You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Clearing up the category conundrum

How supporters become leads

In 1995 and 1996, Julianna Margulies was nominated for drama actress for playing nurse Carol Hathaway on “ER.” In 1997, she was nominated as a lead.

From 1995-99, “Friends” co-star Matthew Perry was considered for comedy supporting actor. In 2000, he was submitted in the lead actor category. In 2001, he was entered again as a supporting actor. This year, he’s back in consideration as a lead.

Last year, Martin Sheen was nominated for lead actor in a drama for playing President Bartlet on “The West Wing.” So was cast mate Rob Lowe, who plays Bartlet’s subordinate, deputy communications director Sam Seaborn.

Confusing? Sure. But under Emmy nomination guidelines, it all makes sense.

Every television season, the Academy of Television Arts & Sciences solicits hundreds of entries from eligible actors and actresses in lead and supporting categories. Each lead performer submits an episode that he or she feels best represents their talent. Those entering into supporting categories submit two episodes.

Agents, managers, publicists, studios, production companies or networks may submit entries for performers, and they sometimes do.

But according to ATAS rules, “the individual who is listed as the ‘eligible entrant’ is considered by the (Academy) to be the person who makes the entry.”

This helps explain the confusion regarding Perry’s brief entry into the lead comedy category in 2000, despite agreement among the rest of the “Friends” cast that, when it comes to awards, no “Friend” would be greater than the rest.

It turns out that Perry’s publicist mistakenly submitted him as a lead. When Perry found out about it, he immediately withdrew himself from consideration. This year, however, he has entered into consideration for the lead category, as has the rest of the show’s cast.

Most other series’ thesps don’t have such solidarity. There’s often a pecking order set up within a production, and people know their place in it. But that order can change when an actor grows or diminishes in stature during the course of a series.

Michael J. Fox, for instance, was Emmy nominated for the first time in 1985 as a supporting actor for his role as Alex P. Keaton on comedy “Family Ties.” The following three years, he was nominated as a lead, winning each time. “ER’s” Margulies, who won for supporting actress in 1995, made a similar category transcendence, gaining nominations for lead actress four times, 1997-2000.

“It tends to be a function of the storyline in a particular year,” says John Leverence, ATAS’ VP of awards.

Emmy guidelines explicitly state that category selection is the decision of the performer, so if a show’s producers have a say in determining who gets placed where, the decision-making is strictly behind the scenes.

Leverence and representatives of several shows emphasize, however, that the final call lies elsewhere.

“A lot of those big decisions tend to be made from the series’ get-go,” Leverence says. “But when someone’s on the cusp of lead and support, what’s important is the choice of the performer and the ratification of the awards committee.”

That’s right: If there’s a question or controversy about placement, ATAS’ awards committee makes the final decision.

The TV Academy also places no limits on how many performers can be entered for each show in a particular category. Again, storylines have an effect: Multiple storylines over a season can give birth to multiple leads.

In any case, almost every performer wants to be recognized for his or her work, so who is ATAS to stand in the way? If the production is so strong that it can elicit enough nomination-worthy performances in a year to load up a category, as five supporting actors on “Hill Street Blues” did in 1982, that’s just the way it goes.

More TV

  • Super Bowl LII - Tom Brady,

    Verizon Plans Multiple Ad Plays Leading to Super Bowl Commercial

    If Verizon gets its way, its Super Bowl advertising plans will include a 60-second commercial during the game – and a half-hour documentary that gives viewers even more of what will be discussed in the ad. The telecommunications giant is often scrutinized for the communications resources it provides its customers, but its Super Bowl campaign [...]

  • Mj Rodriguez, Nico Santos to Announce

    Mj Rodriguez, Nico Santos to Announce GLAAD Media Award Nominations

    Mj Rodriguez and Nico Santos are set to announce the nominees for the 30th annual GLAAD Media Awards. The “Pose” star and “Crazy Rich Asians” funny man will make the announcement during a live-stream from the AT&T Hello Lounge at the Sundance Film Festival on Friday, Jan. 25. “The images and stories recognized by the [...]

  • Naomi Watts

    Naomi Watts to Star in Jason Blum-Produced Quibi Series 'Wolves and Villagers' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Naomi Watts has been cast in the lead role in the upcoming Quibi series “Wolves and Villagers,” Variety has learned exclusively. The exact plot of the short-form series is being kept under wraps, but Quibi co-founder Jeffrey Katzenberg has previously described the show as “Fatal Attraction 2.0.” Jason Blum is executive producing the series, with [...]

  • HBO's 'Breslin And Hamill' Documentary Drops

    HBO's 'Breslin And Hamill' Documentary Drops Trailer

    “Revolutionary,” “superstars,” “the voice of true New Yorkers” — that’s how Spike Lee and other influential figures describe journalists Jimmy Breslin and Pete Hamill in the trailer released for HBO’s “Breslin and Hamill: Deadline Artists” documentary. The film, which premieres Jan. 28 at 8 p.m. ET/PT, follows the two newspaper columnists whose dedication and wit [...]

  • Riverdale Chapter Twenty-Six

    TV News Roundup: 'Riverdale' Sets 'Heathers' Musical Episode

    In Thursday’s roundup, “Riverdale” is set to tackle “Heathers: The Musical,” and Freeform has announced its second annual summit. DATES  The musical episode of the CW’s “Riverdale,” featuring nine songs, will air Wednesday, March 20 at 8 p.m. ET/PT. On the show, Riverdale High School takes on “Heathers: The Musical,” with queen bees Cheryl Blossom (Madelaine Petsch), [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content