You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Soldier’s Girl

For at least half the running time of "Soldier's Girl," the account of the killing at a Kentucky military base in 1999 of a G.I. involved with a transgendered nightclub performer is as pedestrian as telemovies come. But pic recovers in later reels, boosted by superior performances and a powerful final act.

Barry Winchell - Troy Garity Calpernia Addams - Lee Pace Sgt. Carlos Diaz - Andre Braugher Justin Fisher - Shawn Hatosy Calvin Glover - Philip Eddolls

For at least half the running time of “Soldier’s Girl,” director Frank Pierson and screenwriter Ron Nyswaner’s account of the killing at a Kentucky military base in 1999 of a G.I. emotionally involved with a transgendered nightclub performer is as pedestrian as telemovies come. But pic recovers in later reels, boosted by superior performances and a powerful final act. Sketching the relationship with persuasive integrity, the drama quietly builds a sense of indignation over policy regarding gays in the military and the inadequacy of mental health screening for soldiers trained to feed their aggression. Exposure at gay festivals seems certain in addition to a strong reception on cable.

The true story of unsophisticated, learning-disabled G.I. Barry Winchell (Troy Garity) and Calpernia Addams (Lee Pace), a Nashville drag entertainer en route to sexual reassignment, inevitably will draw comparisons with films like “Boys Don’t Cry” and “The Crying Game.” The fundamental difference here is that the ostensibly straight soldier is aware almost from the beginning that his lover started life as a man and still has some of the parts.

Pierson and Nyswaner (“Philadelphia”) devote an inordinate amount of time to by-the-numbers scenes of grueling military training and to less-than-sensational drag numbers before focusing more intimately on the central relationship.

Dragged along for a laugh to a gay bar by a bunch of his airborne infantry buddies, Barry meets Calpernia and is immediately drawn to the exotic creature for her beauty and warmth. She in turn responds to his gentlemanly manner, marveling that a handsome straight boy would want to see her again. Despite confessing to being white trash underneath the makeup, Calpernia is an intelligent, sensitive woman, who prior to starting sex reassignment was a Navy combat medic during the Gulf War, with a higher rank than Barry.

As their tentative courtship overcomes some initial nervousness and progresses to sex and love, the relationship between Barry and his unbalanced, pill-popping roommate Fisher (Shawn Hatosy) also undergoes changes. Issues regarding Fisher’s sexual identity and psychiatric problems and the exact nature of his closeness to Barry drive increasingly manipulative behavior designed to damage his friend.

Fisher begins spreading unspecific rumors about a gay soldier around the base, which starts a campaign by the infantry’s hard-ass drill sergeant (Barclay Hope) to flush out the culprit. While underlining the heinousness of the military’s “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy, Nyswaner is careful not to demonize the entire institution, presenting a voice of reason and fairness in sympathetic Sgt. Diaz (Andre Braugher).

The drama’s well calibrated climactic chain of events kicks in as Fisher insidiously exploits the tension between Barry and Glover (Philip Eddolls), an Oklahoma redneck barely old enough to qualify for the Army. An altercation between Barry and Glover blows over, but Fisher keeps turning the screws and then walks away, leaving Glover to simmer before exploding into stunning violence. The killing is effectively intercut with Calpernia lip-synching to Annie Lennox’s “Cold” in a transgender talent pageant.

While the filmmakers’ approach for the most part is blandly conventional and takes far too long to introduce any real edge into the situation, the drama improves immeasurably as it goes, becoming both affecting and upsetting. The aftershock to the murder also resonates in more unexpected ways, as Calpernia’s loss segues to a new sense of self-worth.

Both Garity and newcomer Pace give complex, controlled performances, full-bodied and richly empathetic, making the union between this unlikely couple seem entirely plausible and natural. Hatosy and Eddolls also register strongly with incisive depictions of two dangerously unmonitored, volatile misfits, each of them scary and stupid in different ways.

Soldier's Girl

Production: A Showtime presentation of a Bachrach/Gottlieb production. Produced by Linda Gottlieb, Doro Bachrach. Co-producer Ron Nyswaner. Directed by Frank Pierson. Screenplay, Nyswaner.

Crew: Camera (color), Paul Sarossy; editor, Katina Zinner; music, Jan A.P. Kaczmarek; production designer, Lindsey Hermer-Bell; art director, Peter Emmink; set decorator, David Edgar; costume designer, Patrick Antosh; sound (Dolby), Bill McMillan; line producer, Lena Cordina; assistant director, Patrick Tidy; casting, Douglas Aibel. Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (Premieres), Jan. 20, 2003. Running time: 112 MIN.

With: Barry Winchell - Troy Garity Calpernia Addams - Lee Pace Sgt. Carlos Diaz - Andre Braugher Justin Fisher - Shawn Hatosy Calvin Glover - Philip EddollsWith: Merwin Mondesir, Daniel Petronijevic, Mike Realba, Jeanie Calleja, Barclay Hope, Tulsi Balram.

More Film

  • 'Aladdin,' 'Pokemon: Detective Pikachu,' 'Shaft' Set

    'Aladdin,' 'Pokemon: Detective Pikachu' and 'Shaft' Set for China Debuts

    Disney’s new live-action “Aladdin” will release in China on May 24, day-and-date with North America, giving the studio a run of three films in Chinese theaters as many months.  Two other Hollywood titles will also hit the big screen in the Middle Kingdom in the coming months: “Pokemon: Detective Pikachu” on May 10 and the [...]

  • Patrimonio

    Film Review: 'Patrimonio'

    Though it never really went away on much of the globe, a sort of creeping feudalism is making such a striking comeback — with the ever-more-fabulously-rich squeezing the poor of every dime and resource — that Lisa F. Jackson and Sarah Teale’s documentary “Patrimonio” feels like a frightening portent. Will such crude appropriations of land [...]

  • Fan Bingbing

    Fan Bingbing Starts to Re-Emerge Months After Tax Scandal

    Half a year after she was found guilty of tax fraud and disappeared from the public eye, Chinese superstar Fan Bingbing has begun to signal her comeback, attending a gala event and launching her own beauty product on social media this week. The 37-year-old actress unexpectedly hit the red carpet in Beijing on Monday at [...]

  • I Trapped the Devil

    Film Review: 'I Trapped the Devil'

    “I Trapped the Devil” sounds like the title of a sermon or gospel song, but it’s a very literal-minded statement coming from the mouth of a leading character in writer-director Josh Lobo’s debut feature. This being a horror film, there’s a chance he’s even literally correct, rather than simply mad. A mixed-bag frightfest, IFC’s limited [...]

  • American Factory

    Tribeca Film Review: 'American Factory'

    When the last truck rolled off the assembly line of the General Motors factory outside Dayton, Ohio, filmmakers Steven Bognar and Julia Reichert were there to film it, documenting the end of a certain American dream, along with the unemployment of more than 2,000 people — down from 6,000 in more prosperous times. That was [...]

  • 'Recorder: The Marion Stokes Project': Truth-Teller

    Tribeca Film Review: 'Recorder: The Marion Stokes Project'

    VHS tapes now have a weird sort of stodgy magical aura. Long ago, they were standard. With the arrival of DVD, they were behind the curve. Then they were totally outdated and unworkable (at a certain point, who besides Quentin Tarantino still had an operational VCR?). But now they’re so old they’re like mystic electromagnetic [...]


    Shorts Encourage Women to STEAM Careers

    Straight Up Films created the anthology “Power/On” of five shorts focused on encouraging girls in STEAM (science, technology, engineering and math with the arts thrown in) directed by actresses Rosario Dawson, Julie Bowen, Ana Brenda Contreras, Lisa Edelstein, and Nikki Reed. With support from YouTube, the shorts premiered Wednesday at the Google campus in Playa [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content