executive producer, Stanley Tucci. Directed, written by Michael Burke.

Crew: Camera (color), Vanja Cernjul; editor, Alfonso Goncalves; music, Marcelo Zarvos; production designer, David Doernberg; art director, Bartholomew Miali; set decorator, Victoria Morris; costume designer, Toni Fusco; sound (Dolby Digital), Damien Elias Canelos; line producer, George Paaswell; associate producer, Kevin Burke; assistant director, Thomas Fatone; casting, Kathleen Chopin, Michele Ortlip. Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (Dramatic Competition), Jan. 17, 2003. Running time: 94 MIN.

With: Duncan Mudge - Emile Hirsch Perry Foley - Thomas Guiry Edgar Mudge - Richard Jenkins Brent - Pablo Schreiber Travis - Zachary Knighton Scotty - Ryan Donowho Tonya - Meredith Handerhan April - Beckie King

More Film

  • Fernando Meirelles The Two Popes

    AFI Fest Adds 'The Two Popes,' 'Aeronauts,' Alan Pakula Tribute

    The American Film Institute has added “The Two Popes” and “The Aeronauts” as galas during the upcoming AFI Fest along with a tribute to the late director Alan Pakula. AFI had previously announced that the romantic drama “Queen & Slim” would launch the 33rd annual festival on Nov. 14 and close with the world premiere [...]

  • Julie Andrews

    Julie Andrews Recalls Husband Blake Edwards' Battle With Depression

    The line to see Julie Andrews at the 92Y wrapped around the square of a sprawling New York City block. Seventy years since the start of her career, 60 since she asked “Wouldn’t It Be Loverly?” as Lerner and Loewe’s first Eliza and 50 since she sang “The Sound of Music” before the Eastern Alps [...]

  • Bloodshot (Vin Diesel) in Columbia Pictures'

    Vin Diesel Comes Back to Life in 'Bloodshot' Trailer

    Vin Diesel is coming back again and again in Sony Pictures’ first trailer for “Bloodshot.” In the forthcoming superhero adventure, Diesel portrays Ray Garrison a.k.a. Bloodshot, a soldier who gets rebuilt by a corporation following his death. The clip, released Monday and scored to Johnny Cash’s rendition of the ballad “Memories are Made of This,” [...]

  • Bouli Lanners Teams With 'Peaky Blinders'

    Bouli Lanners Teams With 'Peaky Blinders' Director Tim Mielants on 'Wise Blood'

    Bouli Lanners, the Belgian actor-director of “The Giants” and “Eldorado,” is teaming with “Peaky Blinders” helmer Tim Mielants to direct “Wise Blood,” an English-language film that will star “Game of Thrones” actor Michelle Fairley and Julian Glover. “Wise Blood” is a Belgian-Scottish-French co-production between Versus Production, Barry Crerar, and Playtime, which will handle international sales [...]

  • Bombshell Charlize Theron Megyn Kelly

    'Bombshell': Why Charlize Theron Was Terrified of Playing Megyn Kelly

    Charlize Theron is getting some of the best buzz of her career for channeling Megyn Kelly in “Bombshell,” but the Oscar-winning actress admits she almost turned down the role. “I was shit scared,” Theron said during a question-and-answer session following a Manhattan screening of “Bombshell” on Sunday. Partly, she was worried about portraying someone who [...]

  • Sean Hayes and Todd Milliner's Hazy

    Sean Hayes and Todd Milliner's Hazy Mills to Co-Produce SAG Awards

    Sean Hayes and Todd Milliner’s Hazy Mills Productions have joined the SAG Awards producing team. The guild announced this morning that Kathy Connell will once again serve as the show’s producer along with Hayes and Milliner in partnership with Avalon Harbor. “Attending the SAG Awards has always been a pleasure and a privilege for me,” [...]

  • Maleficent Mistress of Evil

    Box Office: Why 'Maleficent: Mistress of Evil' Fizzled

    Despite nabbing first place at the domestic box office, Disney’s “Maleficent: Mistress of Evil” debuted significantly below expectations and demonstrated that even the most powerful studio in Hollywood is susceptible to missteps. The follow-up to 2014’s “Maleficent” kicked off in North America with a lackluster $36 million bow, an underwhelming result for a film that [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content