×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

High court rejects Fox’s argument in video case

Net failed to renew copyright in original series

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court ruled Monday that 20th Century Fox could not use trademark law to bar a third party from distributing videos incorporating documentary footage from WWII that had fallen into the public domain.

The 8-0 ruling capped an obscure case involving Fox and Eugene, Ore.-based Dastar Corp. that began in 1995, when Dastar began distributing in Europe the video set “World War II Campaigns,” which drew on footage originally compiled for a 1949 TV series owned by Fox.

Although Fox acknowledged that it had failed to renew its copyright in the original series, allowing it to enter the public domain, it sued Dastar anyway after the vid company removed all references to Fox or series producer Time Inc. in the credits, replacing them with its own introductory material saying “Dastar Corp. presents” and an “Entertainment Distributing Production.”

In its suit, Fox accused Dastar of “reverse passing off,” under the Lanham Act, which generally prevents the unaccredited copying of a work.

Original doc was based on Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower’s 1948 book for Doubleday, “Crusade in Europe,” recounting his years as supreme allied commander in WWII. Fox acquired TV rights to the book and assigned Time to produce the series.

In 1975, Doubleday renewed its copyright on the book, but Fox neglected to renew its claims to the footage.

In 1988, Fox reacquired the TV rights to Eisenhower’s book, including the exclusive right to distribute the original series on video. It sublicensed rights to New Line Home Video and SFM Entertainment.

Case has been watched by public domain advocates as an attempt by Fox to backdoor copyright law and lay exclusive claim to public domain material by using trademark and unfair competition laws.

Writing for the robes, Justice Antonin Scalia said Fox should have renewed its copyright to have a case. “Had Fox renewed the copyright in the (‘Crusade’) television series, it would have had an easy claim of copyright infringement,” Scalia said in a 15-page opinion.

The Lanham Act, he said, “is not designed to protect originality or creativity,” the traditional purview of copyright law. Instead, Congress meant it to apply only to “tangible goods for sale.”

Ruling overturns a $1.5 million judgment in Fox’s favor handed down last year by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco.

Scalia noted that there is still a live issue in the case concerning Doubleday’s copyright in the book, which may have been infringed by Dastar.

(Paul Sweeting is a reporter for Daily Variety sister publication Video Business.)

More Digital

  • Colin Kroll Dead Vine Obit

    HQ Trivia and Vine Co-Founder Colin Kroll Dies at 35

    Colin Kroll, co-founder of the Vine video app and the HQ Trivia game, was found dead in his Manhattan apartment early Sunday of an apparent drug overdose, Variety has confirmed. He was 35. New York Police Department officers responded at 12:18 a.m. Sunday, Dec. 16, to a call by Kroll’s girlfriend who was concerned about [...]

  • Nick Eh 30, StoneMountain64

    CAA Signs Gaming Influencers Nick Eh 30, StoneMountain64

    CAA has signed two popular live-streaming battle royale gamers — Nicholas Amyoony, better known as Nick Eh 30, and David Steinberg, aka StoneMountain64 — for representation. CAA said it will work to create opportunities for Nick Eh 30 (above left) and StoneMountain64 (above right) in all areas, including TV, motion pictures, touring, digital distribution and [...]

  • Amazon Adds NBA League Pass to

    Amazon Adds NBA League Pass Live-Streaming Games to Prime Video Channels

    Amazon is bringing pro hoops action to Prime Video Channels: The ecommerce giant now offers NBA League Pass as part of its lineup of 150-plus subscription options for Prime members in the U.S. It’s the first U.S. live-sports subscription service on Prime Video Channels. Prime members can subscribe to NBA League Pass via Prime Video [...]

  • Fifty Shades of Grey

    International Piracy Ring Stole Over 25,000 Movie and TV Digital Files, U.S. Feds Say

    A five-member international hacking crime ring stole more than 25,000 files for Hollywood movies and TV shows and illegally offered hundreds of them for sale online, according to U.S. law enforcement officials. A federal grand jury in L.A. on Wednesday (Dec. 12) indicted five men, identified as residing in the U.K., India, Dubai and Malaysia, [...]

  • Phil Schiller, Apple's senior vice president

    Apple to Update iPhones in China to Avoid Sales Ban

    Apple is pushing out a software update to iPhones in China to address a recent court order obtained by Qualcomm that banned the sale of certain iPhone models in the country. The update will allow the company to continue selling its phones in China, company representatives told Reuters Friday morning. The Fuzhou Intermediate People’s Court [...]

  • Kevin Reilly Variety Cover

    Kevin Reilly Named Content Chief for WarnerMedia Streaming Service

    Kevin Reilly — a veteran television exec who has led programming at NBC, FX, Fox, and most recently Turner Broadcasting — has been tapped to head content strategy for the still-nascent streaming service that WarnerMedia plans to launch next year. Reilly, who has led programming at Turner brands TNT and TBS since 2015, will serve [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content