You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Beware l’affaire Blair

Variety editorial

The Jayson Blair saga is the talk of the media biz and for good reason. Seldom does a young reporter get taken to the woodshed in a 13,800-word package starting on Page One of the Sunday New York Times.

But the newspaper’s response is troubling.

In demonizing the 27-year-old Blair, the lead article largely exonerated desk editors, copy editors, managers and even the Times accounting department — all essential players in the sorry drama.

The story is all the news fit to squint, an eye-taxing overabundance of gotchas and tsk-tsks. Its pious tone reflects management’s concern for the paper’s august legacy as much as it does a genuine concern for fairness and accountability.

At one point, it suggests that the paper’s top two editors guided Blair to “the understaffed national desk.” Understaffed? Were staffing levels Blair’s fault too?

Just how blind were the top editors to Blair’s limitations in their quest to advance a minority reporter?

The whole episode suggests that the Times was, despite all the signals to the contrary, simply unable to fathom that a reporter in its own newsroom could be so calculatingly deceptive.

Enough wrong was wrought by Blair that a mea culpa was inevitable and appropriate. A simple correction would not do.

But were readers really served by this exercise as much as the Times believed they would be? It appears that responsibility for all the miscues and mistakes has not yet been appropriately assigned in this case. Tune in tomorrow.

More Scene

  • Brandon Flynn, Timothy Granaderos, Alisha Boe,

    Alisha Boe Says Brock Turner Case Was Her 'Bible' for '13 Reasons Why' Season 2

    The Jayson Blair saga is the talk of the media biz and for good reason. Seldom does a young reporter get taken to the woodshed in a 13,800-word package starting on Page One of the Sunday New York Times. But the newspaper’s response is troubling. In demonizing the 27-year-old Blair, the lead article largely exonerated […]

  • Yara ShahidiMTV Movie & TV Awards,

    Yara Shahidi, Noah Schnapp, More Talk the Dangers of Social Media at MTV Awards

    The Jayson Blair saga is the talk of the media biz and for good reason. Seldom does a young reporter get taken to the woodshed in a 13,800-word package starting on Page One of the Sunday New York Times. But the newspaper’s response is troubling. In demonizing the 27-year-old Blair, the lead article largely exonerated […]

  • A Night in the Writers' Room

    Parity Takes Center Stage at Variety's 'A Night in the Writers' Room' Drama Panel

    The Jayson Blair saga is the talk of the media biz and for good reason. Seldom does a young reporter get taken to the woodshed in a 13,800-word package starting on Page One of the Sunday New York Times. But the newspaper’s response is troubling. In demonizing the 27-year-old Blair, the lead article largely exonerated […]

  • American Black Film Festival opening night

    Trevor Jackson Was Originally Told He Was 'Too Young' to Star in 'Superfly' Remake

    The Jayson Blair saga is the talk of the media biz and for good reason. Seldom does a young reporter get taken to the woodshed in a 13,800-word package starting on Page One of the Sunday New York Times. But the newspaper’s response is troubling. In demonizing the 27-year-old Blair, the lead article largely exonerated […]

  • Women In Film Crystal and Lucy

    Brie Larson Says She Learned Her Own Strength Playing 'Captain Marvel' Role

    The Jayson Blair saga is the talk of the media biz and for good reason. Seldom does a young reporter get taken to the woodshed in a 13,800-word package starting on Page One of the Sunday New York Times. But the newspaper’s response is troubling. In demonizing the 27-year-old Blair, the lead article largely exonerated […]

  • 2018 NBCUniversal Upfront

    Andy Samberg on Returning to NBC With 'Brooklyn Nine-Nine': 'It Feels Like Home'

    The Jayson Blair saga is the talk of the media biz and for good reason. Seldom does a young reporter get taken to the woodshed in a 13,800-word package starting on Page One of the Sunday New York Times. But the newspaper’s response is troubling. In demonizing the 27-year-old Blair, the lead article largely exonerated […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content