×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Nat Turner: A Troublesome Property

Charles Burnett's insightful, if somewhat foreshortened docu on slave-revolt leader Nat Turner underlines the subtitle: "A Troublesome Property." Turner was a troublesome "property" to his masters, who he would eventually slaughter, and his story has remained troublesome for historians, novelists and filmmakers.

With:
Nat Turner (Gray) - Carl Lumbly Thomas R. Gray - Tom Nowicki Nat Turner (Edmonds) - Tommy Hicks Nat Turner (Styron) - James Opher Nat Turner (Brown) - Michael LeMelle Nat Turner - Billy Dye Young Nat Turner - Phillip Miller Nat Turner (Stowe) - Patrick Waller

Charles Burnett’s insightful, if somewhat foreshortened documentary on controversial slave-revolt leader Nat Turner underlines the subtitle: “A Troublesome Property.” Turner was, of course, a troublesome “property” to his masters, who he would eventually slaughter. And his story has remained troublesome for historians, novelists and filmmakers — including Burnett. Inasmuch as the film is about how authorial biases influence artistic representations of history to create legend, Burnett and collaborators Frank Christopher and Kenneth S. Greenberg encompass the enigma. Originally fashioned to feature length before being edited down to current, PBS-friendly incarnation, some of the power of “Nat Turner: A Troublesome Property” has been lost in the translation.

Burnett’s goal is to take an evenhanded approach to the various literary accounts (both fictionalized and allegedly non-fictional) of Turner’s life and revolt, starting with Thomas R. Gray’s 1831 “The Confessions of Nat Turner” and continuing through to William Styron’s 1966 novel of the same name. Drawing on additional source material by Harriet Beecher Stowe, William Wells Brown and Randolph Edmonds, Burnett has filmed scenes from these disparate dramatic interpretations, in each case trying to remain as true as possible to the original author’s viewpoint. A different actor plays Turner in each sequence (beginning with the marvelous Carl Lumbly as Gray’s Turner).

At the same time that he tries to examine all angles, Burnett acknowledges the futility of objectivity in history and art, and he never positions himself outside the material or manipulates viewer sentiments to further his own polemic. Ultimately he turns his camera on himself and his film crew (in a wonderful, Kiarostami-style reversal) to acknowledge his own “documentary” is but another inevitably biased interpretation.

Pic’s dramatizations offer Turner as hero, martyr, fanatic and even hot-blooded lothario. In-between, Burnett presents a diverse assortment of interviews with contempo writers and thinkers who do little to clear up the confusion. From historians Eric Foner and Peter Wood to civil-rights activists Ossie Davis and Ayuko Babu to the surviving descendants of Turner and his masters and, finally, to author Styron (very much the big “get” here), the only thing anyone can agree on is how little is known about Turner and how that anonymity has made Turner’s icon so enduring and so malleable. And Burnett comes at the argument from all sides, always one step ahead — though sometimes too fastidious about considering all points of view.

Probably Burnett’s most provocative — and, again, rhetorical — query –is whether artists should be forced to account for historical accuracy to the point that it stifles their creative impulses. It’s a timely discussion, given recent media fracases surrounding films like “The Hurricane” and “A Beautiful Mind”; though with respect to Turner, the situation is even touchier, given his standing as a radical icon in the struggle for African-American civil rights.

Burnett’s film was even stronger on this account in its original version (shown as a “work in progress” at last year’s Full Frame Documentary Film Festival), which was 26 minutes longer and included an entire section about the abortive 20th Century-Fox filming of Styron’s novel, to have been directed by Norman Jewison with James Earl Jones as Turner. There was also more material from Burnett’s interview with Styron and, most intriguingly (both for its original inclusion and eventual deletion) a more elaborate analysis of the incendiary aspects of Styron’s text.

While this re-edit is an improvement over the original in other respects — the cutting is more fluid, the narration has been re-recorded and the archival material (still photos, news clippings, etc.) has been three-dimensionally embossed (a la “The Kid Stays in the Picture”) — it seems, overall, a more timid, less confrontational movie.

Tech aspects are superior for a docu, particularly in the staged dramatic scenes (shot on 24P video for a film-like look), which have a bigscreen lushness.

Nat Turner: A Troublesome Property

Production: Produced by Frank Christopher. Co-producer, Kenneth S. Greenberg. Directed by Charles Burnett. Screenplay, Burnett, Frank Christopher, Kenneth S. Greenberg.

Crew: Camera (color, digital video/24P HD video), John Demps; editor, Michael Colin, Frank Christopher; music, Todd Capps; additional music, Stephen James Taylor; production designer, Liba Daniels; art director, Michael Clark; costume designer, Sharen Davis; sound, John Kyoh; associate producer, Cynthia Griffin; assistant director, Kris Krengel; casting, Liz Marks. Reviewed at Pan-African Film Festival, L.A., Feb. 16, 2003. Running time: 57 MIN.

With: Nat Turner (Gray) - Carl Lumbly Thomas R. Gray - Tom Nowicki Nat Turner (Edmonds) - Tommy Hicks Nat Turner (Styron) - James Opher Nat Turner (Brown) - Michael LeMelle Nat Turner - Billy Dye Young Nat Turner - Phillip Miller Nat Turner (Stowe) - Patrick WallerWith: Eric Foner, Peter Wood, Ekewueme Michael Thelwell, Thomas Parramore, Henry Louis Gates Jr., Mary Kemp Davis, Vincent Harding, Herbert Aptheker, William Styron, Kitty Futrell, Eugene Genovese, Rick Francis, Bruce Turner, Martha Minow, Ray Winbush, Ossie Davis, Dr. Alvin Poussaint, Ayuko Babu, Louise Meriwether, Loyle Hairston, James McGee, Charles Burnett, Kenneth S. Greenberg. Narrator: Alfre Woodard.

More Film

  • 'Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse' Weaves Inclusive

    The Secret Power of 'Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse' Is Inclusion

    In a year that gave us films like “Black Panther” and “Crazy Rich Asians,” this weekend’s “Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse” delivers one more home run for underrepresented groups in media in 2018. An animated film that takes advantage of Sony’s piece of the Marvel pie, “Spider-Verse” not only puts a mixed-race, middle-class teenager in the [...]

  • Jeff BridgesJeff Bridges, who stars in

    Jeff Bridges to Receive Cecil B. DeMille Award at 2019 Golden Globes

    The Hollywood Foreign Press Association has announced that Jeff Bridges will receive the Cecil B. DeMille award at the 76th Golden Globes on Jan. 6, 2019. Bridges has starred in films like “The Big Lebowski,” “Crazy Heart,” “True Grit,” and “The Fabulous Baker Boys.” More Reviews Concert Review: Childish Gambino Takes L.A. to Church for [...]

  • Charlotte Rampling Euphoria

    Berlin Film Festival: Charlotte Rampling to Receive Honorary Golden Bear

    Oscar-nominated actress Charlotte Rampling, whose career has spanned more than 100 film and television roles, will be honored with a special Golden Bear at the upcoming Berlin Film Festival. The fest will also pay homage to Rampling by screening a selection of her work, including Sidney Lumet’s “The Verdict” (1982), Francois Ozon’s “Swimming Pool” (2003) [...]

  • The Sisters Brothers

    France's Lumieres Awards Unveil Nominations

    Jacques Audiard’s “The Sisters Brothers” has been nominated for best film and director at the 24th Lumieres Awards, France’s equivalent of the Golden Globes. The Western starring Joaquin Phoenix, John C. Reilly and Jake Gyllenhaal world-premiered at Venice Film Festival, where it earned Audiard a best director award. More Reviews Concert Review: Childish Gambino Takes [...]

  • CAA to Represent Peter Chan's We

    CAA to Represent Peter Chan's We Pictures

    Creative Artists Agency (CAA) has signed with We Pictures, the production and distribution company founded by Hong Kong-born director and producer Peter Chan Ho-sun. It aims to boost the company’s footprint both in China and abroad. Within China, CAA China will help We Pictures to develop new business partnerships and find new sources of investment [...]

  • Elizabeth Karlsen, Stephen Woolley to Receive

    'Carol' Producers Elizabeth Karlsen, Stephen Woolley to Be Honored by BAFTA

    Elizabeth Karlsen and Stephen Woolley, the producers of such films as “Carol,” “Their Finest” and the recent “Colette” starring Keira Knightley, will receive the Outstanding British Contribution to Cinema Award at the BAFTA Film Awards. The prolific pair run Number 9 Films and have a long list of credits. They will pick up their accolade at [...]

  • BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY

    Korea Box Office: 'Rhapsody' Reclaims Top Spot, Beats ‘Spider-Verse’

    “Bohemian Rhapsody” reclaimed top place at the South Korean box office, overtaking “Default,” after spending two weekends in second place. The Fox release earned $4.38 million from 554,000 admissions for a total of $61.0 million from 7.94 million admissions. In its seventh weekend of release “Rhapsody” accounted for 27% of the weekend box office. CJ [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content